Ecosystems change over time
Changes in abiotic and biotic factors leave behind traces of evidence. Coupled with and compared to changes in the fossil record, it has been possible to link these changes in the environment, which we know as selection pressures, to changes in the abundance, distribution and types of species. It is therefore possible to see the influence that past changes in the environment have on the evolution of living things. This allows scientists to infer possible future effects of environmental change on living things.
Indigenous cave paintings
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people have lived in Australia for more than 65,000 years, and over this time have recorded and passed down the history of the land through their culture. One method of documentation used by Indigenous Australians is rock painting, the art form for displaying stories of the land from thousands of years ago. Rock art in Kakadu has been dated to show that paintings are approximately 20,000 years old, making the paintings the longest historical records kept by humans. Some examples of rock art are thought to depict extinct species of Australian animals, such as megafauna, consolidating evidence for when exactly these animals roamed the Earth.
In addition, by dating the rock paintings and analyzing the style of art, scientists and anthropologists have been able to connect significant geological events to changes in the organizations of populations. Scientists from the University of New England have shown, through dating methods, that the Wanjina period of indigenous history began 5000 years ago, rather than the previously assumed 4000 years ago. This period was the beginning of the organization of groups linked to particular territories of land. From the research, and by understanding stories told in the rock paintings, anthropologists suggest that this organization occurred as a result of sea level stabilization, which caused a loss of land in the Kimberley region.
Indigenous paintings of people and kangaroos
Examples of the three rock types
Banded iron formations
Australian canyons formed from river flows
Preserved fossils in rock formations
Fossils preserved in rocks provide a wealth of information about past ecosystems. Preserved flora and fauna can give us an idea not only of what organisms inhabited the Earth in the past, but what environmental conditions they would have needed to sustain life. Fossils are generally found in sedimentary rocks. Sedimentary rocks generally form in water as layers of sediment as it is deposited. Igneous rocks form from lava and their heat destroys biological materials. Metamorphic rocks similarly destroy fossils.
Mineralized remains such as molds and casts, petrified wood and opalized remains
Organic remains (e.g. preservation of soft and hard tissues in ice, amber, bogs and dry caves, as well as carbonized remains)
Impressions - the shape of the external organism recorded in sediment
Trace fossils, which are the remnants of organic molecules or other signature atoms associated only with life. These are also known as 'geochemical remains' and require advanced technology to detect.
Rocks are not, however, only useful as preservers of fossils, but can also provide information about past environments, and therefore what ecosystems would have thrive in them. By observing rock structure and formation, we can gain information about what natural events occurred millions of years ago.
There are three types of rock structures, sedimentary rocks, igneous rocks, and metamorphic rocks.
Sedimentary rocks: are created by deposition (placing) of material, and often have a sandy texture. These rock structures are formed when substances are moved by wind, fast-moving water, glaciers, or the sea (by erosion). They can therefore tell us about how ecosystems looked in the past based on weather patterns. For example, the formation we know as the Grand Canyon was formed by rivers, which carved the valleys we see today out of the stone. From this information, we know that the landscape did not always look that way, and millions of years ago, they dry and arid Arizona was actually a wetter environment.
Igneous rocks: are formed from lava spilling either onto land or into ocean. Presence of these rocks in stratigraphic layers will indicate a volcanic event in past ecosystem. This could show that areas which are now mountains were once active volcanoes, and provide information about how ecosystems would have looked when this was case.
Metamorphic rocks: are formed by metamorphisms; the process of changing sedimentary or igneous sediments into a new rock form by extreme heat and pressure. This changes the arrangement and composition of minerals within rocks. As these rocks are formed deep below the Earth's surface, their presence in current landforms can give us information about how the earth has changed. Mountains containing quartz or marble would have moved from below the sea. The presence of slate indicates that an area was once a river or lake.
Banded iron formations are a form of geochemical evidence found in Australia and other continents. Scientists think that Earth's atmosphere has undergone many changes, with the change from anaerobic to aerobic around 1.8-2.5 billion years ago being one of the most notable. Banded iron formations are geological formations consisting of alternating bands of iron-rich and iron-poor sediments.
In addition to the types of rocks, formation of these materials can also provide information about how landscapes and ecosystems used to look. Canyons may been eroded by rivers. Mountains may have been pushed up from the seabed. Using strati-graphic tools, geologists can begin to piece together Earth's history, and imagine how continents have moved and changed. This provides useful knowledge also for understanding evolution, and how different organisms have changed as their environments changed too.
Ice core drilling samples
Ice core drilling is a scientific technique used by scientists to analyze the compositions of past atmospheres. This method is able to provide very well-preserved information about past climates, as gases have been trapped in the ice without melting for millennia. The records are very pure, and kept distinctly separate, as the gases are not able to move once frozen. Each layer of the ice core will be formed from snowfall each season, which will trap the gases present in the atmosphere at that time. The oldest ice core record spans 800,000 years, and was drilled from Antarctica. Ice core drilling involves literally drilling into ice to take a cylindrical 'slice', like a cross-section of the ice sheet or glacier. This is done either mechanically or thermally, to obtain an ice core, which can then be analyzed.
Data obtained from ice cores may be in the form of impurities, bubbles, or the frozen water itself. Snow fall will contain mostly water, but may also contain traces of impurities from the atmosphere, such as dust, pollutants, debris from volcanic activity or fires, and salts from the ocean. The presence of such impurities allows us to understand what major events have occurred in the past to change the composition of the atmosphere. Bubbles are formed in ice cores when air between snowflakes is trapped, and act as 'time-capsules' of the atmosphere from when the layer was formed. This information has helped scientists demonstrate the large increase in the Earth's greenhouse gases since human industrialization.
Lastly, by analyzing the frozen water properties in ice cores, the age of a layer can be determined. Like all elements, hydrogen and oxygen have isotopes. About 1 in every 500 oxygen and 1 in 70 hydrogen molecules is a heavy isotope. The number of isotopes in a layer of snow will be indicative of how much water was evaporated and deposited as snow during that time period. Therefore, the number of isotopes can help determine what the temperature was during the time the snow originally fell.
By analyzing the composition of the atmosphere using ice core drilling, we can understand how temperatures have changed overtime, as well as the increase of gas molecules within different periods of history. This can help scientists to infer what the Earth would have looked like in the past, including what organisms may have thrived or become extinct due to atmospheric change.
Process of radioactive decay
Radiometric dating is a technology which is used to date geological materials, such as fossils and rocks. Dating fossils and rocks is a useful tool for understanding evolutionary relationships, as it can indicate the order of organisms' existence, and therefore define ancestry. Radiometric dating can also be used to show how the Earth has changed over thousands of years, through a technique called geochronology. Geochronology is the practice of finding the ages of sediments, and therefore allowing scientists to determine a time-scale for geological phenomena. Additionally, many organisms are preserved within rocks, so an understanding of what the Earth may have looked like in terms of flora and fauna can be established. From this, rate and methods of evolutionary change can be established. Understanding the composition and age of rocks also allows scientists to make hypotheses about other factors, such as atmospheric composition, climate, and radiation levels, at different time periods in Earth's history. By building chronology of what rocks existed when, we can place organisms within this timeline, and see how they may have changed in the past.
So how does radiometric dating work? Well, it rests on the principle of radioactive decay. Known isotopes have quantifiable rates of decay (i.e. we know how long it takes for a certain amount of an element to disappear), and using this information we can determine how old a substance is, based on how much of the original element and how much of the decay product exist. Therefore, by measuring the number of radioisotopes and their decay products in a rock layer or a fossil, we can determine the age of that rock layer, and where they fit in the geochronology of Earth. Some common radioisotopes used for radiometric dating include uranium, potassium, and carbon.
ANSTO Opal reactor
Gas concentrations over time
Ice core sample
Ice core layers
Isotopic fingerprints
Ancient air trapped in ice
Measurement of gas concentrations:
Since the 1950s, humans have been actively monitoring the atmosphere, taking regular measurements to obtain conclusive data about how our environment is changing. A number of techniques are used to achieve this.
Amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere can be determined using infrared light, as CO2 absorbs this light. This technique can be used in the original place, and simply involves exposing air to an infrared light source, and measuring how much of the light is absorbed by the air. This will give an indication of carbon dioxide concentrations within the air sampled
Samples of air can be taken in flasks to be analyzed in labs using gas chromatographs. These machines determine the concentrations of different gases by separating them out by their molecular weights, and measuring their absorbance.
We can also look at the isotopic fingerprints of atmospheric samples. We know that all processes in nature will produce a specific ratio of isotopes and so by analyzing this we can know where the gas came from. This can tell us whether it was produced in nature or in burning of fossil fuels. These isotopic ratios are determined using a mass spectrometer.
By gathering the data obtained from these techniques, humans have demonstrated that levels of greenhouse gases have significantly increased over the past 50 years. The Keeling curve is a graph which has collated all this data from an observatory in Hawaii since the 1950s, and it displays that CO2 concentrations have been rapidly rising since measuring began.
Ice cores:
The process of ice core drilling allows us to gather a lot of data about past atmospheric conditions, and therefore understand what past climates may have been like. As ice cores contain sequential data in seasonal snowfall, we can obtain an ordered picture about how climates changed from year to year.
Air bubbles are extracted from ice cores by crushing or melting the ice within a vacuum, to trap any escaping gases. These gases can then be measured, using technologies such as gas chromatography, to identify the amounts of different components. This can provide us with detailed information about how levels of CO2, methane, and nitrous oxide have changed within the last 800,000 years. By comparing this information against modern measurements taken from the 1950s forwards we can prove its reliability. This provides us with an idea of how amounts of greenhouse gases have changed in the past.
Ice cores also provide information about past temperatures, to help us understand the Earth's warming and cooling patterns. A layer in the ice core that is thick will indicate a high rate of snowfall, and therefore a cooler year. A layer that is thin, a 'melt layer' will indicate a warm year in which air temperatures were higher than usual.
Austrosaurus mckillopi fossil
Scientists analyze evidence of organisms from the past to determine if present-day organisms may have evolved from them.
Rainbow Lorikeet and a flowering gum tree
Due to Australia's long history of isolation, Australian ecosystems consist of a unique array of flora and fauna. Fossil evidence gives scientists clues to the slow, progressive changes that have taken place in Australian species over the last 30 million years since Antarctica separated from Australia. Australia's climate has alternated between warm/wet cycles and cold/dry cycles. This in turn has influenced the pattern of vegetation, which has gone from tropical rainforests with broad-leafed plants to predominantly open grassland and desert with sclerophyll plants as the dominant plant life.
The first mammals appeared on Earth around 240 mya and evolved from reptiles. The three groups, monotremes, marsupials and placental mammals, gradually evolved as branches from the common ancestor. The oldest mammals appear in Australia's fossil record around 125-110 mya. By around 110 mya, flowering plants were establishing in Australia and mammals had appeared. The mammals shared the land with dinosaurs, which consisted of Australia, Antarctica, New Zealand and South America. Eventually at 30 mya these links were severed, starting the period of isolation.
Parallel evolution of marsupials and placentals
Evolutionary tree of monotremes, marsupials and placental (eutherian) animals
Comparison of development in young in monotromes, marsupials and mammals
Evolution of early mammals
Australia has been isolated as a continent for about 40 million years, meaning that during this time populations have been able to adapt and evolve into an array of unique animals. The Australian mammal population is mostly composed of marsupials (young carried in pouch), and also includes monotremes (egg-laying mammals) and placental mammals (carry young in utero until they are able to survive outside the body). Marsupials occupy a majority of ecological niches normally filled by mammals elsewhere in the world. This demonstrates the principle of convergent evolution, how very different animals with no recent common ancestors can evolve similar traits due to exposure to similar selection pressures.
Early evidence of monotremes in Australia are found as fossils, dating back to the Early Cretaceous period (145-99 million years ago). Teinolophos trusleri was a primitive platypus, whose remains were found in flat Rocks, Victoria. The platypus family, Ornithorhynchidae, first appeared on the Australian fossil record about 25 million years ago, followed by echidnas.
Early platypus
The marsupial is thought to have arisen in North America, spreading through South America to Australia while the landmasses were still connected. The first undoubted marsupial fossils in Australia are dated back to the Oligocene era 25 million years ago, although they may have appeared as early as 65 million years ago. During the Miocene era (23-5 million years ago) the Australian climate became drier, with rainforests becoming sparser and shrub-like. During this period, marsupials diversified to suit the new ecological niches, evolving to become more similar to modern marsupials.
The first placental mammals are theorized to have arisen 120 million years ago, from marsupial ancestors. It is thought that placental mammals came to Australia during the Miocene era, during which the continent drifted closer to Indonesia, and animals (such as the dingo) were able to migrate. The oldest bat fossil in the world was found in Murgon, Queensland, and dated back to 55 million years ago.
Evolutionary tree of modern mammals
Sclerophyll forest
Sclerophyll plants are vegetation found very commonly in Australia, characterized by their hardened leaves and ability to withstand warmer temperatures. They have adapted to the harsh Australian climate by having small and thick leaves (minimizing water loss) with high amounts of lignin (prevent wilting) and a leathery coating (resist heat). Examples of Sclerophyll plants include eucalyptus, acacias, banksias, and hakeas.
Most Sclerophyllus vegetation evolved from Gondwanan forests, subtropical rainforests which populated the Gondwanan super continent as the predecessors to modern rainforests.
The wide-spread dissemination of these plants is thought to have begun during a major drought which occurred about 5000 years ago. The sclerophyll were best suited to this new environment, so began to undergo 'adaptive radiation'. It is during this time that sclerophyll changed from being a minor component of Australian flora to major species. This change is demonstrated in the fossil record of Australian flora.
A factor which contributed to the success of sclerophyll plants were incidences of fire which became more frequent during drought periods. These harsh conditions actually helped species such as eucalyptus and acacia to flourish, and diversify across the continent. It is also thought that indigenous Australians contributed to the spread of sclerophyll plants. There is evidence of burning practices, used by the indigenous to seasonally renew bushland.
Modern Australian ecosystems
If the climate in a habitat changes, the distribution and abundance of living things within that habitat also tend to change. Organisms that are better suited to the new environment survive and new species may evolve.
The distribution and abundance of present-day plants in Australia reflect three main origins:
Those already on the continent when it split from Gondwana
Those that dispersed from South-east Asia to Australia
Introduced species
The origins of animals that led to present-day fauna are:
'original residents' - those that were on the continent when it split from Gondwana (for example, frogs, reptiles, monotremes, marsupials, emus and lyrebirds)
Asian 'immigrants' that arrived when sea levels were low - 15 mya and again 40 000 - 30 000 years ago (poisonous snakes, back-fanged snakes, rats, mice and bats)
Those introduced by immigrant traders or late arrival Aboriginals - 4000 years ago (for example, dingo's)
Those introduced by European immigrants - beginning 200 years ago.
The Permian-Triassic extinction event
Period: Occurred on a large scale over a long time.
Cause:
Meteor impact events (abiotic)
Volcanism (abiotic)
Increase in methanogenic microbes (biotic)
Explanation:
This extinction event happed about 252 million years ago at the end of the Permian period. It is the most severe extinction event in the history of life on earth, causing the extinction of about 95% of marine species, and 70% of land species. One of the major theories about how this extinction occurred is that marine microbial life (Methanosarcina) evolved a new pathway by gene transfer, enabling them to turn the vast reserves of organic carbon on the sea-floor into methane. The new levels of methane gas in the atmosphere had significant impacts upon ecosystems at the time.
Bleaching of corals
Period: Occurring on a small scale over a short time.
Cause:
Increasing sea water temperatures (abiotic)
Overfishing (biotic)
Increased sedimentation from runoff (caused by humans - biotic)
Explanation:
Coral bleaching happens when corals expel the symbiotic algae-like organisms which live inside them. This is detrimental to the coral, as zoocanthellae is an endosymbiont which helps maintain coral health. It provides nutrients to coral by performing photosynthesis, as the ocean is not very nutrient rich. This provides about 0% of the coral's energy needs, and without the zooxanthellae the coral starves. In high sea temperatures (caused by global warming), the coral gets rid of the endosymbionts to their detriment, and eventually die (called bleaching). Ultimately this is a result of human activity (biotic factors).
Tree's recolonizing the Fantastic Lava Beds
Causes of change to an ecosystem are called ecological disturbances. These are events which disrupt ecosystems and change resource availabilities, forcing organisms to adapt to new conditions. Ecological disturbances can be either abiotic (storms, floods, fires, droughts) or biotic (deforestation, plagues, tunneling by other organisms, grazing patterns of organisms).
Bushfires cause ecological disturbances
Invasive species are a major cause of ecological change. These organisms insert themselves into ecological niches, displacing other organisms within the environment by out competing them. This has a cascading effect on all organisms in the ecosystem, due to disruption of the food chain. An example of an invasive species is cane toads or rabbits in Australia.
Rabbits are an invasive species in Australia
Eutrophication process
Otters control sea urchin populations
Another type of ecological disturbance is the disappearance of a keystone species. Keystone species are those that play a unique and central role in ecosystem function. When they are removed, there can be a significant change in how the ecosystem works. For example, sea otters play an important role in maintaining Pacific kelp forests. Otters eat sea urchins, which eat the kelp. When otters were removed from this ecosystem due to hunting, sea urchins were left unregulated, decimating the kelp forests, and removing homes for fish and other sea life. The removal of the otters had widespread effects on a number of organisms in the system.
For fun: Otters go to war
Ecological disturbances also occur when resources are changed. This might be adding an excess or new resource, or removing existing resources. This will shift the ecological niches. New ones might emerge, or old ones might disappear, and this changes the sizes of populations within the system. A example of this is Eutrophication. This occurs in lakes or ponds when excess amounts of phosphates are added (typically from agricultural run-off) to the ecosystem. This encourages algae to grow in excess, which eventually covers the pond, blocks off oxygen to the rest of the ecosystem, and causes all other aerobic organisms within the pond to die.
Eutrophication process summary
Giant wombat - Diprotodon optatum
There are many hypotheses put forward to account for the changes in Australia's flora and fauna. Scientists collect evidence to account for these changes. Changes in Australian ecosystems are intimately linked with the movement of continents and the subsequent effects on climate.
Australia was originally a part of the great southern continent of Gondwana. In the early Cretaceous period, Australia lay much further south than its present location. The climate was cool and wet. Conifers, cycads and dinosaurs were abundant. And yet Australia's first mammals had already appeared. They later developed into the familiar Australian mammals we know today.
Marsupial lion - Thylacoleo carnifex
Riversleigh platypus - Obdurodon dicksoni
Past Ecosystems
Inquiry question: How do selection pressures within an ecosystem influence evolutionary change?
Analyse palaeontological and geological evidence that can be used to provide evidence for past changes in ecosystems, including but not limited to:
Aboriginal rock paintings
Rock structure and formation
Ice core drilling
Investigate and analyze past and present technologies that have been used to determine evidence for past changes, for example:
Radiometric dating
Gas analysis
Analyze evidence that present-day organisms have evolved from organisms in the past by examining and interpreting a range of secondary sources to evaluate processes, claims and conclusions relating to the evolution of organisms in Australia, for example:
Small mammals
Sclerophyll plants
Investigate the reasons for changes in past ecosystems, by:
Interpreting a range of secondary source to develop an understanding of the changes in biotic and abiotic factors over short and long periods of time
Evaluating hypotheses that account for identified trends