Peer Editing Questions for College Admissions Essays
- Did the writer answer the prompt/ question?
- How does the writer capture the reader’s attention? How so? Is this technique successful? Why?
- Does the essay show, rather than tell? Provide a memorable example. Is the essay interesting? Do you want to keep reading? Why/why not?
- Is the conclusion concise? Does it nail down the message and purpose for the essay? How so? What is the message or purpose?
- Is the essay clear and focused? Does it have any unnecessary or irrelevant details, sentences, or other components? List them.
- Is the essay the correct length?
- Does the essay sound like the writer?