Water Plant Product
Group members: Nicolle, Sara, Simon, Jamie
How do you understand this issue in your context (school)?
We understand this issue as we are currently students at CNG that have experienced all types of weathers. We noticed the structure of our school causes it to flood through the ceilings of the classrooms, and this can lead to water damage and breakage of the roofs, which can be unsafe for students.
What were the results of the observations and interview exercises?
The bathrooms are one of the biggest problems mentioned. Since they are automatic, sometimes they tend to flush without anyone being there, wasting water. However, we identified another big problem that needs attention and decided to focus on it. Couple of students mentioned that when it rains the water tends to enter classrooms caused by the roof structure being essentially weak. They also mentioned that it is very inconvenient as they tend to get wet and feel unsafe in the walkways as there as been occcasions that part of the roof would fall.
Analyze and interact with the reality of your users (young people) in depth; go beyond the definition on the card.
Think about their lifestyle rather than generalizations.
What were the results of observations and interviews?
CNG campus is mainly open as builidngs can be far away from eachother and there are not any covered walways to connect them. This is a problem as when it rains it is very hard for students to get to their classrooms without getting wet. The other side of the problem is that when students are able to walk through covered hallways they can be in the danger of parts of the roof falling on top of them due to the water damage. This is because the drainage systems and roof structures are too weak to hold heavy rains which are common in Bogota..
Reflect on CNG's cultural, social, emotional demands
Think about the relationships between practices, people, institutions, and the ecosystem you made observations.
What were the results of the observations and interviews?
roof structure is not strong for Bogota rainy seasons
if plants receive excessive amounts of water, it can reduce oxygen in the soil which damages fine roots and renders the plant unable to take up water
the snails/insects that live in these plants can also be affected because the overflowing of water in the soil
Students can be affected as well since it can be hard to get from one class to another therefore effect their productivity at CNG.
when it rains, the structure of the school doesn't support all the rain
lots of flooding in passageways
water damage in classrooms
roof structure coming apart
the draining system on the roofs are not effective
Write down your most important findings and discuss them by making specific observations from the EXPLORE stage.
Summarize your 5 W's here
what- we would like to change the roofs and work with the drainage. We would like to do this by adding a plant that absorbs water and adding draining tubes that will collect reusable water. This will also help take some weight off the roof structure declining the probability of breakage.
who- students and facility at CNG
where- roof's walkway and classroom roofs
when- in Mr. Smith's class
why- so there wouldn't be as much flooding and water damage
Do you think your proposals are coherent and relevant? (Relevant = applicable to the context. Coherent = makes sense with what you found in DEFINE) YES
Summarize your two best ideas. Which biotechnology or aspect of biomimicry appeals to you and why? What opportunities does biotechnology offer that no other type of technology can provide?
add plants that absorb water on top of the roofs to collect the rain water so that it doesn't cause flooding and water damages. Also having a connecting tube in it to collect reusable water and take pressure off the roof.
Have large sewage system units around campus. The will lead to a more effective "stop" to large quantities of water flooding campus due to the constant flooding due to where we are located (mountain).
Synthesize your experiences as part of the prototyping process. What was the purpose of your prototype and what did you discover by making it?
The purpose of our protoype was to see what type of structure could sustain the amount of water that is collected when it rains. We also wanted to see what would succeed in our draining system and what needed to be fixed. We discovered that we had to take into consideration the weight and how effective the draining system would be in order for the prototype not to break the roof while helping prevent leakages in classrooms.
Were there any failure along the way? Which ones? Were you able to resolve any? What changes did you make following your discoveries? What new questions emerge?
Yes, there were multiple obstacles throughout the process. For example, when our first prototype, we realized the water was splashing, and there was no draining system, so the container would fill up and get heavier. The next prototype tested out the tube for the draining system by creating holes at the side of the container to pull the tubes out. Yet, it didn't work as we found out the water was not draining from the sides since the main tubing was not in the container, therefore, the tubes were not connected to anything that would allow the water to follow through. In our first prototype, we got a deeper container so the water wouldn't splash as much.
Write about your project's positive and negative impacts.
positive impacts: helps avoid water damage in classrooms, not disturb any ecosystem as it will be a plant that camouflages with the ecosystem, students will avoid unsafe situations
negative impacts: If draining system fails, it can become too heavy to be sustained on the roof. The plant can also flood which can be worse and add to the flooding and water damage on roof.
In a few words, detail the scientific feasibility of the project.
In our opinion, we think it wouldn't be so scientific feasible because too many can make the structure of the roof weak and the rain water comes down much faster then the plant has time to absorb.
The self-evaluation and evaluation processes are very valuable to understand progress and group dynamics. What do you need to change, adjust, improve?
Overall, we need to improve our final protoype since it was not successful as we expected. We need to change the structure of the tubing system because we made the hole too small for the water to drain through. We need to improve the quality and the effectiveness because the drainage system is too slow compared to the speed of the rain coming down. We also need to adjust how the prototype does not math to the structure of a plant that we would use this allows for a lot of error in our prototype compared to a final product.
What are the next steps? What and who do you need?
Our next steps are to improve our design and plan with the help of someone with a specialist not only in drainage systems but also someone who know a lot about the behavior of plants. Another step we could possibly take is making a protoype with an actual plant to see if it would be feasible.
Include a powerful and attractive summary of the project.
Sometimes less is more. Quality information is greater than quantity of. What can you share quickly and concisely to make anyone understand your project?
Students are unsafe when it rains at CNG. As a group we took on an ongoing problem at CNG that we have experienced firsthand and we were able to conduct interviews to get further perspectives on the matter. The problem is that the heavy rain in Bogota can not be held by the CNG structure of the school causing flooding and water damages in classrooms. Therefore, we decided to create and design a product that could solve this problem by also gathering the rain water to be reused. Specifically using the structure of a plant that absorbs water as our inspiration. Adding a draining system, that would take off the pressure of the accumulating weight of the water on the roof. Our final aim is for CNG students and faculty not to be afraid to walk through the passageways next time it rains at CNG. Safety is cool.