We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-20 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a hard shell made specifically to cradle JBL Tune on-ear headphones with a snug, no-rattle fit, choose WERJIA Hard Carrying Case; if you need one case that covers a much wider spread of brands — Beats, JLab, Soundcore, Sony, Skullcandy and more — plus room for a cable, choose XANAD Headphone Case.
• WERJIA — biggest strength: A dedicated JBL Tune fit (510BT, 520BT, 500BT, T450BT) in a compact, lightweight hard EVA shell that's built purely for storage and bump protection.
• WERJIA — biggest trade-off: Narrow compatibility and a single plain black finish; it's a case only, with no cable storage area mentioned and no hand strap in the spec sheet.
• XANAD — biggest strength: Broad multi-brand compatibility across Beats, JBL Tune, JLab, Soundcore, TOZO, Sony, Skullcandy and more, with a storage area for cables or a charging wire.
• XANAD — biggest trade-off: It's a "small" hard case, so very large over-ear models may not be the target here, and its khaki oxford-wrapped shell is a different look from a plain matte case.
• Who WERJIA is for: Someone who owns one specific pair of JBL Tune on-ears and wants the tightest, simplest protection for it.
• Who XANAD is for: Someone with several headphones, or a headphone plus a cable and dongle, who wants one case to cover more ground.
WERJIA's case is refreshingly honest about what it is. The spec sheet lists compatibility with the JBL Tune 520BT, 510BT, 500BT and T450BT on-ear wireless headphones — and that's basically it. In my opinion, that narrowness is the point. When a case is designed around one family of headphones, the molded interior tends to hold the earcups where they belong instead of letting them slide around inside a generic cavity.
The build is hard EVA (ethylene vinyl acetate), which is the same family of foam-plastic material most rigid headphone cases use. The listing calls out an "excellent touch" with soft protection of the contents, and describes the job plainly: protect your device from bumps, dents and scratches. There's also a stated internal size of 7.5 by 2 inches, which tells you the interior is long and shallow — the shape of an on-ear headphone folded flat, not a big over-ear can.
Weight is listed at 0.23 kg, which keeps it firmly in the "toss it in a backpack and forget it" category. The design notes emphasize compact and lightweight, recommended for travel and home storage. Two things to be clear about: it's sold as the case only (headphones and accessories aren't included), and the finish is a solid black with no color options mentioned.
Who should skip it: If you have Beats, Soundcore, Sony or Skullcandy headphones, or you want a case with a cable pouch and a carry strap, look elsewhere. This one is a specialist, not a generalist.
XANAD Headphone Case: Who It's For
XANAD takes the opposite approach: one case, many headphones. The compatibility list is genuinely long — Beats Studio Pro, Solo 4, Solo 3 and Solo 2; JBL Tune 720BT, 670BT, 520BT, 510BT, 500BT, 570BT, 660NC and more; JBL Live 770NC and 670NC; JLab JBuds Lux ANC and Go Lux ANC; Soundcore Anker Life Q20; Sony MDR-ZX110; Skullcandy Crusher Evo, Hesh ANC, Hesh Evo, Riff 2 and others; plus TOZO, BERIBES, Picun and KVIDIO models. That's the standout feature, and it's the reason most people end up here.
Protection is layered differently too. The shell is hard EVA, but it's wrapped in oxford fabric, which the listing describes as semi-waterproof and shockproof with a soft-touch feel. The stated goal is protection from dust, scratches, scuffs, shock and crush — a slightly broader claim than WERJIA's bump-and-scratch framing, and the oxford outer layer is what backs it up.
Two practical details stand out. First, there's a dedicated storage area for cables or a charging wire, which matters if you carry a USB cable, a dongle or an airplane adapter. Second, it comes with a durable hand strap, so you can carry it on its own instead of burying it in a bag.
The external dimensions are listed at 6.5 x 6.3 x 3.0 inches, and the item dimensions at 5.6 x 5.2 x 2.4 inches — a chunkier, more cube-like footprint than WERJIA's long-and-flat shape. The color here is khaki, and the listing also mentions multi-color options for personalization, so you're not locked into one look. It's also pitched as a gift idea for a friend, family member or student.
Who should buy it: Anyone with a popular over-ear or on-ear model from Beats, JBL, JLab, Soundcore, Skullcandy or similar, especially if they want to carry a cable alongside the headphones.
Who should skip it: If your headphones are unusual, very large, or not on that compatibility list, don't assume the fit — and if you specifically want the tightest possible fit for a JBL Tune on-ear, WERJIA's dedicated shell is the more targeted choice.
• Best for a dedicated JBL Tune fit → WERJIA Hard Carrying Case. It's built around the Tune 510BT/520BT/500BT/T450BT specifically, so the interior geometry is aimed at those on-ears.
• Best for multi-brand flexibility → XANAD Headphone Case. Beats, JLab, Soundcore, Sony, Skullcandy, TOZO and more are all covered in one shell.
• Best for carrying a cable → XANAD Headphone Case. It has a storage area for cables or a charging wire; WERJIA's listing doesn't mention one.
• Best for a slim, lightweight profile → WERJIA Hard Carrying Case. At 0.23 kg with a stated 7.5 x 2 inch interior, it's the flatter, lighter option.
• Best for carrying the case on its own → XANAD Headphone Case. The durable hand strap makes it a standalone carry; WERJIA is better suited to going inside a bag.
• Best for weather resistance → XANAD Headphone Case. The oxford outer layer is described as semi-waterproof, while WERJIA's spec sheet sticks to bump, dent and scratch protection.
• Best for Beats or Skullcandy owners → XANAD Headphone Case. WERJIA doesn't list those brands at all.
• Best for a color choice or a gift → XANAD Headphone Case. Khaki plus multi-color options and gift framing versus WERJIA's solid black only.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the XANAD Headphone Case. The reason is simple: it does more. Broad brand compatibility means it stays useful if you switch headphones, the cable storage area solves the everyday annoyance of a loose charging wire, and the oxford-wrapped EVA shell adds a semi-waterproof layer that WERJIA's spec sheet doesn't claim. The hand strap is a small thing that makes a real difference in daily use.
That said, if you own a JBL Tune 510BT, 520BT, 500BT or T450BT and nothing else, I'd go WERJIA — it's lighter, flatter, and purpose-built for exactly that headphone. Buy the case that matches the headphones you actually own, and check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since both change over time.
FAQ
No. The WERJIA listing only names the JBL Tune 520BT, 510BT, 500BT and T450BT. For Beats or Soundcore, the XANAD case lists those brands directly.
Yes. The listing states it has a storage area for cables or a charging wire, so you can keep a USB cable with the headphones instead of in a separate pocket.
Both are described as lightweight and travel-friendly, but they solve it differently. WERJIA is the slimmer, lighter shell at 0.23 kg, while XANAD adds a hand strap and a semi-waterproof oxford outer layer.
The XANAD listing describes its oxford-covered shell as semi-waterproof. WERJIA's spec sheet doesn't make a water-resistance claim — it focuses on protecting against bumps, dents and scratches. Neither should be treated as fully waterproof.
Match your exact headphone model to the compatibility list first. WERJIA names four JBL Tune models; XANAD names a much longer spread including Beats, JLab, Soundcore, Sony and Skullcandy.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.