On 15/5 we screened rough cuts of our films. This was the version that I showed. Before the screening, I explained that there were still some parts that I needed to add, and there were a couple of placeholders. Essentially, what I wanted to know was if people understood the narrative and if it was too subtle or too obvious.
I decided to record the feedback I received:
Overall, I really loved the animation I think its really well done. There's one specific moment that really stands out to me when she's looking at her hand and its a mix of hand drawn and rotoscope, I think it really lends itself to her being hyper aware of herself and the hand is almost sticking out.
I love how in the room theres a picture of the sun.
I love the animation and even without the music you could get a sense of the abstract emotions. I really got what you were trying to do, especially from your pitch.
I think you illustrated overstimulation so well and how it builds up and the release of that- I felt it the same as she did.
Can I ask about the animation, that hand bit - is that rotoscoped? Yeah. What was the rest, was that hand drawn? The only other bit that I rotoscoped was the page turning, basically anything with hands I rotoscoped. Everything else was hand drawn.
Visually I feel like you really managed to capture what those emotions are like and how it feels, and going forward to when it has sound I feel like it's really gonna wrap it all up and give that really overwhelming feeling.
It's quite exciting because we're kind of there already and we haven't even got the sound. Sound on any animation holds a lot of weight because we're looking at complete silence here, not even any film set sound so imagining what that will add is really promising. I find it difficult to respond to some of your questions because I know it and we've been talking about it so I'm not necessarily a clean set of eyes. I really like the octopus ink and the ways that those images move from one to another. You're really using the form of animation to explore that and get us from shot to shot without it just feeling like cuts. It feels like a very fluid motion which isn't always easy to achieve. I would comment on pace at the beginning but I feel like I can't until there's sound. Ending on the gravestone, whats the rationale behind this sort of way it comes to a close? I wanted to show that it was the reincarnation of the character and I thought that was kind of the best way to do it. Would you have any suggestions? I don't know yet I think I might have to have a little bit of a ponder. I might need to revisit the scenes that run up to that final one to see how we're coming to the close to not maybe leave the audience feeling like there's just death and commemoration. So it might be just viewing that sequence when it's a little bit more formalised to see how that lands.
I felt like that's okay to have there but I feel like to move to the more positive feeling, I think the gravestone needs to be out of sight.
Yeah I think you're right, maybe we need to finalise on the flower. Because a gravestone is a place you often come to remember and grieve and look back, I think a nudge towards connecting the dots a bit more with the turning into a seed and the flower growing. It might just need repositioning, where we end.
The end did leave me feeling sad, which speaks to how well you evoke emotion, even without sound.
Is there a reason you chose a daffodil specifically? I researched different flowers and what their symbolism was. Originally I planned to use a lily because of its symbolism, which I can't even remember now, but I chose a daffodil in the end because I wanted something that had stronger more explicit connotations with new life. Daffodils tend to be the first flowers to bloom in spring.
I think it would be cool to have an extreme close up of the flower at the very end.
I have a question about the orbs, is the character one of the orbs, or are they all of the orbs, what do the orbs represent? Basically in my original idea, the transition into the spiritual journey was a lot more gruesome, it had more body horror but I realised that I don't actually have the skills to animate that so I used the different colours as a transition into that state for the character. The orbs don't really represent anything specifically.
I'm really happy with the feedback. I think that everyone made valid points and I found it interesting to hear how different people received the film. I thought the first point that was made interested me the most, because having the mix of hand drawn and rotoscoped animation was a technical choice, rather than a stylistic one, however I'm glad that it lent itself to the effect I was going for. I was pleased to hear that, even without sound, my film seemed to successfully convey the feeling of a sensory overload and what that feels like. That was my biggest priority when animating and I'm glad that it paid off. After hearing people's thoughts about the ending, I'm considering changing it to not show the gravestone. The original ending would have probably been quite impactful but perhaps not in quite the right way. I don't want to leave the audience feeling too sad as I want the message to be hopeful overall. When I animate the end, I think I will not include the gravestone. This actually makes it slightly easier for me as I can just fade the black and white daffodil into the real world one without having to move it within the frame to make room for the gravestone.
I created a questionnaire so that I could have feedback about specific aspects of my film. I posted it online alongside the film hoping that people would respond to it. Unfortunately, I didn't get a lot of responses but I'm not too worried.
I found the narrative easy to follow and well developed
Yep
Yes. Very easy
I was able to interpret it in multiple different ways
I found it very warm and charming
loved the style of the animation and the emotion it conveyed
Absolutely brilliant !!!! The style was gorgeous and really smooth and cohesive - and the colours were gorgeous.
Really, really cool. I like how stylised it was and how easy it is to tell who made it. :)
I thought the sound fit the film well
complemented the animation perfectly
I liked the music and the sound design was really good
It was the best part
I felt the ending concluded the story well I wouldn't change it
The ending felt peaceful after the earlier turmoil
I liked it!
I love the ending. I like how powerful it is as it leaves you in a quiet field of contemplation.
The part where all the colourful imagery was flashing up caught my eye the most
The black and white outline that was crying and collapsed
The card reveal and the flower animation were brilliant, as well as when the colourful patches set in with all the stars and swirls and the music changed.
My favourite part was definitely the flower blooming. Even though it was so short and somewhat insignificant, I thought the animation was so smooth and beautiful.
I think the flashback scene could have been of a more typically jolly area/scene like a sunset or a beach to help push the feeling of longing to have it back in a slightly more clear way
Nothing I can think of
No I really enjoyed it
I think you should have made it more coded for the music and foley
My interpretation was it illustrates the frustration and overwhelming nature of sensory overload
To me it looks like an autistic meltdown and finally recovery
Hmmm either overstimulation or maybe a dream?
I think of it as a progression on feeling, from a high intensity, to completely numb. But I think I thought that way because that is how I have experienced it.
As previously mentioned, I put my film on Letterboxd, a film reviewing website, in order to get more feedback for it. Out of the nine ratings it got, four were 5 stars, one was 4.5, two were 4, one was 3 and one was 1 star. These were the reviews:
SUCH A GREAT SHORT FILM
BEAUTIFUL ANIMATION AND SO CREATIVE
I LOVE IT
The middle section is just so soothing to watch
it’s very impressive :)
beautifully animated!
The transitions were so nice
soooo goood, i love it
The person who rated it one star did not review it. I think hearing their thoughts could have been valuable as much of the feedback I've received hasn't been necessarily biased but it has definitely been influenced by the fact that people know me and many of them know a lot about the process and message of the film.