All-Americans (1)
1996 Brye Gerhardt
Scholar All-American (1)
2020 Ian Zitney
Regional All-Americans (13)
1976 Kurt Hoffman
1977 Chris Riethmiller
1984 Darren Wyville
1985 Jeff Keeley
1986 Federico Larco
1995 Brye Gerhardt
1996 Brye Gerhardt
2000 Dan Podor
2005 Patrick Coleman
2007 Zach Sukel
2009 Chris Litzler
2020 Ian Zitney
2024 Oscar DiFranco
Academic Regional All-Americans (2)
2001 Dan Sanson
2002 Tom Hanculak
All-Ohioans (41)
1972 Norm Brakeman (1st Team)
1973 Joe Burwell (1st Team)
1974 Glenn Goodrich (HM)
1975 Carl Falsgraf (1st Team), Chris Riethmiller (HM)
1976 Kurt Hoffman (1st Team), Chris Riethmiller (1st Team)
1977 Chris Riethmiller (1st Team)
1978 George Sakoske (1st Team)
1982 Ken Foley (2nd Team)
1983 Jack Schmidt (2nd Team)
1984 Darren Wyville (1st Team)
1985 Jeff Keeley (1st Team)
1986 Federico Larco (1st Team)
1989 Doug Gier (3rd Team)
1992 Casey Dustin (3rd Team)
1993 Bill Wahl (3rd Team)
1994 Steve Frappier (3rd Team)
1995 Brye Gerhardt (2nd Team)
1996 Brye Gerhardt (1st Team)
1999 Dan Podor (3rd Team)
2000 Dan Podor (1st Team), Ben Smith (3rd Team)
2002 Tom Hanculak (3rd Team)
2005 Patrick Coleman (2nd Team)
2006 Matt Preyss (3rd Team)
2007 Zach Sukel (1st Team)
2008 Vince Coleman (2nd Team)
2009 Chris Litzler (1st Team), Bobby Casarona (2nd Team)
2011 Blake Schach (2nd Team)
2012 Joey McSherry (2nd Team)
2014 Christian Keiper (2nd Team)
2015 Mac Mazzola (2nd Team)
2017 Aaron Passalacqua (2nd Team)
2018 Zach Hoover (2nd Team)
2020 Ian Zitney (1st Team), Jack Stauffer (2nd Team)
2021 Alex Cantor (2nd Team)
2024 Oscar DiFranco
2025 Eric Nemunaitis
Academic All-Ohioans (108)
1984 Lee Mighdoll
1985 Eric Arthurs, Jeff McKenna
1988 Aaron Jacobs
1989 Greg Luib, Geoffrey Owen, Stephen Trickey
1990 Bo Johns, Mike Zaretsky, Chris Reeder
1991 Matt Bifano
1995 Mike Eshelman
1996 Brye Gerhardt
1997 Mark Redding, Matt Striewing
1999 Brett Garson, Matt Hanculak
2000 Adam Kerlek, Ben Preyss
2001 Dan Sanson
2002 Adam Brule, David Bruno, Eric Hull, Tom Hanculak, Chris McCall
2004 Josiah Frey, Josh Hurtuk, Matt Olsson, Kyle Sullivan, Alex Vespoli
2005 Patrick Coleman, Justin Fung, Chad Rende, Will Vogelgesang
2006 Brian Cook
2007 Zach Frey, Ben Groneman, Scott Reighart, Cory Seeger
2008 Vince Coleman, Brendan Fung, Rush O'Connor
2009 Matt Digel, Chris Flesher, Andy Garvin
2010 Brian Binder, Jimmy Boldt, Oli Mason, Alex Kreger, Ian Appelbaum, Kyle Mansour
2011 David Kohn, Alex Hallwachs, Blake Schach, Colin Groneman
2012 Johnny Ciabotti, Rory Gilbert, Andrew Osgood, Matt Simon
2013 Tyler Bryant, Jamie Connoly, Reed Kreger
2014 Nate Diedrich, Tommy Harmat, Jacob Jaskiel, Max Maistros, Anthony Rizzo, Ben Stapulionis
2015
2016 Will Bartlett, Patrick Emery, Trevor Gravely, Karl Koenig, Niels Kristensen, Mike Weimann, William Westbrook, Matt Wynveen
2017 Mason Bartlett, Max Di Lalla, Lars Kristensen, Trevor Stevenson
2018 Jack Amendola, Zach Hoover, Steve Kruszenski, Griffin Lowe, Aaron Passalacqua, Ben Reider, Mike Vandertill
2020 Ellis Clark, Alex Fisher, Zach Lechman, Brenden Levey, JT Marting, Andy Neimeier, John Ranieri, Luke Volpe, Ian Zitney
2021 Duncan Bannerman, Lance Buescher, JC Deruytter, Adam Hamdan, Michael Maschke, Calvin Struk-Marn, Brett Vaccaro
2022 Jack Gips, Evan Johnson
2023 Andrew Brackett, Ben Cowan, Taein Kang, Kaz Kanieski, Charlie Reeder
2024 Drew Demko, Oscar DiFranco, Renner Matta
2025 Siebrand Hilbers, Ethan Johnson, Eric Nemunaitis, John Rankin
Most Valuable Tiger Players
1971 Joe Burwell
1972 Norm Brakeman
1973 Joe Burwell
1975 Carl Falsgraf
1976 Paul Sakoske
1977 Scott Cornelius
1978 George Sakoske
1979 John Cressman
1984 Tad Taft
1985 Tim Topalian
1986 Rob Thompson
1987 Thad Barry
(Scott Brewer Memorial Award)
1988 Aaron Jacobs
1989 Doug Gier
1990 Mike Zaretsky
1991 Casey Dustin
1992 Casey Dustin
1993 Bill Wahl
1994 Steve Frappier
1995 Scot Wahl
1996 Mike Heintzelman
1997 Matt Striewing
1998 Tyler Exline
1999 Matt Hanculak
2000 Ben Preyss
2001 Sam Jacobs
2002 Tom Hanculak, Andy Murschel
2003 Mike Spresser
2004 Matt Olsson
2005 Patrick Coleman
2006 Matt Preyss
2007 Zach Sukel
2008 Matt Digel
2009 Chris Flesher
2010 Kyle Mansour
2011 Colin Groneman
2012 Johnny Ciabotti
2013 Reed Kreger
2014 Andrew Passalacqua