One of the best resources for understanding the purpose and process of these Senior Talks is the PBL Gold Standard that has inspired the project-based learning throughout our district.
Load the complete guide to the process, which includes a breakdown of all the options available to students, by clicking here. You can also load the instructional post above or below.
Below are selected projects and presentations. Student statements of purpose come from that stage of the overall process. In some cases, students opted out of recording their live presentation, but wished to share the content of their project through the slideshow. In other cases, the final presentation is included without the script, slideshow, or other accompanying materials.
The goal has been to give students choice in topic, audience, and delivery, and to celebrate the variety of voices in the graduating class at the high school.
Note: Statements of purpose are copied over directly from the work done for them in class. In some cases, these statements have been replaced by background information or context.
"The purpose of my project is to spread the idea of what it's really to be an adult role within a school. I think it's important to spread information on what being a teacher is really like. There's always work to be done, you have to build students confidence, create trust with your students, write lesson plans, collaborate with other teachers, etc. People just think that working with kids takes common sense but the truth is that it's so much deeper than that."
Kari's final portfolio website contains much of her thoughts and insights about teaching and working with children. Below, she walks us through the portfolio, offering additional insight as she goes.
"My senior talk is a reflection of my time in Boy Scouts. I've been in scouts since first grade and it's always been a huge part of my life. I've recently made my Eagle Scout rank and need to write a speech to give at my Court of Honor. My senior talk will either be the speech directly or a version revised to meet the criteria for this assignment. I'm hoping for this speech to inspire the younger boys in the troop to stick with it and maybe even get Eagle. I hope that when people listen to my speech they understand how much I enjoyed my time in scouting, and I hope they can learn a lesson of persistence from it."
Lucas decided to use the exceptional work he'd done to earn his Eagle Scout rank as the basis for a Senior Talk. It evolved into a showcase of his experience and learning, which he collected into the website below.
"My purpose for this Ted Talk is to have the underlying theme of open mindedness and understanding.This is not a traditional Ted Talk and I will be speaking on multiple subjects such as; Going far from home for college, my family, and spirituality. All of these subjects have caused me to be as open minded as I could be and I want to talk about my journey and how being open minded can help you grow in any situation."
Liz delivered her Senior Talk live, recording it herself in order to fine-tune the results. While we wait for a copy of that presentation, enjoy the exceptional process work she has shared: the script for her talk, the slideshow, and the way these items reflect her ongoing, iterative efforts to have a true purpose in presenting.
Live Presentation: TBD
"Assumption by defention is the act of laying claim to something without proof. In our podcast we talk about blame and assumption when it comes to someone we care about, and how that can carry on to social media. Blame and anger when it comes to the topic of our podcast is very essential because our topic explains how a personal situation could have been diffused or gone in a different way that could've resolved the issue if both people were able to identify and talk about each other's faults and and how both people felt about it. "
Direct link: Senior Talk Podcast
Below is an embedded copy of this group's podcast, which was a combination of scripted elements — you'll hear those at the outset — and extemporaneous discussion.
They workshopped their podcast for weeks, recording multiple takes and using the makerspace to have practice discussions while under teacher supervision. In every step, they focused not just on their statement of purpose, but on our unit study of empathy, hoping to showcase empathetic listening in their final product.
"Many people think that playing paintball is really bad for kids or teens because it teaches them about violence. How about when kids turn on their computers or gaming consoles and start playing Call of Duty(COD). Paintball isn't violent at all like people believe it is. You are using markers that look nothing like real guns shooting little balls of paint. When you play COD you are using guns that look real, shooting real bullets at other players while blood is coming out of them. At least when people play paintball they are outside staying active unlike when you play video games sitting down in a chair all day. "
Josh Contreras & Juan Ingunza: Super Mario Bros. Speedrunning
"Speedruns have been in generations for many years. Many people always try to see who can get the fastest time in a game. There are always new records being broken in speedruns it never ends. Being the fastest at something is an easy qualification able way to measure a player's greatness, not unlike meaning a high score. Speedrunning is a way to prove your talents in the game. "
Note: This duo took inspiration from an emulative study of online speedrunning analyses, especially those by a creator named Summoning Salt. This is part of the course's focus on deconstructing what we value in order to recreate its value, instead of analyzing simply to analyze.
Darya Moein: Adopt, Don't Shop
This final Senior Talk deals with the importance of local adoption of animals, which is contrasted with so-called "puppy mills" and other pet shops.
Rashel De La Rosa: Supporting Local Businesses
"Small and also local businesses have never gotten back to the state they were before the pandemic. They have been struggling as big companies are starting to make it harder for them to stay in business. We need to support them because it also benefits us and the community when we do."
Note: Rashel built her final Senior Talk on work done for the NYS Seal of Biliteracy, which she earned earlier in the quarter. This is worth noting, because the makerspace is designed for just such a "doubling up" in work. When a student is passionate about a subject and has already created something exploring that subject, it only makes sense to deepen that work through a process like this one.
Connor McCullough: Pollution
"My purpose for this Ted Talk is to educate and teach the viewer about the types, causes, and effects of pollution, and how we can help reduce pollution and have a cleaner earth. my hope is that people will see this ted talk and be inspired to make a difference."
Victor Mejia, Juan Ayavaca, Daniel Arevalo, & Jaime Pinto: Car Safety, Shopping, and More
"[Our]" senior ted talk is very important and very valuable for various reasons there is the main idea that is trying to show my peers how the car industry works helping them out facilitating them with some knowledge that our group has about them. It's worth everyone's time to know the cons and pros about cars, safety measurements, and how to purchase a car!"
Note: This group's final product is the result of weeks of in-class discussion, which is where the true learning of universal skills and traits takes place. The focus on a shared interest allowed them to focus on sharing the space, involving each other equally, and meeting the criteria of the assignment.
Sabrina Bisio, Andrew Tyndall, Diana Vukovic, & Josh Walsh: Student Optimism, Pessimism, and Motivation
"We chose to talk about optimism vs pessimism, further to motivation vs laziness. I really wanted to work on this to focus in on my own drive to want to be the best player I can be. This goes into my training and constantly pushing myself to work and not waste time. I want to use this motivation and focus to use it for other aspects focusing on school, work and other aspects that my peers could relate to. If I can exemplify how my want to succeed and how it benefits my work ethics and passion to work it can be used for others similar life situations theoretically any aspect."
Note: The video below shows this group spreading out into the high school for interviews and a kind of "piecemeal" presentation. This is deliberate, especially in their use of the iLC space to discuss, record, and edit.
Alan Recinos: Life Lessons from Animal Crossing
This presentation covers a seminal game in the life of the student: Animal Crossing. Its purpose is to showcase how one game can influence a person's life, resonating in it long after the game itself has been outgrown.
Note that Alan presented live, recorded the presentation himself, and then opted out of showcasing that recording here. This is an excellent example of student agency and control: Students share what they wish to share, to the extent they choose, and with an audience particularly in mind.
Anthony Tardibuono: Surviving Outside of Earth
"Is it possible to survive on other planets or stars like the moon. If so, what obstacles and challenges would we need to overcome, and do we have any ideas on how to do so. What purpose do the Mars rovers serve in helping us figure out what is needed for survival?"
Brayan Posadas: Video Game Narratives
Brayan's focus on video game narratives echoes the reader-response essay we workshopped earlier in the quarter. The argument that video games can tell stories well enough to count as "literary merit" is interesting, and projects like this purport to show us how the discussion arose.
The live presentation of this was done without recording, and Brayan was comfortable sharing why: He did not want to focus on the delivery of his message, but on the message itself. Stumbles, stutters, etc., were not the goal; an interesting and engaging presentation was. Note the use of GIFs in the slideshow to highlight the points made.
Christopher Anfuso: The Skilled Trade Crisis
"The demand for trade workers in not only this country but the world has proven to be a big problem, and it's only gonna get worse. The average age for a trades worker is in the 40's, and more are retiring than coming into the field. Why do people not want to go into trades? What is a trade? What is going to happen if we run out of trade workers?"
David Paris: Thoughts on "Cancel Culture"
"I want to discuss how ideas become important. Spreading ideas is especially easy and accessible in the digital age so it is very important to understand how they spread. I can look at how people can abuse the system to make an unimportant opinion important and change the public opinion. "
Connor Lopez: "Try New Things"
"The Purpose of this ted talk is to explain the use of trying something new and what benefits it has on your body and soul. A simple talk on what benefits of new hobbies and new experiences can lead on a better life."
Hayli Sandoval & Danae Guevara: Obstacles for Students — An ENL Perspective
"I want to talk about the difficulties and obstacles of young people when attending school and how this can lead to the consequence of leaving school or not advancing further in their academic level. [We want to] go deeper into these topics and talk about them since we all have a different obstacle and a different socioeconomic situation."
This duo offered an ENL perspective on the common difficulties that young people face in high school. They also piloted a small-scale presentation, which we ran in the school's library for a select group of peers. In this way, the pressure of a large audience did not get in the way of delivering an excellent message.
Jennifer Lazo Morocho: What No One Tells You About Teenage Pregnancy
The purpose of this presentation is self-evident: to share with others an experience they will probably never experience and may never have considered so deeply and insightfully.
This was one of the most powerful presentations, not just because of the vulnerability and insight of the material, but because the speaker took command of the room. She elected to share the details through a slideshow here, not the in-person presentation, and that is her right; however we are given access to her experience, we are the better for it.
John Galli: American Reliance on Diesel
"From farm to table - can you get there without diesel? Diesel fuel and diesel trucks are heavily relied on without people knowing. The infrastructure of America relies on it heavily. People could not survive without it for very long. The topic of electric taking over just isn't valid, electric vehicles would not be able to make the power a diesel makes and could not do its job."
It is worth noting that John had his presentation cut in half by a false lockdown drill, recovering to finish at a later date. This is one of the reasons in-person presentations that have no filmed or pre-filmed aspect are going out of style: When the goal is to share student voices, we need to use the most resilient and flexible methods to do so.
Julius Walters: Commencement Address
Seniors were invited in May to write speeches for graduation, with one student selected by administration to deliver this speech after the valedictorian. This opportunity is part of the Addressing an Audience project available to all seniors in English 12.
This speech did not win, but it came in a "close second," according to the panel — and you can see why below.
Kaitlyn Leahy: COVID's Impact on Healthcare Workers
"Covid-19 has affected everyone's life in one way or another. Whether you lost someone you know or love to covid, you or someone you know getting covid, working or knowing someone who worked in health care, or you just simply living through the world wide pandemic. We all were affected. My main focus for this ted talk is to focus on the healthcare workers who struggled while we were all inside our homes quartining. How their lives were affected/ changed by this pandemic."
Madison Primavera: Food Corruption in America
"This Ted Talk idea has been in my mind since the beginning of this school year. This topic is very important to me because I feel that society needs to know what is going on around them. Now, I do not work with the government or anything so I am not claiming I know top secret information. The only information I am claiming in my presentation is the facts that I have researched online."
Moe Poley: Toxicity in Social Media
Another example of a presentation that does well enough without the live recording, which is a testament to the information and analysis within it. This one deals with a critical, ongoing question, and it avoids the obvious answers.
Nicholas Folchetti: Be Less Certain of Yourself
The goal of this presentation is to invite listeners to embrace uncertainty. The use of chocolate as an analogy builds us up to the existentially critical idea of questioning ourselves and our beliefs.
Nick opted to give his presentation without recording it, choosing instead to discuss his performance one-on-one the next day. This is part of the burden of choice and flexibility in a makerspace, and for him, that burden led to deeper philosophical work, like this presentation shows.
Rafael Rivadeneira: Sportswashing
The purpose of this presentation is to define and explore the concept of "sportswashing," or using sports to "whitewash" the negative aspects of a corporation, country, or other community.
Recording live presentations like this allows students to stop and start over while retaining the high-stakes weight of a traditional presentation. There is also an opportunity for the student to reflect on the performance more specifically through a rewatch.
Samantha Pauta: Dance and Daily Life
Sam is an example of taking the personal writing of senior year, which starts with college essays and narratives and expands into the "river" writing of the real world, and connecting it to others who are part of the "collective good" around us.
This presentation was more personal, and the student asked if the venue could be more personal, as well. With that in mind, we moved a small group to the iLC, using the space to host this Senior Talk.
Billy Carlin: How Casinos Take Your Money (and How to Combat This)
"The purpose is to educate others on the amount of research by casinos that goes into gambling, how to be a better bettor once you start, and avoiding addiction (focused on gambling, but will have generalities for any addiction)."
This student chose not to record the live presentation of the Senior Talk. The work is effective and interesting, though, and worth sharing here. His presentation in person was also one of the more polished and practiced that we saw.
Emma Rollins: Learning from Mrs. Welch
Emma opted for a five-minute presentation format, focusing herself on one of the most effective teachers she had this year: Mrs. Welch. The kind of project-based learning and standards-based grading used in our makerspace is also found in Mrs. Welch's classroom. Many artifacts, including this course one-sheet, discuss these core innovations and their evolutions.