Dr Steve Barrett of the University of Liverpool has designed and built a cloud chamber that has a number of advantages over other designs available. He built it to use as a demonstration as part of a talk on ‘Cosmic Rays’ and also to use at space-based outreach events.
Steve’s design differs from other DIY cloud chambers in that it is simple, compact and cheap. It is constructed from components that can be readily purchased for less than £50 and, unlike many other designs, does not require any dry ice as it uses thermoelectric cooling. This makes it easy for a teacher, or student, to construct and use.
Some of the background, and details of the design, components, construction, operation and images of the particle tracks that can be seen (muons, electrons, protons and alphas) are given in his flyer, (information can also be found on TES). You can follow the instructions on this page too.
Required Components
The basic components are:
A container, such as a glass jar or cylinder (100mm ∅ x 100mm tall, £2)
A source of heat, such as a mug-warming coaster (100mm ∅ x 8mm thick, £10)
A source of 'cold', such as a small refrigeration kit (120 x 100 x 60mm, £20)
Also needed are:
Sponge (90mm ∅ x 15mm thick, £1)
Alcohol (250ml of IPA, £2)
A few hand tools (screwdriver, craft knife, etc.)
Optional Extras
Non-essential but quite handy items include:
Digital thermometers with LCDs (Set of three, £7)
Felt coasters for thermal insulation (100mm ∅ x 5mm thick, £3)
LED torch for illuminating the particle tracks
Odd bits of Meccano™ or 3d-printed pieces
Total ~ £35 - 45
If you don't already have a mug warmer, sponges, IPA, thermometers, coasters, etc, lying around then they can be sourced from various online retailers such as Amazon (other suppliers are available):
USB mug warmer: www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B08X3GM37N
Peltier cooling kit: www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0C4HTD88D
Additional Peltier: www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0CBTHX2VV
Set of sponges: www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0BPDDH6QF
250ml bottle of IPA: www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B096KXJCV6
Set of thermometers: www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B074BSC1XD
Set of felt coasters: www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B09HSJ238Y
Add a Peltier module to the refrigeration kit
An off-the-shelf refrigeration kit (~ £15) will probably have only one Peltier module, as shown on the right. Two modules work better to get the temperature below –20°C.
See the Appendix of Steve's flyer for details of how he came to that conclusion.
Surrounding each Peltier module with a thermal insulator, such as a felt coaster, reduces heat leaking in from the surrounding air and so allows them to reach a slightly lower temperature.
Peltier module on heat sink and fan (a refrigeration kit)
Use a thermal paste in between the Peltier module (white square) and the heat sink to ensure the best possible heat transfer across the surfaces in contact
Peltier module surrounded by a felt coaster
A felt coaster with a square cut out of its centre can be placed over the Peltier module to provide good thermal insulation
Second Peltier module stacked onto first
Use a thermal paste in between all surfaces in contact to ensure the best possible heat transfer from the cold plate to the heat sink
Aluminium cold plate
The cold plate keeps both the Peltier modules clamped in place and provides the 'source of cold' for the cloud chamber
Make the cold plate black
Particle tracks show up better when illuminated against a black background, so if the cold plate is bare aluminium then either: (i) paint it black; (ii) apply a black sticker; or (iii) attach a black plate onto the cold plate (Figure 7).
Attach some legs to the bottom of the fan
To ensure unobstructed air flow through the fan and heat sink, lift the fan off the table-top using whatever you have available. Steve used small pieces of Meccano™ with rubber caps over the feet to avoid scratching the table.
Black plate on cold plate
A black plate provides a dark background for the particle tracks to make them easier to see
Connect the Peltier modules and fan to a power supply
For the two modules used, Steve found that a 8V/ 6A/ 50W supply was sufficient.
Having a variable-voltage bench power supply has the advantage of being able to vary the power to see the effect on the base temperature reached by the cold plate. However, a fixed-voltage power supply should be fine, providing it can supply the necessary current.
Many amateur astronomers use a 'power tank' to power telescope mounts, cameras, dew heaters, etc, and these should provide plenty of power for the Peltier modules.
If you haven't already got one, fixed-voltage power supplies are reasonably priced – for instance, a 9V/ 6A power supply can be bought for ~£10 – £15.
Place a sponge on the inside of the top of the jar
The size of the sponge is not important, but it should be enough to soak up a few ml (cc) of IPA. A circular cosmetic sponge with a diameter less than that of the jar and ~1cm thick is ideal.
If using a pickle jar, glue the sponge inside the base of the jar so that it is at the top when the jar is inverted. If using an open-ended glass cylinder then the sponge can be glued to the underside of a felt coaster and the coaster placed onto the top of the cylinder.
Pour/spray about 5ml (5cc) of IPA onto the sponge
The sponge should soak up the IPA. If it doesn't then either the sponge is too small or you have gone overboard with the IPA.
Place the jar onto the cold plate of the Peltier module
The air in the jar needs to be in good thermal contact with the cold plate to ensure that the IPA vapour gets cooled enough to condense into a liquid. If using a jar with a lid, some thermal paste between the lid and the cold plate will improve the transfer of heat, especially if the lid is not absolutely flat.
Placing the jar onto the cold plate without the lid in place makes the heat transfer more efficient. Using an open-ended glass cylinder gives the same results as using a jar without its lid.
Place the USB mug-warming coaster onto the top of the jar
This will provide heat to the top of the jar and hence the IPA-soaked sponge inside. Only a modest level of warming to about 30 – 40 °C is required, but some USB coasters get quite hot (above 50 °C). Hence you can either: (i) keep the coaster the right way up so that the heat getting through to the bottom of the coaster warms the jar; or (ii) invert the coaster but use something to separate the hot surface of the coaster from the jar. I used a felt coaster 5mm thick to do this.
If your budget doesn't stretch to a USB mug-warming coaster (~ £10) then you can try carefully placing a cup of tea onto the top of the jar. It will probably provide all the heat required, but may need replacing with a fresh cup every once in a while. I call this the "Cuppa Cloud Chamber" option. Try it at your own risk.
Plug the Peltier cooling module(s) into a suitable power supply
Plug the mug-warming coaster into a USB port
The time taken for the cloud chamber to reach the optimal conditions for observing particle tracks will depend on the amount of IPA inside the jar and the temperatures at the top and bottom of the jar. As a rough guide, I found that...
Peltier modules will cool from room temperature to –20°C in 5 minutes.
The IPA-soaked sponge will warm from room temperature to 30°C in 10 minutes.
Shine some light into the side of the jar
A simple LED torch should be enough. Illuminate the inside of the jar from the side as viewed by the observer(s) or camera. When the IPA starts condensing a mist will appear to form at the bottom of the jar as tiny droplets of IPA drizzle down onto the cold plate. This should be visible after about 5 minutes
Wait for cosmic rays
If you can't see any particle tracks then you can never be quite sure whether the right conditions have not yet been reached or whether there are not many cosmic rays or other particles from background radiation passing through your cloud chamber. One way around this dilemma is to place a radioactive source close to, or inside, the cloud chamber. That's not as dramatic as it sounds, as radioactive sources can be acquired without putting you on any government watchlists...
Many naturally occurring minerals contain uranium, thorium or potassium and contribute to background radiation throughout the world.
Some glass objects may have had a few % of uranium compounds added to give them a characteristic greenish colouration.
Tungsten welding rods may have had a few % of thorium added to improve the quality of the welds.
The radiation from any of these sources in close proximity will be more intense than the radiation from cosmic rays and so can be used to confirm whether or not the cloud chamber is working.
If you want to learn more about Steve's outreach and a demonstration of his cloud chamber, there is a great video you can find below where Steve is giving an outreach talk to the Southport U3A (SoU3A) Astronomy Group on 22 May 2024.
Cloud chamber using Peltier cooling
The design of a simple, compact, inexpensive cloud chamber is described and examples of particle tracks from cosmic rays and a radioactive sample are shown. A temperature gradient is established in the chamber through the use of a simple heater at the top and Peltier modules at the base, eliminating the need for dry ice. Using a few millilitres of isopropyl alcohol it starts to show particle tracks a few minutes after being switched on and operates for over two hours without any intervention. The cloud chamber is constructed using components that can be readily obtained at a total cost of about £40.
Barrett SD. Cloud chamber using Peltier cooling. Physics Education. 2024 Jun 12;59(4):043010.
If you are having trouble accessing this paper, use this link to a PDF version of it.