Published by Prescience. We offer the products recommended here.
How an ICHRA compares with a Prescience group plan ()
What employees get: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) An allowance to buy an individual plan · Prescience group plan One company plan with an effective $0 deductible and simple copays
Employer cost: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) Allowance per class, plus platform fees · Prescience group plan One monthly cost set in your quote, $0 admin fees
Platform or admin fees: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) Prescience Choice: $20 per enrolled employee/month; other vendors vary · Prescience group plan $0
Exposure to individual-market prices: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) Individual premiums determine the employee shortfall · Prescience group plan Compare the group quote and annual renewal terms
Network: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) The chosen individual policy; check local providers and out-of-area care · Prescience group plan Broad national PPO network plus direct-contract providers
Deductible: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) Varies by the individual policy and eligibility for cost-sharing reductions · Prescience group plan Effective $0 deductible
Employee effort: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) Shop, enroll, submit proof, request reimbursement · Prescience group plan Enroll in the company plan; simple copays shown before a visit
Plans per company: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) Employees may select different policies · Prescience group plan Company health plan; confirm available options
Care support: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) Carrier support; Prescience Choice also includes Crystal · Prescience group plan 24/7 physician-led care navigation
Budget control: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) Hard cap per employee, set by you · Prescience group plan Fixed monthly cost set in your quote before the plan starts
Multi-state teams: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) Each employee buys locally · Prescience group plan Broad national PPO network; confirm local providers
Minimum group size: ICHRA (including Prescience Choice) None · Prescience group plan 2 employees
A fair comparison separates authorized allowance, actual reimbursements, platform fees and employee spending. I would also compare the networks, drugs and out-of-pocket limits before calling two offers equivalent. The following budget exercise intentionally uses hypothetical premiums and fees so it does not mix different survey years, ages or benefit levels and present the result as a market quote.
Illustrative only. All 25 employees enroll in self-only coverage for 12 months. Each eligible individual premium is $700 per month. The employer allowance is $600. Assume an administration charge of $30 per enrolled employee plus $50 per company monthly. The comparison group premium is an assumed $800 with the employer paying 75%. None of these inputs is a vendor price.
ICHRA annual reimbursement: 25 × $600 × 12: $180,000
Assumed annual administration: (25 × $30 + $50) × 12: $9,600
ICHRA total employer budget: $189,600
ICHRA employee premium balance: 25 × $100 × 12: $30,000
Group employer budget: 25 × $800 × 75% × 12: $180,000
Group employee premiums: 25 × $800 × 25% × 12: $60,000
In this example the ICHRA costs the employer $9,600 more while employees pay $30,000 less in premiums. That does not establish the better benefit. If the individual policies have larger member costs or exclude an essential provider, the premium comparison is incomplete. Replace every assumption with matched quotes before deciding.
Affordability is a separate calculation: The $700 selected premium in this example is not necessarily the lowest-cost silver benchmark. An ALE must evaluate its offer using the applicable ICHRA affordability rules. Run the ALE count using the prior calendar year and related entities. Do not infer compliance from a 25-person enrollment list or from the employee accepting the offer.
A fixed allowance limits the stated contribution per eligible person, but total employer spending still changes with headcount, participation, permitted age or family adjustments, and reimbursed expenses. Employees experience the difference between renewal premiums and the allowance. I would show them that difference before enrollment rather than describing the benefit only as a fixed monthly amount.
Illustrative premium renewal with a fixed $600 allowance (Scenario)
Current year: Premium $700 · Employer reimbursement $600 · Employee premium $100
Premium rises 10%: Premium $770 · Employer reimbursement $600 · Employee premium $170
Allowance also rises to $650: Premium $770 · Employer reimbursement $650 · Employee premium $120
The 10% increase is a sensitivity test, not a forecast. It increases the employee's premium balance by 70% when the allowance stays fixed. If the employer raises its allowance instead, update both the budget and affordability calculation. Compare renewal notices for the actual individual plans and verify that providers and covered drugs remain available. Employees may have to change policies even if the allowance does not change.