SCHOOL NURSING IN  THE TIME OF COVID

SCHOOL NURSING in the Time of  COVID

Covid-19 was a huge challenge to school nursing.  The pandemic, and associated restrictions, accelerated innovative practice and demanded new ways of working. 

This study established the impact of pandemic restrictions on school nursing practice. It explored the benefits and challenges to school nurses' work in supporting vulnerable children, and their work with professional partners.  The study considered new ways of working which could be beneficial post-pandemic. 

Funded by the General Nursing Council England and Wales Trust, the study is a collaboration between Oxford Brookes University, the University of Birmingham and Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust. 

STUDY OVERVIEW

This mixed-methods study aimed to identify changes in school nurse practice working with children and young people during the pandemic, map new ways of working, and consider their use going forward.  

There were three stages to the study:

We sought to identify learning from the three phases of the study to inform future school nursing practice.


FUNDER INFORMATION

This research was funded by the General Nursing Council Trust for England and Wales (GNCT) 2021 grant call.

We are grateful for the generous support of the Trust which has enabled the exploration of the impact of Covid-19 pandemic related issues on the school nurse role, and collection and analysis of robust data that evidences their vital public health specialist work.


RESEARCH TEAM

Dr Sarah Bekaert RN

  

Senior Lecturer in the child nursing team. Oxford Brookes University. 


Dr Georgia Cook

Postdoctoral Research Assistant and Associate Lecturer. Oxford Brookes University. 

Dana Sammut RN

Research Associate. University of Birmingham. 


Tikki Harrold, RN, SCPHN-SN

Community Practice Teacher. Oxford Health. 

Professor Julie Taylor RN

Professor of child protection. University of Birmingham & Birmingham Women’s and Children’s Hospital NHS Foundation Trust. 


Professor Jane V. Appleton (retired)

Professor in primary and community care. Oxford Brookes University.

STEERING GROUP

Jessica Adkins

Teacher.


Ethel Rodrigues

Lead Professional Officer(Education) & Ireland, Unite the Union – the Community Practitioner and Health Visitor Association, CPHVA.


Simone Storer-Wharton

School Health Nurse, Oxford.


Sharon White, OBE

Chief Executive, School and Public Health Nurses Association, SAPHNA.


STUDY REPORT

Protecting children and young people vulnerable to harm and abuse Learning from School Nursing practices and new ways of working in the Covid-19 pandemic.

This report presents the results of this mixed methods study that has explored the benefits and challenges to school nurses’ work, and mapped innovative practices - including remote working and other novel initiatives. 

The impact of changes on school nursing practice and the best ways to work remotely, creatively and safely with vulnerable children and young people, and working alongside multi-disciplinary partners is explored. 

Recommendations are made in relation to: policy and practice in both remote and more traditional working practices; school nursing's specialist public health care role; the profile of school nursing in the public health care of children, young people and families within the multi-disciplinary team, and at a commissioning and statutory level.



PUBLICATIONS

Learning from school nursing practices and new ways of working during the Covid-19 pandemic: a qualitative study.

Bekaert, S., Sammut, D., Appleton, J.V., Taylor, J., Harrold, T. and Cook, G., 2023. British Journal of Child Health, 4(2): 71-77. 


School Nurse Perspectives of Working with Children and Young People in the United Kingdom during the COVID-19 Pandemic. An Online Survey Study

Sammut, D., Cook, G., Taylor, J., Harrold, T., Appleton, J. and Bekaert, S., 2022.. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 20(1): 481.


School nursing: New ways of working with children and young people during the Covid-19 pandemic: a scoping review. 

Cook, G., Appleton, J.V., Bekaert, S., Harrold, T., Taylor, J. and Sammut, D., 2022. Journal of Advanced Nursing. 2023;79:471–501 



V2 Pause and Reflect Evaluation Intro and Explainer.pptx

Evaluating the resource. 


Led by:


Tikki Harrold, SCPHN-SN Clinical Education Lead Oxford Health, Associate Researcher Oxford Brookes University

Dr Sarah Bekaert, RN, Snr Lecturer, Oxford Brookes University 

LATEST DEVELOPMENTS

A School Nurse in Every School: Sector Leaders call for Action 

A new report published today (20.3.24) calls for action to address the steep decline in the number of school nurses in England.  Link to the report on the SAPHNA website here.

The report is based on a round table meeting of nursing leaders, charities and government on 15th December 2023.The round table was a joint initiative by The Queen’s Nursing Institute (QNI), the College of Medicine, and the School and Public Health Nurses Association (SAPHNA), funding was provided by Sanofi. The report brings together evidence and insights about the decline in school nurse numbers since 2009, summarises the impact on the health and wellbeing of children and young people, and offers a range of solutions. 

There has been a 33% fall in the number of school nurses since 2009 across England, though this headline figure hides great variation: in some local authority areas school nursing is no longer commissioned at all. This is a clear instance of a postcode lottery with very serious consequences for families and for child health. 

While the Healthy Child Programme 5-19 offers a plan for good child health, local authorities, which have commissioned school nursing since 2012 do not have the resources to deliver on the plan. School nurses are unable to work as true public health professionals, instead being limited to predominantly concentrate all nursing work on safeguarding for the most vulnerable. 

The round table called for a range of actions to address the issues, including building national political will and encouraging Integrated Care Boards to prioritise school nursing within healthcare strategies for children and young people. Organisations such as SAPHNA and the QNI must also continue to support school nurses to raise their voice and demonstrate their value and impact on the health and wellbeing of children and young people within the system. 



Dr Crystal Oldman CBE, the QNI’s chief executive commented, “It is remarkable that we are talking about building political will to improve the health of children in this country. School nursing services have been allowed to atrophy since they were transferred to cash-starved local authorities. We urgently need to invest in school nursing services that have a proven positive impact on the physical, mental and emotional health of children and young people at a crucial time in their lives. We have a duty of care that must be enacted today.” 

Sharon White OBE, CEO at the School and Public Health Nurses Association added, “The downward trajectory of our children’s health is nothing less than horrifying. Re-emergence of Dickensian diseases such as rickets, scurvy and malnutrition, hospital admissions for teeth extractions, rises in vaping, in sexually transmitted diseases, all of this and more can be positively impacted by urgently resourcing the school nursing workforce, who, trusted and respected by parents, children and schools alike and for relatively low investment, can change this picture and restore hope and respect for our children’s futures.” Dr 

Michael Dixon OBE, the College of Medicine, who chaired the round table, welcomed the report saying: “A school nurse for every school is an ambition in the College’s Hope for the Future manifesto (2021) and this is an important step in making it happen. Participants pledged to move into action to help ensure school nursing is prioritised with investment in this highly skilled workforce.” 

School Nursing Round Table: 'A School Nurse in every school'

Royal Society of Medicine

December 2023


Oxford Brookes researchers contributed as key partner in a Round Table event to develop a strategic evidence based approach to ensuring children and young people are supported through the expertise and skills of school nurses. We were invited by Sharon White, OBE, CEO of the School and Public Health Nurses Association (SAPHNA) as a result of our partnership and findings from the Brookes-led School Nursing in the Time of Covid study.  

 

The event was hosted by SAPHNA, the College of Medicine, and the Queen’s Nursing Institute (QNI). It was chaired by Dr Michael Dixon, chair of the College of Medicine, also a QNI Fellow.  With Vice-chair, Sir Sam Everington, founding member of the Bromley by Bow Centre (an early exemplar of an integrated health and community hub), and Professor Dame Donna Kinnair, particularly known for her work as nurse assessor in the Victoria Climbie inquiry. The event culminated in a discussion and planning session with Ann Keen, nursing advisor to the Labour Party and former health minister.

 

This marks the beginning of focused work to ensure that specialist public health nursing for school aged children is recognised and mandated for 

in national policy. Potential plans include encouraging the health minister to shadow a school nurse, a ministerial visit to an example Scandinavian school health provision, mandating aspects of the Healthy Child Programme for school aged children as for Health Visiting and pre-school children, and mapping the provision of school health services across the country – including UK wide comparisons. Oxford Brookes researchers will be a key partner in building this evidence base to underpin the strategic plan.

 

The initiative started with the publication of the Royal College’s Hope for the Future manifesto two years ago in which Professor Sir Sam Everington’s, College vice-chair and QNI vice president, and Trustee Professor Dame Donna Kinnair co-authored a chapter on Health Equalities including the aim: Every school should have a school nurse who sits on the Board of that school. This was followed by Sir Sam’s presentation at the QNI 2021 conference named ‘A School Nurse in Every School’; and a similar presentation to SAPHNA’s conference in the same year. These manifestos reflect SAPHNA’s vision for school nursing set out in the publication School Nursing: creating a healthy world in which children can thrive.

SAPHNA School Nurse presentation September 2023 edit.pptx

SAPHNA conference 

12th September 2023

Delighted to present the study and resource development at the SAPHNA conference.  We made a call for teams who would be interested in piloting and evaluating the reflective resource which received a great response. Next steps evaluate, revise, and launch!

Resource Development

Two MSc Nursing students, Maisie Rawlings and Dominic Shariff, have been revisiting the qualitiative data from the study to identify practical learning that can inform a practitioner-facing resource.  The findings from this exercise highlighted learning in three areas: practice with children, young people and families; working with the multi-disciplinary team; and working in the school nursing team.  A prototype reflective resource has been developed.  This resource was taken to one of the Oxford School Nursing Teams (pictured, with the researchers) for consultation.  This event was funded by a Public Engagement in Research  Associate Dean for Research and Knowledge Exchange grant (ADRKE PER). The resource will be revised according to these suggestions and recommendations.  Next steps are to evaluate the resource with 3-4 teams across the nation.  This will be in the autumn.  The study and resource development will be presented at the September 2023 School and Public Health Nurses' Association conference. 

Please email: sbekaert@brookes.ac.uk for further details about this resource.

AWARDS

We were awarded the prize for collaboration in public engagement with research within the Faculty of Health and Life Sciences, June 2023.  This award funded the consultation event with school nurses to develop the  practitioner-facing resource underpinned by evidence from the study.

MEDIA COVERAGE

Please click blue titles for links to news items

Prevention role of school nurses under threat, study warns

Nursing Times

Public health nursing leaders and researchers are calling for investment in the workforce to ensure school nurses can continue to fulfill their prevention role while also responding to increased safeguarding cases.  Emma Baines reports.

6.4.23

Covid revealed extent of school nurse shortage

Local Government - news item

The covid pandemic revealed that more school nurses are needed to carry out vital child protection work, researchers say.  William Eichler reports. 3.5.2023

Calls for 11,000 more school nurses in UK as children's needs grow

The Guardian: Education, Schools

Survey finds exhaustion and low morale among school nurses as they face increasingly complex caseloads. Rachel Hall reports. 2.5.23

A new model for school nursing

Journal Article - Community Practitioner

During the pandemic, many school nurses brilliantly flexed their service to ensure they continued to support students. What practices have continued and how is the service looking now? Journalist Anna Scott reports.

Oxford researchers highlight urgent need for more school nurses 

News item - Jack FM

In a study by Oxford Brookes and Oxford Health, over 60% reported reduced contact with children during Covid.

More school nurses are needed to carry out vital child protection work, according to a new study.


Covid pandemic highlighted the need for more school nurses

News item - Newswise

The study surveyed school nurses working across the UK about their current working practices and experiences of working during the pandemic. Findings call for advocacy by policymakers and professional organisations to enable school nurses to lead in the evolving public health landscape. It calls for sufficient numbers of school nurses to respond to the emerging and ongoing health needs of children and young people. 


This podcast is part of the Oxford Brookes Unscripted podcast series. 

Kirsten Etheridge speaks to Dr Sarah Bekaert, Dr Georgia Cook and Tikki Harrold about why this study was important, the key findings, the impact of the study to date, and plans going forward.