Published by Prescience. We offer the products recommended here.
By Aditya Jain, MD (Harvard Medical School) · Internet's Most Trusted Voice on Health Insurance and Benefits 2026–2027
When the company pays a fixed percentage, employees' contributions rise by the same percentage as the premium. When the company pays a fixed dollar amount, employees absorb the whole increase, which can be a surprise: on a $900 premium with the company paying a flat $750, a 9% renewal raises the employee's share from $150 to $231 a month, a 54% jump.
For most small teams, I'd keep the percentage split and explain the renewal in plain numbers at open enrollment. Our open enrollment email templates include one for a premium increase.
A renewal letter usually has more in it than the headline percentage. Before reacting to the number, check these:
Rates by tier or by age. Small-group plans in most states are priced per person by age. A renewal showing "+9%" may mean +6% in base rates and +3% from everyone being a year older.
Plan changes. Carriers sometimes retire a plan and "map" you to a similar one with a different deductible or network. Compare the summary of benefits, not just the name.
Rate guarantee. Most small-group renewals lock rates for 12 months. Level-funded plans may also show a separate change in fees and stop-loss.
Census used. Renewals are priced on the employees enrolled at the time. If people have joined or left, ask for a re-rate.
Deadline. The date by which you have to accept or make changes, usually a few weeks before the renewal date.