Brian Quinn, also known as just Q on the show, grew up in Staten Island. He next went to Brooklyn College and after became a firefighter. Q then resigned from his job as a firefighter to star in the show.

 James Murray, nicknamed Murr on the show also grew up in Staten Island. He went to Georgetown University and earned his bachelor's degree in English. After college he later starred on the show in 2011.

Joe Gatto grew up in Staten Island and later went to Long Island University. In 2011 he starred in the show but left in 2021. Now he is touring as a comedian in a very successful career.

Sal Vulcano grew up in Staten Island, and went to St John's University receiving a degree in finance. He started on the show in 2011 an is still currently a member, also persevering in a comedy career.