Light Availability
Nutrient availability
Death/grazing pressure
Phytoplankton (the marine primary producers) are the base of the marine food web. These organisms utilize light energy to convert carbon dioxide to biomass (photosynthesis!). Thus, it stands to reason that if light is not available, they are not able to synthesize biomass (in other words, make more of themselves). Besides light, organisms also need nutrients to grow. The elements an organism needs to survive are called nutrients. In the ocean, some of these nutrients are available in excess (for example, carbon) and some are less available and become limiting for growth (for example, nitrogen or phosphorus). Lastly, primary producers are food for consumers (organisms that digest food for energy, rather than photosynthesize); thus, the abundance of primary producers may be reduced by the rate at which consumers eat them. This is called grazing.
In this lesson, we will focus on nutrients - specifically their relative abundance (or stoichiometry) in cells and how marine observations of nutrients can help us understand the conditions at the base of the food web. Nutrient availability for phytoplankton influences higher levels of the food web (for example, zooplankton, fish, whales, etc.) and that's one reason why it is important to understand nutrient distributions and nutrient ratios.
Generally, nutrients are divided into macronutrients and micronutrients. Macronutrients are elements or compounds that organisms need a lot of to survive and micronutrients are only required in small amounts.
Macronutrients in the marine system are: Carbon (C), Nitrogen (N), Phosphorous (P), and Silica (Si).
Nutrients are supplied to the surface ocean by external sources such as rivers (also called allochthonous sources) or by internal recycling of nutrients (also called autochthonous sources).
Phytoplankton consume nutrients at an organism-specific ratio, on average this value is 106:16:1 (C:N:P). This means that to grow and function most phytoplankton require 106 parts carbon and 16 parts nitrogen for every 1 part phosphorus. This canonical ratio (106:16:1) for both phytoplankton biomass and dissolved nutrient pools was described by Alfred Redfield and is often called the "Redfield Ratio." Not all organisms consume nutrients at this ratio, but it is broadly observed throughout the open oceans.
This ratio, classically observed in marine seawater samples, is also predictable based on the stoichiometry that is required for photosynthesis. During photosynthesis, phytoplankton generate biomass from inorganic constituents of C, N, and P. Oxygen is produced in the process. When the reaction is reversed, respiration releases nutrients back into the water column and consumes oxygen. An idealized form of this reaction is shown below.
As you can see, the C:N:P:O2 ratio is 106:16:1:150. Because this ratio is widely observed and predictable, we can investigate the ratios of nutrients dissolved in seawater (say N:P) to hypothesize whether or not a nutrient is limiting.
Figure from Gruber and Deutsch, 2014. Panel "a" depicts the global N:P pattern with the Redfield Ratio (16:1 N:P) draw in a black line. Panels "b" and "c" show the relative effects of different nutrient processes. Photosynthesis (uptake) and Decomposition (respiration) alter nutrient concentrations along the 16:1 slope by either removing or adding nutrients, respectively. Other processes may also influence nutrient concentrations and cause nutrient ratios to fall off the 16:1 N:P trend - such as denitrification or nitrogen fixation, but the average effect of the nitrogen cycle in the global ocean tends to drive observations toward the 16:1 trend. See the section below for more on "What About When Redfield Does Not Apply?".
The availability of nutrients and light dictates when and where phytoplankton in the surface ocean can grow. This is a seasonal cycle, as light availability changes based on time of year. In a high latitude environment, the presence or absence of sea ice will also affect light availability. When light and nutrients are available, biomass will increase, this is known as a "bloom". This is accompanied by a decrease, or "drawdown" of nutrient concentration, like N and P, in the surface as they are consumed by the phytoplankton. Phytoplankton biomass is often estimated by the amount of chlorophyll in a sample: organisms that photosynthesize utilize chlorophyll to absorb energy from light, thus there is often a correlation between biomass and chlorophyll abundance.
In the Northern Gulf of Alaska, phytoplankton blooms typically occur in the spring. At the start of spring, nutrients are abundant because they accumulate over winter when organisms consume less nutrients than are delivered by physical mixing. Once enough light is available, phytoplankton quickly grow and consume the available nutrients. In summer, although light is plentiful, phytoplankton growth is usually limited because of a lack of nutrients. This depletion of nutrients occurs because the organisms have drawn down the available nutrients and nutrient resupply is lessened due to increased stratification. The presence of freshwater in the surface (due to summer river discharge) and a temperature gradient driven by heating from the sun creates a sharp contrast in density between the fresh and warm surface water and cold and salty bottom water. This layering, or stratification, prevents nutrients like N and P from being brought back up to the surface. Thus, summer productivity is very low as the nutrients have been consumed during the spring bloom. By fall, there may be smaller blooms as the water column becomes less stratified and fall storms mix the water column. During storms, nutrients stored deeper in the water column are mixed into the surface water, but there are fewer nutrients overall, which may be limiting to growth. In winter, light levels are low and phytoplankton are abundant, other organisms, like bacteria may become relatively more common. Winds pick up in the winter and resupply nutrients to the surface layer and the cycle begins anew.
Conceptual diagram of the Northern Gulf of Alaska. The expanded box depicts the changing biological community in spring, summer, fall, and winter which are responding to light (shade of blue) and nutrient availability. The supply of nutrients is influenced by the structure of the water column: a more turbulent water column supplies more nutrients to the surface (wave action indicated in each box). The thermocline, or how stratified the system may be, is represented in red. As light penetrates the water column it warms and mixing nutrients up from the bottom water in summer is unlikely. Figure created by the NGA-LTER and modified by AKDatUM.
One way oceanographers assess nutrient limitation is by investigating the nutrient ratios in seawater, if the ratio is higher than 16:1 (N:P) the system is phosphorus limited, an organism feeding in those waters would run out of phosphorus before nitrogen. If the N:P ratio is lower than 16:1, the system is nitrogen limited and an organism would run out of nitrogen first.
Another example of the utility of ratios in marine systems is in estimating the effect of respiration without multiple nutrient measurements. For example, oxygen drawdown during respiration can be used to estimate the amount of inorganic carbon produced. If 10 µmol/kg of O2 is used during respiration we can multiply that amount by the ratio of C:O2 (106:150, see respiration reaction above) to estimate the amount of inorganic carbon produced (see calculation below).
Uptake of nutrients is variable depending on distance from land, usually a result of the depth of the euphotic zone, or how deeply light can penetrate the water column. Nutrients also tend to be more abundant closer to land where river and terrestrial input is high. The amount of nutrient uptake is highly dependent on the location and the type of phytoplankton.
If nutrients are drawn down to zero, the corresponding N to P ratio is usually not detectable or it is lower than 16:1. This will result in a shallower slope when plotting N to P. Additionally, high latitude environments tend to have a stronger temperature control on phytoplankton productivity and many species will preferentially consume P, thus more P is regenerated compared to N in the water column, leading to a lower N to P ratio.
The nitrogen cycle is also very complex in marine systems and there are some processes that don't occur at the Redfield Ratio. In regions with abundant nitrate and low oxygen, denitrification may occur. This is the process of converting nitrate into gaseous nitrogen (N2 or N2O). Denitrification tends to leave the water column with a lack of N relative to P (so it would fall below the 16:1 line). Nitrogen fixation, on the other hand, is the process of converting N2 gas into bioavailable N (NH3). This process adds nitrogen relative to phosphorus and would drive water column observations above the 16:1 trendline. In low N regions the primary producing community may be dominated by organisms that can access nitrogen by nitrogen fixation; these types of oranisms are called diazatrophs.
Tyrrell, 2001; Sharp, 2001; Tyrrell, 2019, Mottl & Elderfield, 2014; Tanioka et al., 2022 (https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-1344335/v1)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/redfield-ratio
Gruber, N., Deutsch, C.A. (2014). Redfield's Evolving Legacy. Nature Geosci 7, 853-855 https://doi.org/10.1038/ngeo2308