Published by Prescience. We offer the products recommended here.
An ICHRA lets the employer choose its allowance, while employees choose qualifying individual coverage. Platform charges are separate. Thatch’s direct Standard pricing lists $45 per enrolled employee monthly plus a $50 monthly compliance charge for employers with 1–49 eligible employees. That published price is a vendor-specific fee, not evidence of an industry margin or a typical ICHRA cost.
ICHRA can work across ages and family types when allowances are sufficient and local coverage fits. It may also simplify purchasing for a dispersed workforce. Conversely, an inadequate allowance or missing provider can make it a poor fit for an employee of any age. I would compare actual household outcomes rather than treating young workers as automatic winners and older workers as automatic losers.
When ICHRA is a fair choice, and when it isn't (Your team)
Mostly under 35, single: ICHRA is a reasonable fit if… Your local marketplace has several insurers and broad plans · Look elsewhere if… Your area has one or two insurers with narrow HMOs
Spread across many states: ICHRA is a reasonable fit if… No group carrier has a usable network everywhere you hire · Look elsewhere if… A national PPO covers where your people live
Several parents and older staff: ICHRA is a reasonable fit if… You fund age-scaled and family allowances generously · Look elsewhere if… The budget only stretches to a flat single allowance
Lower-wage staff: ICHRA is a reasonable fit if… The allowance is clearly larger than the subsidy they'd lose · Look elsewhere if… An "affordable" offer would wipe out their tax credits
Recruiting senior hires: ICHRA is a reasonable fit if… Candidates already buy their own coverage · Look elsewhere if… Candidates compare you with big-company PPO plans
ICHRA isn't a scam, but some of the ways it's sold are misleading. Watch for these:
"Employees get more choice and better coverage for less." More choice, yes. Better coverage for less only holds if the allowance is generous and the local market is healthy. Ask to see actual plan prices for your oldest employee and your largest family.
Savings shown against your current group renewal only. The employer saves; the comparison rarely shows what employees now pay out of pocket.
No mention of the premium tax credit rules. If the vendor can't explain affordability, they haven't modeled your lower-income staff.
Allowances that don't move with premiums. If premiums rise 26% and the allowance rises 3%, your team just took a pay cut.
Fees quoted per enrolled employee without the minimums. Read the pricing page for platform fees, minimums and what large-employer compliance costs.
Price your three hardest cases. Your oldest employee, your largest family and your lowest-paid employee. Get real marketplace quotes for each in their ZIP code.
Compare total cost to each person. Annual premium gap plus expected cost sharing, or the out-of-pocket maximum for a high-use scenario, against what they pay on your group plan today.
Check networks. Make sure the hospital and doctors your team actually uses are in at least one plan at each price point.
Model the tax credit. For anyone who might qualify for subsidies, compare the allowance with the credit they'd lose.
Decide who helps employees. Someone has to answer "is this doctor in network?" and "why was this denied?" Ask whether the platform does that or only reimburses.
I want a benefits proposal to say who helps after the plan is selected. Ask who checks provider participation, helps with enrollment errors and explains how to appeal a denied claim. The individual insurer still makes coverage decisions under its contract; an HRA administrator cannot promise approval. A named support channel and an escalation procedure make the practical responsibility clear without assuming employees must manage everything alone.
If you want to go deeper on the switch itself, read Should we switch from a group plan to ICHRA? and Why are insurers pushing ICHRA?