We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want one low-cost set of liners that keeps baskets, racks and sheet pans clean across several appliances, choose WMKGG 3; if you need actual replacement hardware for a Cuisinart-style air fryer toaster oven, choose COWHERDING 2Pcs. These two look like they belong in the same search results, but they solve completely different problems.
• WMKGG 3 biggest strength: three different 9 x 11 inch PTFE-coated fiberglass mats — mesh, perforated and solid — so you get a liner for nearly every cooking job in one set.
• WMKGG 3 biggest trade-off: these are flexible liners, not structural parts, so they won't replace a broken tray or basket.
• COWHERDING 2Pcs biggest strength: rigid food-grade steel tray and basket sized at 12.4" x 11" x 2.3" and 11.5" x 10", built specifically around Cuisinart TOA-60 and TOA-65 style ovens.
• COWHERDING 2Pcs biggest trade-off: it's a fit-dependent replacement part, not a universal accessory — if your oven isn't a similar size, it's the wrong buy.
• Who each pick is for: WMKGG 3 for anyone who wants less scrubbing and more reusable liners; COWHERDING 2Pcs for owners who need a drop-in tray and basket replacement.
The WMKGG set is a three-piece kit of reusable mats, each 9 x 11 inches, and the whole point is that the three styles do three different jobs. The mesh mat is the one I'd reach for when I'm cooking small items — think fries, nuggets, shrimp — because the mesh holds the food up instead of letting it drop through the holes, and it also lets oil drain away from whatever is sitting on the rack or pan below. The perforated mat is the airflow play: it lets hot air move around the food from every direction while the basket underneath stays clean. And the solid black mat is the generalist — line the bottom of an electric oven with it, or use it as a pan liner, baking sheet or grill mat.
Material-wise, these are PTFE-coated fiberglass, non-stick, and rated for heat up to 500°F. That's the number that matters most here, because it comfortably covers normal oven and air fryer temperatures. The sheets are also dishwasher-safe, though the maker recommends hand washing and drying with a towel to keep them in good shape over time.
Who should buy it? Anyone juggling more than one appliance — an air fryer for weeknights, a toaster oven for toast and small bakes, a regular oven for bigger trays. Having three mats in three formats means you're not constantly washing one liner to reuse it. It's also a sensible pick if you hate scrubbing baked-on grease out of a basket or off a rack.
Who should skip it? If what you actually need is a rigid tray or a replacement basket — something with walls that holds food and slides into a specific oven — these flexible mats won't do that. They line and protect; they don't replace structure. And if your oven is much larger than 9 x 11 inches, you'll need to think about coverage, because a single mat of this size won't span a big sheet pan.
The COWHERDING set is a different animal entirely: it's a two-piece replacement kit made of food-grade stainless steel, and it's shaped around a specific family of ovens. You get a tray measuring 12.4" x 11" x 2.3" and a second piece at 11.5" x 10". The listing calls out Cuisinart TOA-60 and TOA-65 compatibility, and notes it also works with other similarly sized air fryer toaster ovens — so the honest framing is: check your oven's dimensions before ordering, because fit is the entire value proposition here.
The material is stainless steel, described as BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, and the set weighs 16 ounces. The finish is non-stick and the pieces are dishwasher-safe, which makes cleanup straightforward — though the maker specifically warns against scouring with abrasive cloths or metal balls, which makes sense for any coated steel surface.
There's one genuinely important detail in the guidance: preheat the basket before first use. The recommendation is a 300°F preheated oven for 10 minutes, and the stated reason is to prevent warping or bending and to preserve structural integrity. Heat resistance is listed at up to 480°F. If you skip that step, you're taking a risk with a part whose whole job is to hold its shape.
Who should buy it? Owners of Cuisinart TOA-60 or TOA-65 style ovens who need a replacement tray, a basket, or both. Also anyone with a similarly sized air fryer toaster oven whose stock tray has warped, lost its coating, or gone missing. It covers grilling, baking, frying and roasting — wings, fries, vegetables.
Who should skip it? If you own a different brand or a noticeably different oven size, this is the wrong purchase; a 12.4-inch tray in a smaller cavity simply won't seat properly. And if you're just looking for something to keep your existing basket clean, a liner is cheaper and easier than a hardware swap.
• Best for keeping multiple appliances clean → WMKGG 3. Three mats, three formats, one purchase.
• Best for replacing a worn or missing tray → COWHERDING 2Pcs. It's an actual tray and basket, not a liner.
• Best for small foods like fries and nuggets → WMKGG 3. The mesh mat is designed to keep small pieces from falling through.
• Best for airflow around food → WMKGG 3. The perforated mat is built to let heat circulate in all directions.
• Best for Cuisinart TOA-60 / TOA-65 owners → COWHERDING 2Pcs. Sizing is built around those ovens.
• Best for high-heat tolerance → WMKGG 3. Up to 500°F versus 480°F for the steel set.
• Best for rigid, dishwasher-safe structure → COWHERDING 2Pcs. Steel holds shape; fiberglass mats flex.
• Best for low-effort, low-commitment upgrade → WMKGG 3. No fit anxiety, no preheat ritual.
My Verdict
For cleanup, WMKGG 3. The non-stick mats catch grease and crumbs so you rinse a liner instead of scrubbing a basket. COWHERDING 2Pcs is dishwasher-safe steel, but it's replacement hardware — its job is cooking, not protecting other surfaces.
Only if your oven is close to Cuisinart TOA-60 or TOA-65 sizing. The pieces measure 12.4" x 11" x 2.3" and 11.5" x 10". Measure your cavity and your existing tray first — if they're meaningfully different, don't order it.
Yes, the maker recommends it: 300°F for 10 minutes before first use, specifically to prevent warping or bending. It's a small step that protects the part's shape over time.
No. They're flexible PTFE-coated fiberglass liners rated to 500°F, not rigid cookware. Use them to line and protect; if you need a tray with walls that holds food, that's the COWHERDING set.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: LNQ LUNIQI 2Pcs vs COWHERDING 3PCS: Air Fryer Toast Rack, JOINPAYA 2pcs vs Didiseaon 2pcs, BAVRQMZX 2PCS vs GRIRIW Square Double Layer