How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• ZENSEWEN 150-Pack — biggest strength: 150 unbleached, silicone-coated rounds in three real diameters (6, 8 and 10 inch), oven-safe to 450°F (232°C), flat instead of rolled — so they drop straight into bakeware without measuring, tracing or trimming.
• ZENSEWEN 150-Pack — biggest trade-off: Every sheet is round. If your air fryer basket or baking tray is square or rectangular, a round liner will leave the corners bare.
• Garneck Air Fryer Baking — biggest strength: 50 round plus 50 square liners made from paper pulp, so you get coverage for both round and square air fryer baskets, with oil-absorbing behavior built into the material.
• Garneck Air Fryer Baking — biggest trade-off: It's narrower in scope. It's built around air fryer cooking, and the paper-pulp build is a different animal from a parchment round you'd trust in a springform pan or under a cheesecake.
• Who each pick is for: ZENSEWEN for bakers, meal-preppers and anyone who wants one liner that covers cakes, freezing, steaming and air frying. Garneck for air fryer owners who want a round-and-square combo pack that catches grease.
The ZENSEWEN 150-Pack is really a "one box, many jobs" product. You get 50 sheets each of 6-inch, 8-inch and 10-inch rounds — 150 total — all precut and perfectly flat. That flatness matters more than it sounds. Anyone who has fought a roll of parchment knows the drill: it curls up at the edges, springs back on itself, and you end up creasing it just to keep it down. These rounds skip that entirely. You pull one out, drop it in, done.
The material is unbleached paper with a silicone coating, and the sheet says it holds up to 450°F (232°C) in ovens and grills without burning or curling. The non-stick coating is the headline for bakers: delicate cheesecakes and sponges are supposed to release without extra butter or grease, which means less scrubbing afterward and fewer calories added along the way. If you bake in springform pans, that release behavior is the whole point of buying liners in the first place.
The 10-inch rounds are the ones I'd point air fryer owners toward, though it depends on basket size — and this is where the honest trade-off lives. A round liner in a square basket leaves four corners uncovered. For cakes, freezing and steaming that's a non-issue. For a square air fryer basket, it's a real gap.
Buy it if: you bake, you freeze burger patties and want non-stick dividers between them, you steam food, or you want liners that work across multiple pans instead of just one appliance.
Skip it if: your air fryer basket is square or rectangular and you want full edge-to-edge coverage, or you specifically want a grease-absorbing liner rather than a non-stick barrier.
Garneck takes a different route: 100 liners total, split 50 round and 50 square. That shape split is the reason to look at it. Round and square coverage means it's meant to fit multiple types of air fryers rather than one specific pan — the product copy calls it a versatile accessory for exactly that reason. If you own a square-basket air fryer, the square liners are the ones you'll reach for.
The material is paper pulp, khaki colored, coated with silicone oil so food doesn't stick and cleanup is easier. The distinctive feature here is oil-absorbing behavior: the paper pulp is designed to pull excess oil away from food, which is a different job than simply stopping food from sticking. If you're cooking chicken wings, fries or fish fillets and you want less grease on the plate, that's the use case this product is built around.
In practical terms, the squares measure roughly 6.29 x 6.29 x 1.57 inches and the rounds about 6.48 x 6.48 x 1.57 inches — both on the smaller side, aimed at air fryer baskets and trays rather than large cake pans. You don't cut or measure anything; you place a liner on the tray or in the basket and load food on top.
Buy it if: you own an air fryer with a square or round basket, you cook greasy foods and want the liner to absorb some of that oil, and you want both shapes in one package.
Skip it if: you're baking cakes in springform pans, need a 10-inch round, or want a liner you can trust in a hot oven up to 450°F — that's not what this sheet claims.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for baking cakes and cheesecakes → ZENSEWEN 150-Pack. The silicone-coated non-stick surface and 6/8/10-inch sizes are built for springform pans and clean release.
• Best for square air fryer baskets → Garneck Air Fryer Baking. The 50 square liners cover corners that a round liner can't.
• Best for greasy foods like wings and fries → Garneck Air Fryer Baking. The paper-pulp material is designed to absorb excess oil.
• Best for oven and grill heat → ZENSEWEN 150-Pack. Rated to 450°F (232°C) without burning or curling; Garneck's sheet makes no comparable temperature claim.
• Best for size range → ZENSEWEN 150-Pack. Three diameters versus one approximate size per shape.
• Best for one-appliance simplicity → Garneck Air Fryer Baking. If the air fryer is the only thing you're lining, the round-and-square split covers your bases.
• Best for total sheet count → ZENSEWEN 150-Pack. 150 sheets versus 100.
I'd buy the ZENSEWEN 150-Pack. In my opinion, it's the more useful box for most kitchens because it isn't locked to a single appliance — it handles springform pans, air fryer baskets, pizza stones, steaming and freezing dividers, and it's rated for oven and grill heat up to 450°F. The three-size range means you're more likely to find a liner that actually fits what you're holding.
The one situation where I'd switch: if your air fryer basket is square and you cook a lot of greasy food, Garneck's square liners and oil-absorbing paper pulp are the better-matched tool. Buy ZENSEWEN for range and oven capability; buy Garneck for square air fryer coverage and grease absorption. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit — both are inexpensive enough that owning one of each isn't a crazy idea.
which air fryer has a removable divider
Neither of these is an air fryer — both are liner accessories, so neither has a removable divider. The closest thing to a "divider" here is the ZENSEWEN 150-Pack, whose flat rounds work as non-stick dividers between frozen hamburger patties or stacked portions. If you specifically need a physical divider inside an air fryer basket, you'd be looking at a different type of product.
are these parchment rounds or air fryer liners
Both, depending on which one you pick. The ZENSEWEN 150-Pack is described as precut unbleached parchment rounds in 6, 8 and 10 inch sizes — usable in springform pans, air fryers and pizza stones. The Garneck set is described as air fryer baking liners in round and square shapes, made from paper pulp with a silicone-oil coating.
can I use Garneck liners in a regular oven
The Garneck sheet describes them as air fryer baking liners made from paper pulp, and it doesn't state an oven temperature rating. The ZENSEWEN sheet, by contrast, explicitly says its rounds withstand oven and grill temperatures up to 450°F (232°C) without burning or curling. If oven baking is your main use, that stated rating is the detail I'd weigh.
do these liners stop food from sticking
Yes — both describe non-stick behavior. ZENSEWEN's rounds use a silicone coating that requires no extra butter or grease, while Garneck's liners are coated with silicone oil and also absorb excess oil from food. The difference is emphasis: ZENSEWEN is about clean release, Garneck is about clean release plus grease absorption.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: DecoPac 7 vs AGIgear Ceramic Nonstick Baking: Air Fryer, HEISENLIN Air Fryer Silicone vs GWY 3-Pack: Air Fryer, best air fryer under $150