BOOK REVIEW
BOOK REVIEW
The information and images used in this book review are intended solely to enhance the artistic expression of the writing. They are not used for defamation, commercial purposes, or any form of personal gain. Their inclusion is meant only to add depth and visual appeal to the review, respecting the spirit of the original work.
The book is a touching memoir that reflects the hardship and struggle of the author’s youthful journey. Born into an underprivileged environment, the author’s path is marked by perseverance, determination, and emotional endurance. Through raw and honest storytelling, the author paints a vivid picture of growing up with limited resources, yet an unshaken resolve to pursue a better future. His voice resonates deeply with those who have faced adversity in their formative years.
One of the most striking aspects of the book is how it portrays the challenges of schooling from a disadvantaged background. The author does not simply recount events; he beautifully captures the emotional weight of striving for education amidst poverty and lack of support. His resilience in facing these challenges becomes a source of inspiration. The schooling system, social stigma, and limited opportunities all form the backdrop to his determined journey.
The narrative takes a poignant turn as it delves into the tragedy surrounding his first love. Despite the deep emotional bond and even the birth of their child, the relationship is strained by hardship and diverging paths. The struggle to maintain a family in such circumstances is powerfully portrayed, showing the emotional toll when partners are not aligned in their dreams and priorities. The vulnerability and pain of lost love are deeply felt through the author's words.
As the author reflects on his life, he shows the complexity of relationships and the sacrifices one must make. His ex-wife, portrayed with grace and honesty, Eventually, she finds a different path for herself, in search of better opportunities. The book does not offer easy answers but rather a thoughtful reflection on love, loss, and the pursuit of purpose. Overall, it is a compelling and emotional read that leaves a lasting impact on the heart and mind.
Dear Tshogyal is a touching and thought-provoking book that reflects the life of a woman engaged in prostitution. The story takes us through her emotional journey, filled with pain, survival, and deep longing for acceptance. It presents her life not as a choice, but as a result of circumstances that left her with little to no options.
One of the key messages of the book is that not everyone is born with equal opportunities. While some enjoy the privileges of a stable home, education, and love, others are forced into difficult paths to simply survive. This imbalance is strongly felt in the life of Tshogyal, whose story is a reminder of the harsh realities many face.
The book also exposes society's harsh treatment of women who are labeled as prostitutes. It shows how quick people are to judge, without knowing the real struggles behind such a label. Society often sees the act, not the person behind it, leading to unfair treatment and deep emotional suffering.
Through Tshogyal’s story, I came to understand that no one becomes a prostitute by choice. There is always a reason—be it poverty, abuse, or abandonment—that pushes someone into that world. The book asks readers to look deeper and consider the "why" behind someone’s situation.
Even when people are given the same opportunity, not everyone would choose the same path. Tshogyal’s story makes it clear that some people are forced into choices they would never make if life had been kinder. It is a painful reality that many live silently, without support or understanding.
In the end, Dear Tshogyal is more than just a story—it is a call for empathy. It encourages readers to be less judgmental and more compassionate. The book gave me a new perspective on how society views women in prostitution and reminded me of the importance of understanding before judging.
This book offers a moving and deeply personal reflection on the sacrifices, struggles, and unyielding determination of a middle-class Bhutanese family whose income could not keep pace with the growing demands of modern life. It highlights how love, resilience, and unwavering commitment to education can help overcome even the most daunting challenges. One of the most striking examples of sacrifice is when the author’s younger brother dropped out of school so that the family could channel their limited resources into the author’s education—a gesture that forever shaped his sense of responsibility and gratitude.
A pivotal moment in the narrative comes with the untimely death of the author’s father—the family’s pillar of care, guidance, and financial stability. His father not only ensured the smooth running of the household but also nurtured the author’s dream of visiting Thimphu, the great capital of Bhutan. Losing him meant the loss of emotional comfort, moral support, and practical security, plunging the family into a period of immense struggle. This tragedy forced the author to confront the fragility of life at a young age, while also igniting a deeper determination to succeed.
The story also paints a powerful portrait of a single mother’s quiet heroism. Thrust into the role of sole provider after her husband’s passing, she carried the weight of raising her children, managing household duties, and ensuring their education, all while enduring personal grief. Her sacrifices were often silent but unwavering—her endurance forming the unspoken foundation upon which the author’s journey was built. Her strength, though not always celebrated, was the invisible force that kept the family from falling apart.
What sets this memoir apart is its touching depiction of rural life, where domestic animals were not merely companions but lifelines, helping to fulfill dreams and sustain livelihoods. Plants and natural resources became vital assets, providing food and other necessities during lean seasons, underscoring the importance of self-sufficiency in times of hardship. These details create an authentic backdrop of a household that balanced survival with aspiration.
The narrative also captures a critical transitional era in Bhutan’s history, when modernization began to seep into rural communities. While it introduced new opportunities, it also brought fresh challenges, forcing families to adapt to rapidly changing social and economic realities. This shift widened the gap between the wealthy and the poor, but the author’s journey shows how education could serve as a bridge to narrow that divide.
Education emerges as the central transformative force in the author’s life. Despite economic hardship and the lack of privilege to study without worry, he persevered, eventually earning a scholarship through sheer hard work and commitment. This accomplishment not only validated his own determination but also stood as proof that education remains the most powerful tool for breaking cycles of poverty and opening doors to a brighter future.
The book closes with reflections on the warmth and security once provided under the father’s guidance, where all needs—both physical and emotional—were met with care. After his passing, the author, as the young male of the household, stepped into adult responsibilities far earlier than expected. Among these duties was performing woola—mandatory community labor required by the gewog—which became a formative experience in discipline, service, and resilience. These trials, combined with family sacrifice and the lessons of rural life, shaped a character defined by perseverance, humility, and a deep appreciation for the value of both tradition and progress.
This book offers a vivid reflection of travel in earlier times when private vehicles were few, and most people relied on public service buses for their journeys. It captures the everyday realities and challenges faced by travelers during that period, providing an authentic glimpse into the hardships and unpredictability of road travel.
Throughout the narrative, the author’s personal experiences serve as a powerful reminder of the many complexities and struggles encountered on these routes. Political unrest, protests, and roadblocks often forced travelers to halt unexpectedly, making journeys uncertain and sometimes perilous. For instance, the author’s own experience of being stopped at Samdrup Jongkhar due to protests in Assam illustrates the widespread disruptions that were common.
The book also sheds light on the dangers travelers faced, especially when moving through the Indian plains. Incidents such as kidnappings, violent attacks, and accidents were common, creating an atmosphere of fear among drivers and passengers alike. The author recounts a frightening attack on two buses in a small town, revealing the harsh realities and risks that many Bhutanese travelers endured.
Despite these threats, the narrative highlights the courage and resilience of those who continued their journeys. Travelers and drivers displayed remarkable determination to reach their destinations, navigating through uncertainty and danger with hope and perseverance.
Kindness and solidarity also emerge as central themes. The author describes offering help to wounded individuals during violent incidents, reflecting the deep compassion and humanity that prevailed even in times of crisis. These moments of generosity stand as a testament to the strength of community spirit amidst adversity.
The book further explores how political conflicts affected everyday lives by creating divisions and fostering mistrust. However, it emphasizes the importance of not allowing political tensions to breed immediate enmity. Instead, it encourages understanding and patience, reminding readers that many conflicts arise from misunderstandings rather than true personal hostility.
Through detailed descriptions of events and emotions, the author transforms personal experiences into a broader message about endurance and hope. The book honors the strength of ordinary people who faced dangers and uncertainties with dignity and courage.
In conclusion, this book is not only a historical account of travel hardships but also a profound reflection on resilience, kindness, and empathy. It invites readers to appreciate the human spirit’s ability to overcome adversity and the vital role of compassion in bridging divides during times of political turmoil.