Group of Logic, Language and Computation @ KCL
[1 February 2010] The Group of Logic, Language and Computation (GLLC), an informal research alliance spanning the departments of Computer Science and Philosophy at King's College London, is disintegrating due to budget cuts and questionable managerial decisions that have targeted several academics for redundancy, including Dr. Anatoli Degtyarev, Dr. Jonathan Ginzburg, and Dr. Odinaldo Rodrigues at Computer Science, and Prof. Shalom Lappin and Dr. Wilfried Meyer-Viol at Philosophy---all of them highly respected researchers and successful teachers.
This site has been created by the GLLC PhD graduates of the Department of Computer Science to strongly protest against these actions and to express our support for the affected scholars. See our letter of protest below.
Some other sources of information:
- [28 Jan 2010] Post on Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog about the KCL crisis (and several follow-ups, such as this one)
- [27 Jan 2010] Statement from Shalom Lappin
- [2 Feb 2010] Message posted to the SIGdial mailing list
- [5 Feb 2010] Post at Language Log about the annihilation of computational linguistics at KCL
- Facebook group in support of KCL philosophers
- Initiative by KCL Philosophy students
- [2 Feb 2010] Article in the London Student
- [11 Feb 2010] Article on the Times Higher Education website, and readers' comments
- [16 Feb 2010] Article in The Daily Princetonian by Anthony Grafton (Henry Putnam University Professor of History)
- Blog on the new management culture at KCL by Iain Pears
- [4 Mar 2010] "Rick, Problems always occur where you least expect them!": follow-up post at the Language Log
- [23 Mar 2010] This article in the Guardian suggests KCL management is retreating as far as Philosophy is concerned. But what about CS?
- [18 May 2010] The Way Forward: A happy ending for Philosophy (see also Leiter Reports). Still, what about CS?
- [20 May 2010] Reaction by Shalom Lappin and Wilfried Meyer-Viol
- [14 May 2010] Adding insult to injury: DCS is now advertising positions for a professor and several lecturers.
- [22 June 2011] And another one (insult, that is): KCL Principal wins some sort of award for leadership
Some other letters of protest:
- Website assembling various letters of protest
- Letter of protest signed by 335 scholars, in particular philosophers and linguists
- The Future of Logic, Language and Computation at KCL, open letter signed by 243 scholars, in particular logicians and computer scientists
- Open letter by Swedish researchers in philosophy, linguistics, computer science, and logic
- Open letter of support from Norway
- Open letter by German researchers in linguistics and related fields
- Letter of protest from the Association for Logic, Language and Information (FoLLI)
- Letter of protest from the International Federation of Computational Logic (IFCoLog)
- Letter from the president of SIGdial in support of Jonathan Ginzburg
- Letter by Prof. Dafydd Gibbon (KCL Alumnus and Associate)
[sent on 1 February 2010, 4:20PM CET]
Open Letter to Prof. Andrew J.I. Jones
Head of Department
Department of Computer Science
King's College London
Copied to:
Professor Rick Trainor, Principal of King's College London
Professor Keith Hoggart, Vice-Principal (Arts & Sciences)
Mr. Chris Mottershead, Vice-Principal (Research & Innovation) and Head of School of Physical Sciences and Engineering
Dear Professor Jones,
It is with great sadness that we have heard the news regarding the planned forced redundancies in the Department of Computer Science. We are particularly upset by the fact that it appears that the Group of Logic, Language and Computation (GLLC) has been singled out to bear the brunt of these cuts. We, the PhD graduates of the GLLC of the years 2002-2007, are writing to you to express our indignation and to urge you to reconsider your actions concerning this matter.
For over a decade, the GLLC has enjoyed a stellar international reputation and it has provided us with an outstanding research and educational environment to kick-start our careers. We have found that a PhD from KCL-GLLC can open many doors. Most of us have chosen to pursue an academic career and have obtained attractive positions at top universities around the world. Others have found that the qualifications we gained during our PhD studies have prepared us equally well for rewarding jobs in the City of London. Through its graduates, the GLLC will continue to have a strong impact on academia around the globe for some time to come. No other research group at the Department of Computer Science has been able to achieve the same kind of success in terms of graduate training.
We find it deplorable that this great tradition seems set to come to a sorry end. The recently announced cuts are of course just the latest episode in a series of major upsets. First, it is incomprehensible to us how the Department managed to reach a situation where it lost Professor Michael Zakharyaschev to Birkbeck in 2005 and Professor David Makinson to the LSE in 2006, both of them scholars of the very highest distinction. Second, it clearly would have been in the interest of Computer Science to do everything in their power to keep the equally distinguished Professor Shalom Lappin, who eventually left for the Philosophy Department in 2005. The latest plans to further diminish the group will effectively finish off the very successful line of research in Logic, Language and Computation at King's. It is hard to understand how this could be part of any meaningful managerial strategy, even in the light of the current financial difficulties.
To conclude, we believe that closing down research into Logic, Language and Computation at King's is a major mistake. It will seriously harm the reputation of the College and of the departments involved for a very long time to come. As the Head of Department for Computer Science, we urge you to do your utmost to reverse these decisions.
Sincerely yours,
The PhD Graduates of the Group of Logic, Language and Computation
at the Department of Computer Science, King's College London, 2002-2007
Dr. Stefan Schlobach (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2002)
Assistant Professor
Department of Computer Science, VU University Amsterdam
Dr. Ulle Endriss (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2003)
Assistant Professor
Institute for Logic, Language and Computation, University of Amsterdam
Dr. George Metcalfe (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2004)
Assistant Professor
Mathematical Institute, University of Berne
Dr. Matthew Purver (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2004)
Lecturer
Department of Computer Science, Queen Mary, University of London
Dr. Roman Kontchakov (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2004)
Research Fellow
Department of Computer Science and Information Systems, Birkbeck College
Dr. David Gabelaia (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2005)
Research Fellow
Razmadze Mathematical Institute, Tbilisi
Dr. Christian Ebert (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2005)
Lecturer
Department of Linguistics, University of Tuebingen
Dr. Leif Arda Nielsen (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2005)
Consultant
Accenture, London
Dr. Corinna Elsenbroich (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2005)
Research Fellow
Department of Sociology, University of Surrey
Dr. Raquel Fernandez (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2006)
Research Fellow
Institute for Logic, Language and Computation, University of Amsterdam
Dr. Vladimir Aleksic (PhD, KCL-GLLC, 2006)
Statistical Arbitrage Trader
JPMorgan Chase, London
Dr. Zoran Macura (PhD KCL-GLLC, 2007)
Research Fellow
Centre for Robotics and Neural Systems, University of Plymouth
Dr. Yo Sato (PhD KCL-GLLC, 2007)
Research Fellow
Science and Technology Research Institute, University of Hertfordshire