How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Xloey Air Fryer Parchment — biggest strength: 100 square 9x11 inch liners with a perforation pattern built to let steam circulate, so you get nonstick release and almost no basket scrubbing.
• Xloey Air Fryer Parchment — biggest trade-off: It is a single-use paper product with a hard safety rule — food must cover at least two-thirds of the sheet so the paper can't touch the heating element.
• TABLETREANDS 8 — biggest strength: A rigid, nonstick aluminum round pan that holds its shape, so wet dough and heavy toppings don't sag or leak through.
• TABLETREANDS 8 — biggest trade-off: One pan, one item at a time, and it takes up real space in a small basket compared with a flat sheet of paper.
• Pick Xloey if your priority is fast cleanup and you cook flatbread, leftovers and messy proteins several times a week.
• Pick TABLETREANDS 8 if your priority is structure — a flatbread pizza, pie, or anything that needs a solid base under it.
This is a consumables product, and that's the whole point. You get 100 unbleached paper liners, each 9x11 inches and square, so they're sized for the flat basket floor of a typical air fryer rather than a round oven rack. The material is oil-resistant, waterproof, non-absorbent and rated heat-resistant up to 450°F / 232°C. The color is beige, which is what "unbleached" looks like — no chlorine bleaching step, which some cooks prefer for food-contact paper.
The feature that actually matters for air frying is the perforation pattern. The holes are arranged to speed up steam circulation inside the basket, which is the difference between crispy flatbread edges and a soggy, steamed result. Because the sheets are nonstick, food releases cleanly and keeps its shape, and the basket stays free of baked-on residue.
TABLETREANDS 8: Who It's For
TABLETREANDS 8 is the opposite philosophy: one reusable, rigid piece of hardware instead of a stack of disposables. It's a round pan made of aluminum alloy with a nonstick, scratch-resistant coating, black, measuring roughly 7.87 inches across and about an inch deep. It weighs around 4.6 ounces, so it's light enough to lift out with one hand but stiff enough to hold a shape.
The depth is the interesting part. An inch of wall means this pan can hold more than a flat disc — think a thick flatbread with wet toppings, a small deep-dish-style pizza, a pie, a frittata-style egg dish, or a batch of vegetables and shrimp that would otherwise roll around the basket. Because the coating is nonstick, food slides out and the pan is dishwasher safe, which matters if you're using it most days. The manufacturer also lists it as usable alongside a cake pan, rack, skewers or silicone mat, so it's meant to be a general oven-and-air-fryer baking accessory rather than a one-trick pizza plate.
Who should buy it: anyone chasing a crisp bottom on flatbread or pizza in an air fryer, where a bare basket lets soft dough droop through the grate or stick. Anyone who wants a reusable option instead of buying paper forever. Anyone who also bakes small cakes, cookies or pies and wants one pan that covers all of it. Who should skip it: people who mostly air fry loose, saucy or breaded items where a liner is faster, and anyone whose basket is too small for a 7.87-inch round pan to sit flat with air still moving around it.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup → Xloey Air Fryer Parchment. Toss the liner, wipe the basket, done. No soaking, no coating to protect.
• Best for structure under wet dough → TABLETREANDS 8. A rigid aluminum base holds flatbread and pizza dough flat instead of letting it sag into the grate.
• Best for high-volume cooking → Xloey Air Fryer Parchment. 100 sheets means you're not washing anything between batches; you just swap paper.
• Best for very hot cooking → Xloey Air Fryer Parchment. It's rated to 450°F / 232°C, so it stands up to the top end of most air fryer temperature ranges — provided food covers it.
• Best for small, delicate or loose items → TABLETREANDS 8. The raised edge keeps shrimp, veg and crumb-coated pieces from sliding into the drip tray.
• Best for following a recipe without thinking → Xloey Air Fryer Parchment. Lay a sheet, load food, cook. There's nothing to season or store.
• Best for someone who bakes beyond pizza → TABLETREANDS 8. Cakes, cookies, pies and tarts all fit the listed use cases; paper doesn't help you there.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the TABLETREANDS 8 pan — but only if flatbread and small pizzas are the reason you're shopping. In my opinion, a rigid nonstick round pan solves the actual problem with air fryer flatbread: soft dough needs something solid underneath it, and paper doesn't provide that. That said, if your air fryer life is mostly wings, fish, vegetables and reheating, the Xloey liners will save you more time day to day. They're not really competitors — they solve different problems, and plenty of kitchens would be better off with both.
how to air fry flatbread pizza
Roll or press your dough to a size that fits your basket, then set it on the TABLETREANDS 8 pan so it can't sag through the grate. Add sauce and toppings, keeping them inside the pan's rim, and cook until the crust is set and the cheese has melted. If you use a Xloey liner instead, make sure the dough covers at least two-thirds of the sheet so the paper is weighed down.
how to air fry flatbread
For plain flatbread, a liner is the easier route — lay the Xloey sheet in the basket, place the flatbread on top with the paper fully covered, and cook until it puffs and browns. For a thicker or wetter flatbread, use the TABLETREANDS 8 pan so the base stays flat and firm. Either way, leave room around the edges so hot air can still circulate.
how long to air fry flatbread pizza
Timing depends on your dough thickness and your air fryer's wattage, so treat any number as a starting point rather than a rule. Thin, pre-made bases cook fastest — check at the shorter end and add time in small increments. Thick or raw dough needs noticeably longer, and the pan you choose matters: the TABLETREANDS 8 aluminum pan will crisp the bottom more evenly than a paper liner.
how long to air fry flatbread
Thin flatbread browns quickly, so start checking early and pull it as soon as it's puffed and lightly charred at the edges. Thicker flatbread takes longer and benefits from being flipped partway through. With the Xloey liners, remember the covering rule at every stage — never let an uncovered sheet sit under the heating element.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: verkelly Parchment Paper Rounds vs GUIAHENG 100: Air Fryer, Numola Parchment Paper Sheets vs Apenkes 200: Air Fryer, HQT 8QT vs INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Parchment: Power XL Air