Published by Prescience. We offer the products recommended here.
A low premium does not tell you why the plan costs less. Compare networks, covered medicines, deductible rules and service-specific charges. KFF's 2025 small-firm single deductible average was $2,631 among workers whose plans had a general deductible, for firms with 10–199 workers. That is context, not a prediction for your group or evidence that a particular benefit will pay for itself through avoided medical care.
Fictional comparison, not actual quotes: ten single enrollees, fully employer-paid premiums. Lean plan: $600 monthly, $5,000 deductible, then 20%, $8,000 maximum. Richer plan: $780 monthly, $1,000 deductible, then 20%, $4,000 maximum. One maternal episode has $20,416 of covered in-network allowed claims in one year, all subject to these rules. Newborn and preventive claims are excluded.
Extra premium for the richer plan, 10 × $180 × 12: $21,600 a year (company)
Lean plan: $5,000 + 20% of $15,416, capped: $8,000 (employee)
Richer plan: $1,000 + 20% of $19,416, capped: $4,000 (employee)
The lean design saves the company $21,600 in premiums and costs this member $4,000 more. This example does not establish which option is best for all ten people. Run other scenarios and compare payroll contributions, access and account funding before deciding.
Cost levers, what they save and what they cost you (Lever)
Cut PEO or platform fees: What it saves The actual fee removed, less replacement services · Trade-off You may need separate payroll and HR tools
Check introductory terms: What it saves Avoid relying on an expiring discount · Trade-off Future renewals still need a sensitivity test
HDHP with employer HSA money: What it saves Actual premium difference less HSA contributions · Trade-off Employees face a higher deductible unless you fund it
Section 125 premium-only plan: What it saves Applicable income and payroll tax exclusions · Trade-off Written plan, eligibility and nondiscrimination administration
Small business tax credit: What it saves Up to 50% of employer premiums for two years · Trade-off Eligibility, wage phaseouts and SHOP rules; limited exceptions
Contribution policy: What it saves Depends on enrollment and the contribution formula · Trade-off Families pay more
Network choice: What it saves Only the saving shown in comparable quotes · Trade-off Check service areas, providers and network exceptions
Steer care to fairly priced providers: What it saves Difference in actual covered allowed prices · Trade-off Confirm clinical appropriateness, network and authorization
Compare all service fees. If a hypothetical service costs $100 per employee monthly, fifteen employees cost $18,000 annually. That is an illustration, not a PEO benchmark. Subtract the cost of any replacement payroll or HR work before calling it a saving.
Avoid teaser rates. Ask how year two is priced before you sign.
Pair a high-deductible plan with employer HSA money. A cheaper plan plus employer HSA contributions can beat a rich plan on total cost. See the worked example below.
Use tax rules. Section 125 for pre-tax employee premiums; HSAs for tax-free medical money.
Check the small business tax credit if you have fewer than 25 full-time equivalents and modest average wages.
Choose the contribution formula deliberately. Paying all employee-only premiums and half the incremental dependent cost is one option, not an industry default. Show family employees the dollar result and check affordability requirements.
Match the network to where people live. A narrow HMO is good value for a team in one metro with a strong health system, and a bad deal for a distributed team.
Compare covered prices for planned care. Ask for estimates at suitable facilities, including professional and facility charges. Do not promise savings until network status, authorization and the allowed amount are confirmed.
HSA-qualified coverage can be worth quoting, but the comparison should hold network and benefits as constant as practical. For conventional HDHPs in 2026, minimum deductibles are $1,700 self-only and $3,400 family. HSA contribution limits are $4,400 and $8,750 including employer deposits, plus the eligible age-55 catch-up. Special individual-market bronze and catastrophic rules apply separately.
Fictional annual premiums, not market quotes: $9,818 for Plan A and $8,575 for an HSA-qualified Plan B. Assume ten eligible employees, full employer premium payment, a $1,000 upfront HSA deposit per person and no additional fees.
PPO premiums, 10 × $9,818: $98,180
HSA plan premiums, 10 × $8,575: $85,750
Employer HSA deposits, 10 × $1,000: $10,000
HSA plan total: $95,750
Company saves: $2,430 a year
The saving is $2,430 under these assumptions. The HSA deposit belongs to employees even if they leave, but a $1,000 balance may not cover a large early claim. Check the actual deductible and deposit schedule. See HDHP vs. copay plan.