Water Sustainability Project
Group members: Maya, Daniela, Daniella
How do you understand this issue in your context (school)?
CNG has problems with wasting water in bathrooms (sinks, toilets)
There are also problems with excess water when it rains (flooding, waterfalls)
What were the results of the observations and interview exercises?
Students are aware of many varied problems with water at CNG
Water is wasted in science classes, non-automatic faucets
It is hard to walk from one place to the other when it rains
Excessive rains have caused some classrooms to flood, destroying some materials
Too much water can drown plants on campus
Sensors in the bathroom can lead to unnecessary flushing, wasting water
Student's did not know where water at school came from, which can be important to be conscientious about water usage
School could do something about it, but they do not prioritize
Could be dangerous
Architecture is not built well (there are leaks, ceiling crashing)
Better drainage systems
Analyze and interact with the reality your users (young people) in depth; go beyond the definition on the card.
Think about their lifestyle rather than generalizations.
What were the results of observations and interviews?
The users recognized the problems
They would rather have hand levers in things like sinks and toilets rather than an automatic sensor
This would fit in with their lifestyles effectively as it would require no major changes at all
Would be more convenient for their lifestyles and save water
Their lifestyles are disrupted by inefficient water usage
When it rains
Classrooms flood, students cannot learn there
Students and teachers get wet when going from place to place
Getting wet can lead to sickness
As getting wet is inconvenient and uncomfortable, people go long ways to avoid this, which can makes students late to class
Reflect on CNG's cultural, social, emotional demands
Think about the relationships between practices, people, institutions, and the ecosystem you made observations.
What were the results of the observations and interviews?
We observed many types of relationships between students and the ecosystem
They interact with water when it is raining outside, in the bathrooms, and with the water fountains
One of the "demands" of CNG is to not have many tardies or absences
Rain can make someone late as they have to take a longer path to avoid getting wet
Rain can also contribute to absences as getting wet in the cold can lead to sickness
More/better architecture can help prevent this
Write down your most important findings and discuss them by making specific observations from the EXPLORE stage.
Better drainage systems are necessary.
Water drainage is poor at certain places at CNG.
Causes inconvenience for users (teachers, students, staff).
Classrooms & walkways get flooded.
Rain spouts above counselor offices were extended although they still land on walkway of students when raining.
Students are forced to get wet when going from one class to another or when school ends.
Admin have the ability to do something about this but haven't yet.
Students and faculty alike would want a solution to the inconvenience of getting places when it rains.
Summarize your 5 W's here
What - Being unable to get from place to place without getting wet when it is raining is a problem we would like to address
Who - Young people, high school students at CNG
Where - Places where a solution is needed the most, such as the amphi, the snack shack, the buses, and the gate
When - It could be starting in the school year of 2023-2024 to develop the system
Why - Getting wet is a major inconvenience for students when it is raining, as it is uncomfortable and/or wastes time and it is something that all people want a solution to
Do you think your proposals are coherent and relevant? (Relevant = applicable to the context. Coherent = makes sense with what you found in DEFINE)
Yes, our proposals are coherent as well as relevant, because they would apply to the context as their specific purpose is to solve the problems outlined above. Our solutions would provide a better drainage system and allow people to stay dry while it is raining when transitioning to and/or out of classes and different locations around the school. This would aleve discomfort and people would not have to waste time anymore by being slowed down by the raining or having to take a longer detour to avoid it. These are the things that we found and defined in the last section as well, so these solutions are both relevant to the context and coherent with our findings.
Summarize your two best ideas. Which biotechnology or aspect of biomimicry appeals to you and why? What opportunities does biotechnology offer that no other type of technology can provide?
In nature, there are large, flat leaves from plants that keep the ground and animals below dry, and we would be mimicking this aspect of nature in our design. Two ideas that we had that were inspired by this were a covered walkway system and an umbrella system. The covered walkway would be built somewhere that currently has no protection from water when it rains and that is a major transit area for both students, staff, and teachers, so that our design has the greatest impact in our target community. The stairs going down from the amphi meet these exact specifications, so that is likely where we would plan our new walkway. A second idea was creating an umbrella check-out system. There would be umbrella holders throughout the school where anybody could check out an umbrella with their CNG ID card and then return it at the end of the day or when they get to their destination. Three major umbrella hubs that we thought of would be the buses, the gate, and the high school office. These are the places that the largest amount of people walk through and that are hard to get to when it is raining without getting wet or taking a detour to follow a specific semi-dry path. The large, flat leaves from plants that we were inspired by served as inspiration to create some kind of useful covering for people, which is why our ideas included covered walkways and umbrellas.
Synthesize your experiences as part of the prototyping proces. What was the purpose of your prototype and what did you discover by making it?
The purpose of our prototype was to discover if our design would accomplish its objectives of reducing runoff, keeping an area dry, and redirecting water through gutters and a quebrada. We discovered that our design of combining a covered walkway and a gutter is useful and it did work very well, and that it can very likely work in real life as well. As we tried out two slightly different methods of gutters, we now know that both methods work and have provided multiple viable options for solutions.
Were there any failure along the way? Which ones? Were you able to resolve any? What changes did you make following your discoveries? What new questions emerge?
One challenge we had while building the prototype was using the materials we had to work with, including tape, wooden sticks, straws, foam, a water bottle, and hot glue. We had to figure out how to stick things, as some materials like hot glue would not adhere to the tape, and how to build a stable model that would be structurally sound. We resolved this by using trial and error and trying out several different ways of building and shaping certain things to finally reach one that we were happy with. We made changes such as waterproofing the covered walkway more, making the whole thing more structurally sound by using multiple methods of sticking things, and cut a straw so that more water would flow down into it. A question that emerged during our prototyping process was what materials would we need to build the actual structure so that the gutters are lightweight enough to stay attached, even when it rains? Also, which method of gutter would be the most optimal to build at school and which is the most effective?
Write about your project's positive and negative impacts.
The positive impacts of our project would be to cover a very popular transit point at CNG so that students, teachers, and staff stay dry and do not have to get wet or take a detour. Another positive impact would be to redirect the water, preventing flooding and this could be used to water plants. The negative impacts might be that it takes away from the visual landscape and that it costs money to build.
In a few words, detail the scientific feasibility of the project.
Our project is definitely scientifically feasable, as there are other covered walkways, quebradas where water flows to, and gutters on campus. Our design is just fusing all of these ideas and reimagining them while locating it in a location that so far does not have a solution for the rain. This is both scientifically and financially feasable, as the school has built things like the bridge right outside the main gate as well.
The self-evaluation and evaluation processes are very valuable to understand progress and group dynamics. What do you need to change, adjust, improve?
The self-evaluation process was useful for us to really reflect on how we were doing and what we needed to change. For example, it helped us define which roles we needed each group member to do and to encourage us to narrow down all the ideas that we had. It allowed us to define that Daniela was taking charge of the main building of the prototype, Daniella was in charge of writing the website, and Maya was helping with ideas and contributing to both.
What are the next steps? What and who do you need?
After this initial prototype, we would pick which method of gutter is the best and continue with a more professional prototype with materials that more accurately reflect the ones used in real life. The next steps after this prototype would just be to pitch our idea to the administration of the school, likely with the help of teachers, and develop an architectural plan to build the real model. If it gets approved, then it is in the administration's hands to go ahead with the building of it.
Include a powerful and attractive summary of the project.
Our goal was to create a solution to the way that rain impacts students and teachers at CNG, as in some places it is impossible not to get wet, and that is exactly what we did. We combined the existing partial solutions of gutters, covered walkways, and a quebrada into our final design. Our new gutter system would not only effectively cover our users from getting wet and so they do not have to go around and take a longer path, but it also redirects the water in an intentional way so that it all drains where it is supposed to.
Sometimes less is more. Quality information is greater than quantity of. What can you share quickly and concisely to make anyone understand your project?
In order for others to pursure similar water sustainability implementations, one piece of information to know is to always think about how something would work in real life and how practical it would be.