We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-29 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want cooler ears and thicker, more supportive cushions for long Skullcandy sessions, choose WC Freeze Crusher; if you need a simple, soft, factory-size replacement pad that restores a worn-out headset, choose HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads. That is the short version. The longer version is about two very different design philosophies: one pad is engineered to change how your headphones feel over hours, the other is engineered to put your headphones back to how they felt on day one.
• WC Freeze Crusher — biggest strength: a dual-layer cooling gel build combined with memory foam, breathable sports fabric and PU leather, plus extra thickness aimed at extended listening and gaming.
• WC Freeze Crusher — biggest trade-off: it is the more specialized pad, and its thicker, cooling-gel construction is a bigger change from a stock cushion, so it suits people who specifically want that upgrade.
• HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads — biggest strength: a straightforward, same-size-as-original cushion in memory foam and protein leather, in a burgundy finish, that swaps in with a few simple steps and no tools.
• HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads — biggest trade-off: it is a like-for-like replacement, so it does not add cooling gel or extra thickness — it simply restores the fit and look you already had.
• Who each pick is for: WC Freeze Crusher for hot-eared, long-session listeners who want a comfort upgrade; HAOMUK for anyone who just wants their Crusher or Hesh pads refreshed cheaply and easily.
The WC Freeze Crusher is a comfort-first replacement pad. Its whole reason for existing is the dual-layer cooling gel — one interior layer, one top layer — paired with a hybrid of breathable sports fabric and leather. If your ears get hot and uncomfortable after an hour or two under a closed-back Skullcandy headset, that combination is the point. The sports fabric breathes where a plain leather wrap would trap heat, and the gel layers sit between your ear and the foam to pull warmth away instead of holding it. In my opinion, that is the single most useful thing a replacement pad can do for a headphone you wear for hours.
Compatibility is broad but specific: Hesh 3, Hesh Evo, Hesh ANC, Crusher Wireless, Crusher Evo, Crusher ANC, Crusher ANC 2, Crusher 720, Crusher 1080 ANC, and Venue. That covers most of the Crusher and Hesh families, but it is a fixed list — check your model before buying. Who should skip it? If your headphones are outside that list, or if you genuinely like the stock feel and only want a cheap cosmetic refresh, this is more pad than you need.
HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads: Who It's For
The HAOMUK pads take the opposite approach, and that is not a criticism. These are replacement cushions in the truest sense: memory foam and protein leather, made to the same size as the original pads, with a burgundy finish that gives a tired headset a visibly new look. HAOMUK's instructions are refreshingly simple — peel off the old pad, tuck the rubber lip into the top groove, work the rest of the lip around with your fingers, then twist slightly to seat it. No tools, a few steps, done.
The material story is about softness and durability rather than thermal engineering. Protein leather is the smooth, supple finish most people associate with a factory headset pad, and the memory foam underneath is described as soft and not pressing on the ears — which matters if your complaint is pressure and flattening rather than heat. Compatibility runs across Crusher Wireless, Crusher Evo, Crusher ANC, Crusher 360, Hesh 3, Hesh Evo, Hesh ANC, and Venue, and it also lists the Crusher Evo Collina Strada and Crusher Evo Budweiser limited editions, which is a nice bit of coverage for special-edition owners.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for hot ears and long sessions → WC Freeze Crusher. Dual-layer cooling gel plus breathable sports fabric is the only cooling design in this comparison.
• Best for a like-new factory feel → HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads. Same size as the original, memory foam and protein leather, no surprises.
• Best for extra cushioning depth → WC Freeze Crusher. WC explicitly builds these extra thick for extended listening and gaming.
• Best for a quick, tool-free install → HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads. HAOMUK's four-step lip-and-groove method is about as simple as pad swapping gets.
• Best for limited-edition Crusher Evo owners → HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads. It lists the Collina Strada and Budweiser editions; WC's list does not.
• Best for Crusher ANC 2, Crusher 720 or Crusher 1080 ANC owners → WC Freeze Crusher. Those three models appear on WC's compatibility list.
• Best for a color change → HAOMUK Replacement Ear Pads. Burgundy is the stated finish, versus WC's black.
• Best for durability-minded buyers → WC Freeze Crusher. Reinforced stitching and upgraded PU leather are called out specifically as longevity features.
I would buy the WC Freeze Crusher. If I am already spending money to replace pads on a Crusher or Hesh, I want the replacement to change something — and cooling gel plus extra thickness is a real, structural change, not a cosmetic one. The broad model coverage, reinforced stitching and breathable fabric hybrid make it the more purposeful purchase in my opinion. The HAOMUK pads are a perfectly sensible, softer, same-size refresh, and I would recommend them without hesitation to someone who simply wants their headset restored to stock. But as a buying decision, I lean toward the upgrade.
FAQ
how should over ear headphones fit
can you sleep with over ear headphones
You can physically wear them, but most over-ear cups are bulky and the clamp builds up over time. Neither pad here changes the headband or the frame — WC's cooling gel and breathable sports fabric address heat during long wear, and HAOMUK's soft memory foam and protein leather reduce pressure on the ears, but both are still replacement cushions on a full-size headset.
how to wear over ear headphones properly
Center each cup over your ear so the cushion seals against your head, not on top of your ear. This matters more with thicker pads: WC's extra-thick, gel-filled cushions need a moment to settle into position, while HAOMUK's same-size pads go on exactly where the originals sat.
how to wear over ear headphones
Put the headset on with the band over the crown of your head and adjust the sliders so the cups sit level. If you are fitting new pads, HAOMUK's method is peel, tuck the lip into the groove, work it around, then twist to seat it — do that before you put the headset on.
Before you decide, it is worth checking the current price on Amazon, since pad upgrades are usually a small spend and the value math changes with your headphone model. Whichever way you go, confirm your exact Skullcandy model against the compatibility list first — that single check prevents the most common mistake with both of these pads.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Yunsailing 30 vs VkingMoR Kids Headphones: On Ear Headphones, Audiovance USB C vs Vkozlm USB C Headphones, AILKIN Earbuds vs DUCOCUB Hybrid Active Noise, NEXOSYNTH in-Ear Earbuds vs TANKASE Neckband: Deep Bass