The Rumbles-Reid group operates at the intersection of materials and physical chemistry with an emphasis on photo-physical measurements where we are interested in charge dynamics for future applications in solar materials and photoredox catalysis. Although group members work on a variety of projects, all the projects are unified by the use of microwave spectroscopy which allows us to track charges and dipole moments with a sensitivity unachievable by most other spectroscopic techniques. In addition to microwave spectroscopy, members of the Rumbles group work in transient absorption, spectroelectrochem, time resolved photoluminescence, cyclic voltammetry, EPR, thin film deposition, and nano-particle engineering to name a few. With all the resources available at the National Renewable Energy Lab, instrument access if often not an issue making in-house comprehensive material studies standard. Read further to learn about microwave spectroscopy and what projects the group currently focuses on.
Obadiah G. Reid, et. al. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics, Vol. 50 (2017)
We use a wide variety of spectroscopic techniques to study photochemical energy conversion processes in our group, however microwave conductivity deserves special attention, as it is a unique tool in which we have world-leading expertise. Microwave conductivity is an ideal tool for anyone wishing to:
Resolve the dynamics of mobile charges in a semiconducting material with high sensitivity and nanosecond time resolution.
Measure the equilibrium conductivity and dielectric constant of a bulk material.
Study the above processes/properties in samples that are incompatible with device fabrication: solutions, powders, discontinuous films, etc.
Rapidly screen material formulations for potential photovoltaic performance.
Singlet fission (SF) has shown potential to overcome the Shockley-Queisser limit in single-junction solar cells and increase the maximum theoretical efficiency from 33% to 44%. In typical single-junction solar cells, the efficiency is limited in some part by thermalization losses. Singlet fission could circumvent this loss by generating two excitons from one high-energy photon. These excitons can either undergo charge or energy transfer at an interface to produce two charge carrier pairs.
For SF materials to be successfully incorporated into solar cell devices, not only does the SF process need to be efficient, but the subsequent triplets need to dissociate into charge carriers (or undergo energy transfer) in high yield. Organic solar cells that rely on singlet exciton dissociation have been shown to approach internal quantum efficiencies (IQE) near 100%. However, an IQE near 200% in SF materials has yet to be achieved. Triplet excitons in these materials are at approximately half the energy, are more localized, and exhibit different transport mechanisms than their singlet counterparts. Recent work has demonstrated that the driving force for exciton dissociation greatly influences charge transfer from both singlet and triplet states, and the lower energy of the triplet state requires electron acceptors with larger reduction potentials. However, it is not clear how charge transfer is affected by other qualities of SF-born triplets.
Our work is aimed at understanding charge transfer in SF materials in order to determine how triplet excitons can be selectively dissociated into charge carriers in high yields. Ultrafast transient absorption (TA) and time-resolved microwave conductivity (TRMC) are used to investigate the dynamics involved in charge transfer in crystalline thin films of a SF host sensitized with dilute concentrations of electron-acceptors.
N. Pace, et. al. Nat. Chem. 12, 63-70. (2020).
Photoinduced electron transfer (PET) between photoexcited donor and acceptor molecules has been implemented in organic photovoltaic (OPV) devices that can achieve power conversion efficiencies above 16%. This achievement has been facilitated by efforts to optimize electronic and optical properties of the acceptor-donor pairs by taking advantage of the synthetic tunability of organic molecules and polymers. Many models have been proposed to describe PET in OPV devices where molecules aggregate into bulk phases, but there is much debate about which model should be used. Intermolecular interactions are suspected to alter the Marcus behavior, and we propose the change in behavior might be understood by an aggregate-induced increase in the density of states of both the ground and excited states. The goal of the project is to determine the intersection of electron transfer behavior of isolated molecules and that of bulk semiconductors.
Marcus theory uniquely imposes an inverted regime where excess driving force leads to less efficient electron-transfer. Our group has demonstrated an optimal driving force for PET as predicted by Marcus theory in films with isolated accepting sensitizers in donating hosts. To systematically study the effects of aggregation, we aim to develop a model system with tunable driving force and aggregation from donating phthalocyanine and naphthalocyanine dyes that sensitize an accepting phenyl-C61-butyric acid methyl ester (PCBM) host. Recent work by our group has shown that TRMC is an ideal tool to observe changes in the PET as a function of the local intermolecular ordering in host polymers and changes in the photoconductance as a function of aggregation can be investigated using TRMC.
Photoredox catalysts are molecular systems that drive thermodynamically unfavorable reactions through the transfer of an excited state electron or hole. Many light harvesting organisms rely on photoredox catalysis to convert and store energy. In a photoredox catalysts, the charge separation before charge-transfer is crucial; the electron and hole separation must be long-lived for the charge-transfer to occur, and the electron-hole separation potential must be sufficiently large for the charges to undergo transfer. We believe understanding these charge distribution states are crucial in order to design new photoredox catalysts.
Using natures light harvesters as inspiration, our collaboration within the Bioinspired Light-escalated (BioLEC) Energy Research Frontier Center (EFRC) aims to engineer new artificial photoredox catalysts. A key component to synthesizing new photoredox catalysts is understanding how molecular structures affect the catalytic potential of photoredox catalysts. There is currently little known about how the charge density of the photoredox catalyst effects the photocatalytic cycle. Using time-resolved dielectric loss spectroscopy (TRDL) and other photophysical measurement techniques such as transient absorption (TA), we hope to provide useful information on how a photoredox catalysts’ electronic distribution influences its catalytic activity.
Colloidal organic nanoparticles have proven to be a promising class of photocatalyst for performing the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER) due to their dispersibility in aqueous environments, their strong absorption within the visible region, and the tunabilty of their component materials’ redox potentials. Currently, there is little understanding of how charge generation and accumulation in organic semiconductors change when these materials are formed into nanoparticles that share a high interfacial area with water, nor is it known what mechanism limits the hydrogen evolution efficiency in recent reports on organic nanoparticle photocatalysts. We use Time-Resolved Microwave Conductivity to study aqueous-soluble organic nanoparticles and bulk thin films composed of various blend ratios of the non-fullerene acceptor EH-IDTBR and conjugated polymer PTB7-Th and examine the relationship between composition, interfacial surface area, charge carrier dynamics, and photocatalytic activity. We quantitatively measure the rate of Hydrogen Evolution Reaction by nanoparticles composed of various donor:acceptor blend ratio compositions and find that the most active blend ratio displays a Hydrogen Quantum Yield of 0.83% per photon. Moreover, we find that nanoparticle photocatalytic activity corresponds directly to charge generation, and that nanoparticles have 3x more long-lived accumulated charges relative to bulk samples of the same material composition. These results suggest that, under our current reaction conditions, with approximately 3x solar flux, catalytic activity by these nanoparticles is limited by the concentration of electrons and holes in operando and not a finite number of active surface cites or the catalytic rate at the interface.