How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a simple, purpose-built set of replacement cushions for the Microsoft Xbox Wireless Headset, choose XBERSTAR Earpads Cushions Replacement; if you need a fuller refresh kit that also covers the headband and mic foam, choose YunYiYi Ear Pads.
• XBERSTAR Earpads Cushions Replacement — biggest strength: clean, single-purpose earpad replacement in a black protein-skin-and-sponge build that fits the Xbox Wireless Headset family. Trade-off: it's an earpads-only product, so if your headband pad is also worn out, you'll need to look elsewhere for that piece.
• YunYiYi Ear Pads — biggest strength: a complete refresh kit (1 pair earpads + 1 headband pad + 1 pair mic foam) in protein leather and memory foam, with the headband stated as hand- or machine-washable. Trade-off: more parts to install and keep track of, and it's aimed at a slightly broader list of Xbox headsets.
• Who XBERSTAR is for: owners who just need new ear cushions and want a no-fuss, one-part swap.
• Who YunYiYi is for: owners doing a full cosmetic and comfort overhaul who want the headband and mic foam handled in the same purchase.
XBERSTAR keeps things narrow and that's the point. This is a replacement earpad set built for the Microsoft Xbox Wireless Headset, with stated compatibility across the Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One generations. The construction is black protein skin over sponge — a combination chosen for a soft, skin-friendly surface feel and a bit of give against the head during long sessions. If your original cushions have flattened, cracked, or started flaking, this is the direct fix.
Who should buy it: someone whose headband is still perfectly fine and who only needs the ear contact points refreshed. The single-part scope means there's nothing extra to align or trim, which suits people who want the least fiddly job possible. It also suits anyone who prefers a straightforward, tonal black look that disappears into the headset rather than drawing attention.
Who should skip it: if the foam on your headband has also gone flat, or if your mic windscreen is disintegrating, XBERSTAR won't solve those problems — you'd be making a second purchase. It's also worth noting this is specifically an earpad item, so anyone hoping for a "restore everything at once" kit should look at the alternative below.
YunYiYi Ear Pads: Who It's For
YunYiYi takes the opposite approach: it's a kit, not a single part. The package contains one pair of earpads, one headband pad, and one pair of mic foam covers — everything you'd typically replace when a headset has seen a couple of years of daily use. The materials are protein leather and memory foam, which is a sensible pairing for breathability and pressure distribution. Memory foam is the standout detail here: it tends to conform to the shape of your head and ear rather than pushing back flat like cheap open-cell foam.
Compatibility is stated as the Microsoft Xbox Wireless Headset plus the Xbox Stereo Headset 20th Anniversary Special Edition. That's a slightly broader net than XBERSTAR's, so if you own the anniversary stereo model, YunYiYi explicitly lists it.
The headband is the piece most people forget until it's uncomfortable. YunYiYi states the headband pads install without tools and can be hand washed or machine washed — a genuinely useful detail, since headband foam is where sweat and hair product accumulate fastest. Having a washable, replaceable headband pad extends the usable life of the whole headset rather than just the earcups.
Who should buy it: anyone doing a full refurb, anyone whose headband has gone shiny and compressed, and anyone who wants spare mic foam on hand. Who should skip it: if only your earcups are worn, you're paying for parts you may not need yet — though having spares on the shelf isn't a bad thing if you plan to keep the headset for years. The listed item dimensions of roughly 3.94 x 3.15 x 0.59 inches describe a compact, flat-packed kit.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a minimal, earpads-only fix → XBERSTAR Earpads Cushions Replacement. One part, one job, no extras.
• Best for a complete headset refresh → YunYiYi Ear Pads. Earpads, headband, and mic foam in one package.
• Best if you want washable headband padding → YunYiYi Ear Pads. Its headband is stated as hand- or machine-washable.
• Best for a no-tools install → YunYiYi Ear Pads. The headband is explicitly described as tool-free to fit.
• Best for the Xbox Stereo Headset 20th Anniversary Special Edition → YunYiYi Ear Pads. That model is named in its compatibility list.
• Best for straightforward Xbox Wireless Headset earcup replacement → XBERSTAR Earpads Cushions Replacement. Its stated fit is exactly that headset family.
• Best for material feel → a tie, in my view. Both use protein-based covers over foam; XBERSTAR pairs protein skin with sponge, YunYiYi pairs protein leather with memory foam.
In my opinion, YunYiYi Ear Pads is the smarter buy for most people. The reason isn't complicated: a headset that's old enough to need new earpads has almost always compressed its headband foam too, and YunYiYi solves both problems plus the mic foam in a single order. The stated washability of the headband pad is a real long-term bonus, and memory foam is the more comfortable choice for extended wear.
That said, I'd point you to XBERSTAR Earpads Cushions Replacement if your headband is genuinely still in good shape and you want the simplest possible swap with no leftover parts. It's the more focused product, and focus is a legitimate virtue. Just be honest with yourself about the condition of the rest of the headset before you decide.
If your headband pad is also worn, yes — you get the headband and mic foam included rather than buying them separately later. If only your earcups are tired, the extra parts are spares rather than necessities.
The manufacturer states compatibility with the Microsoft Xbox Wireless Headset across Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One. As with any replacement pad, confirm your exact model before ordering.
Based on the specs, YunYiYi lists memory foam, which generally conforms to pressure points better than plain sponge. XBERSTAR's protein skin over sponge is still a soft, skin-friendly combo — I'd give the edge to memory foam for marathon sessions.
No. YunYiYi's package explicitly notes the headphone is not included, and XBERSTAR is an earpad replacement set only. Both are accessories for a headset you already own. Check the current price on Amazon before ordering, since it changes over time.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.