The Intelligence War Debate
To be resolved: Do humans have an inborn general mental capacity (intelligence) that can be quantified as a meaningful number?
The Affirmative Team: Argue humans do have inborn intelligence and it can be quantified in a number
The Negative Team: Argue against the Existence and Quantification of an inborn ‘g’ and for another view of intelligence
Questions to consider:
To what extent is intelligence determined by genes? By the environment?
Nature (Affirmative): Genes play a larger role in determining intelligence
Nurture (Negative): The environment plays a larger role in determining intelligence
Are intelligence tests inherently culturally biased?
Affirmative: Intelligence tests are inherently culturally biased and therefore invalid/unreliable
Negative: Intelligence tests are not inherently culturally biased and therefore valid/reliable
Within the context of the debate each member of your team must:
Demonstrate a working knowledge of the various theories of intelligence
Demonstrate a working knowledge of the nature/nurture debate on intelligence
Demonstrate a working knowledge of the various intelligence tests
Demonstrate a working knowledge of reliability and validity in test creation and administration
Cite your sources be telling the author and date of the material
Demonstrate effective communication in a debate
"nature vs. nurture" AND intelligence
(genetics OR heritability) AND (environment OR SES) AND "cognitive ability"
"gene-environment interaction" AND (IQ OR intelligence)
heritability AND "general intelligence" AND NOT animal (Filters out animal studies if you only want human research)
epigenetics AND "cognitive development"
Core Concept: Nature (Genetics & Biology)
Genetics OR Genetic factors
Heritability OR Heredity
Innate OR Inborn
Biological determinism
Behavioral genetics
Genome OR Genotype
Core Concept: Nurture (Environment & Upbringing)
Environmental factors OR Environment
Socialization OR Cultural influence
Socioeconomic status OR SES
Malleability OR Plasticity
Upbringing OR Parenting styles
Educational intervention
Intersection & Modern Frameworks
Epigenetics
"Nature vs. nurture"
Subject Specific (Intelligence & Cognition)
Intelligence OR IQ
"General intelligence" OR "g factor"
Cognitive ability OR Cognitive development
Standardized testing OR Psychometrics
This is a prepopulated search and has a variety of articles including scholarly, news, reference, and more
This is an article to help you with background information and an overview of the nature vs nurture debate.
This is a prepopulated search of some articles JSTOR has to offer, there are many more but this is a start.
This is a prepopulated search and has a variety of articles including scholarly, news, reference, and more
Dwyer, Helen, et al. The History of Psychology. Smartbook Media Inc., 2019.
Dwyer, Helen, et al. Cognitive Development. Smartbook Media Inc., 2019.
Lilienfeld, Scott O. 50 Great Myths of Popular Psychology : Shattering Widespread Misconceptions about Human Behavior. Wiley-Blackwell, 2010.
Krapp, Kristine M. Psychologists and Their Theories for Students. Volume 1, A-K. Thomson/Gale, 2005.
*This is a 2 volume set, this is only showing Book One
Coyle, Daniel. The Talent Code : Greatness Isn’t Born. It’s Grown. Here’s How. Bantam Books, 2009.