Source Evaluation

One of the most important life skills we can learn in today's digital age of information is how to decipher between credible and not so credible sources, both in print and online. Many of you know ANYBODY can post ANYTHING on the Internet, and it is not difficult at all to self-publish a book now. This is why you HAVE to check both your print and online sources.

Step 1: Watch the video below.

We can't just believe anything we find on the Internet, as you can see in this video.

Step 2: Review the START method.

This source evaluation method can be used for both print and online sources.

Scope

Treatment

Authority

Reliability

Timeliness

For information on the START method, check out the video below by Kid Librarian.

Step 3: Use a Source Evaluation Rubrics

The Source Evaluation Rubrics below can help you check the credibility of your sources.

Website Evaluation Form

Website Evaluation Form

Web Evaluation Rubric.doc

Web Evaluation Rubric

Checklist for Print Evaluation

Checklist for Print Evaluation

BONUS: Complete this Self-Check to see if you can use the START method effectively.

Take a look at the websites linked below. See if you can tell which of the following websites are bogus or untrustworthy and which are authoritative.

The Sierra Club

Shmoop

Dog Island

All About Explorers

Check your answers here.