Modeling infectious disease: COVID-19 and beyond

9-10 March 2021 @Zoom : 17:30~20:00 (JST)・9:30~12:00(CET)

No registration required -- please contact willox@ms.u-tokyo.ac.jp for the details of the Zoom meeting

The COVID-19 pandemic has spurred an almost exponential increase in the number of papers dealing with modeling efforts aimed at describing and predicting the spread of the corona virus in various settings. Besides the sheer number of papers that appeared over the last year, dedicated to this topic, what is impressive is the wide variety of different angles from which those modeling efforts are being undertaken. To give just one example, models taking into account changes in personal behaviour (for example due to social distancing) or models that deal with lockdown strategies (and strategies for the lifting thereof) were few and far between before the current pandemic, but now feature among the most urgent modeling tasks at hand. It is clear that many of those novel modeling approaches, and many of the new mathematical techniques that have been introduced to deal with them, will still prove immensely valuable in the future, beyond the current pandemic.


This mini-symposium, jointly organized by the Pôle Santé, IJCLab, Université Paris-Saclay et IN2P3/CNRS and the Graduate School of Mathematical Sciences of the University of Tokyo in the framework of the strategic Partnerships Project (Paris Grandes Écoles Group) of the University of Tokyo, is dedicated to such novel modeling approaches in the context of COVID-19 and beyond, in the hope that it will not only give insight into the current state of the art of modeling infectious disease, but also that it will spur collaborations and interest beyond the specialized field of epidemiological modeling.

Organizers: Basile Grammaticos [Pôle Santé, IJCLab, Université Paris-Saclay et IN2P3/CNRS] & Ralph Willox [Graduate School of Mathematical Sciences]

Speakers: Mathilde Badoual (Paris), Hisashi Inaba (Tokyo), Toshikazu Kuniya (Kobe) & Gilberto Nakamura (Paris)

Schedule (Japan Standard Time・CET = JST-8:00)

Tuesday 9 March

17:30 ~ Opening remarks: Prof. Tetsuji Tokihiro [Dean of the Graduate School of Mathematical Sciences]

17:40~18:40 Hisashi Inaba [Graduate School of Mathematical Sciences, the University of Tokyo]

An age-structured epidemic model recognizing waning and boosting of immune status

In this talk, we introduce an age-structured epidemic model that recognizes waning and boosting of immune status of the host population. For some infectious diseases, as time evolves, the immunity of recovered individuals may be waining and reinfection could occur, but also their immune status could be boosted if they have contact with infective individuals. This is an important mechanism that makes the infectious disease control difficult. According to a classical malaria model by J. L. Aron, we incorporate a boosting mechanism expressed by the recovery-age into the SIRS epidemic model, where the immunity status is assumed to be determined by the recovery-age. We establish the condition for disease invasion and the existence of endemic steady states based on the basic reproduction number $R_0$. Subsequently, we determine the direction of bifurcation of endemic steady states bifurcated from the disease-free steady state, so we show that a backword bifurcation could exist under the waining and boosting of immune status.

19:00~20:00 Gilberto Nakamura [Pôle Santé, IJCLab, Université Paris-Saclay et IN2P3/CNRS]

Effective epidemic model for COVID-19 using accumulated deaths

The severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2) has infected over 100 million cases and surpassed 2 million deaths to date. The ongoing pandemic has earned these grim milestones despite the extensive machinery developed to model and curtail outbreaks following the onset of the SARS epidemic almost 20 years ago. In part because of the high prevalence of milder cases and sub-notification created an ideal scenario for the spread of the disease. In this talk we will briefly discuss the basics of epidemic models and introduce a simple model based on the number of accumulated deaths that we developed at the beginning of the pandemic. The model shares a close connection with an approximate solution of the SIR model and allowed us to estimate epidemiological parameters. In particular, we calculate the basic reproduction number for the first wave of infections in France, followed by its rapid increase after the relaxation of the lockdown indicating the start of the second wave.

Wednesday 10 March

17:30~18:30 Mathilde Badoual [Université de Paris・Pôle Santé, IJCLab, Université Paris-Saclay et IN2P3/CNRS]

When does a second wave appear in an epidemic?

We address the question of the title using a simple SIR model. We first investigate the impact of various confinement strategies. A universal feature of all our simulations is that relaxing the lockdown constraints leads to a rekindling of the epidemic. We thus seek the conditions for the second epidemic peak to be lower than the first one. From our results, the most promising strategy is that of a stepwise exit. And in fact its implementation can be quite feasible, with the major part of the population (minus the fragile groups) exiting simultaneously but obeying rigorous distancing constraints. Focusing on the COVID-19 pandemic we analyse the patterns of the current epidemic evolution in various countries. Two main effects are considered: seasonality and recruitment. The former corresponds to the variation of the infection rate with the season, corresponding essentially to a decrease during the local summer months. The latter is introduced as a way to palliate for the absence of a spatial component in the SIR model. We show that with our model it is possible to reproduce the observed patterns in several countries thanks to simple recruitment assumptions. Finally, in order to show the power of the recruitment approach, we simulate the case of the 1918 influenza epidemic reproducing successfully the, by now famous, three epidemic peaks.

18:40~19:40 Toshikazu Kuniya [Graduate School of System Informatics, Kobe University]

Evaluation of the epidemic prevention effect of non-pharmaceutical interventions for COVID-19 in Japan

In this study, we use an SEIR epidemic model to estimate the epidemic curve of COVID-19 in Japan. By fitting the model to the early data of newly reported cases from January to February 2020, we estimate the basic reproduction number Ro for COVID-19 in Japan as 2.6. Moreover, taking into account the effect of people's behavior change during the intervention period, we evaluate the epidemic prevention effect of the first state of emergency for COVID-19 in Japan, which was declared on 7 April 2020 and lifted on 25 May 2020. As a result, we conjecture that the 80% reduction of the contact rate, which was a public slogan during that period, could be successfully achieved. In addition, we discuss the effect of massive testing by using an epidemic model with quarantined classes.

19:45~20:00 Closing remarks: Basile Grammaticos & Ralph Willox


Each talk will be about 45', with about 15' of time for discussions after each talk.