How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Vaguelly's biggest strength: a carbon steel crisper plate with a double-layer nonstick coating that is dishwasher safe and sized at roughly 8.5 x 8.5 inches, so it sits flat in a basket and can act as a divider between foods.
• Vaguelly's biggest trade-off: it is a single rigid tray at just 0.04 inches thick, so it is one flat surface rather than a set, and it is not flexible or deep.
• PRETYZOOM's biggest strength: you get two silicone liners in the pack, each about 7.66 x 5 x 3.14 inches, and silicone is naturally nonstick and heat resistant, so food releases easily.
• PRETYZOOM's biggest trade-off: the liners are flexible and shallow, so they hold and contain food rather than giving you a firm flat grate or a hard divider edge.
• Pick Vaguelly if you want a flat crisper plate or divider for steaks, fries, pizza and vegetables in an air fryer or steamer.
• Pick PRETYZOOM if you want reusable, foldable liners that catch grease and crumbs for baking, frying and roasting, and you like having a spare in the drawer.
The Vaguelly Air Fryer Crisper is a replacement tray rather than a liner. It is made of carbon steel with a double-layer nonstick coating, and it measures 8.54 x 8.54 x 0.04 inches at 3.68 ounces. That combination matters. The steel gives it rigidity, so it holds its shape when you slide it in and out of a basket, and the thin 0.04-inch profile means it does not eat much vertical space, which is exactly what you want when you are trying to stack or separate food in a small basket.
The "divider" angle is where this tray earns its keep. Because it is a flat, firm plate, you can use it to keep two different foods apart in the same air fryer or steamer — vegetables on one side, protein on the other — instead of letting everything mingle. The listed food compatibility covers steaks, vegetables, fish, fries, pizza and chicken wings, which is a broad enough range to treat it as a general-purpose cooking surface. It also works in steamers, not just air fryers, so if you own both appliances you are getting more use out of one accessory.
Cleanup is straightforward on paper: the double-layer coating is there to stop food from sticking, and the tray is dishwasher safe. It is also easy to install and remove, which sounds trivial until you have fought with a jammed insert after a greasy cook. Who should buy it? Anyone with a roughly 8.5-inch square basket who wants a flat, sturdy plate for crisping and dividing. Who should skip it? If you want something soft, deep and flexible that can hold saucy or messy food, or you want more than one piece in the pack, this is not that product — it is one rigid steel tray.
The PRETYZOOM Reusable Air Fryer is a two-pack of rectangular silicone liners in grey, each measuring 7.66 x 4.99 x 3.14 inches and weighing 10.4 ounces for the pair. Silicone is the whole story here: it is heat resistant, it is naturally nonstick, and it is flexible. That flexibility is the feature you will notice most. You can lift a liner out of the basket by the edges, tip it, and let grease or crumbs slide off, rather than scraping a flat plate.
The rectangular shape is deliberate — the description notes it is made to fit most air fryer baskets so food cooks evenly. Because each liner is about three inches deep, it will hold and contain food in a way a flat plate cannot. That makes it a good fit for baking, frying and roasting, and for anything that releases fat or liquid you would rather not have pooling in the basket itself. The reusable design is also the sustainability argument: silicone liners are meant to be used many times, which cuts down on disposable paper or foil.
Maintenance is described as easy either by hand or in the dishwasher, and the nonstick surface is intended to let food residue come off quickly. You also get two liners, so you can cook with one while the other is in the wash — a small thing that matters on busy weeknights. Who should buy it? Anyone who wants reusable, food-catching liners with a spare in the pack, especially for baking and roasting. Who should skip it? If your goal is a hard, flat divider or crisper grate that keeps foods physically separated, a soft silicone liner will not do that job the same way.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for dividing food in the basket → Vaguelly Air Fryer Crisper. A rigid 8.5-inch steel plate is the more convincing divider; a flexible liner is not.
• Best for crisping flat foods → Vaguelly Air Fryer Crisper. The thin carbon steel plate is designed as a crisper surface for fries, pizza and wings.
• Best for catching grease and crumbs → PRETYZOOM Reusable Air Fryer. Each liner is about three inches deep, so it holds mess instead of letting it drain into the basket.
• Best for appliance versatility → Vaguelly Air Fryer Crisper. It is listed for both air fryers and steamers; the PRETYZOOM liners are described around air fryer baskets.
• Best if you want a spare in the pack → PRETYZOOM Reusable Air Fryer. You get two liners; Vaguelly is a single tray.
• Best for low-profile cooks → Vaguelly Air Fryer Crisper. At 0.04 inches thick, it barely reduces usable basket height.
• Best if you prefer flexible, easy-lift cleanup → PRETYZOOM Reusable Air Fryer. Silicone bends, so you can lift and tip it without a spatula.
In my opinion, the pick comes down to one question: do you want a flat, firm surface or a soft, containing one? If I wanted to separate two foods in a basket or get a proper crisping plate for fries, pizza and wings, I would buy the Vaguelly Air Fryer Crisper. The carbon steel construction and 8.5-inch flat profile are built for exactly that, and the steamer compatibility stretches the value further. I would choose the PRETYZOOM Reusable Air Fryer instead if my priority were catching grease, baking and roasting, and having a second liner ready while the first is drying. Both are sensible; they simply solve different problems. Whichever you lean toward, check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since that is the one thing that can tip an otherwise even call.
which air fryer has a removable divider
The Vaguelly Air Fryer Crisper is the one designed to work as a divider. Because it is a rigid carbon steel plate measuring 8.54 x 8.54 x 0.04 inches, it can be installed and removed easily to separate foods in an air fryer or steamer. The PRETYZOOM liners are flexible silicone trays, not hard dividers, so they are not built for that job.
Both are described as dishwasher safe. The Vaguelly crisper relies on its double-layer nonstick coating for easy release and can go in the dishwasher, and the PRETYZOOM silicone liners are listed as easy to clean by hand or in the dishwasher. Either way, you are not stuck scrubbing.
A crisper plate like the Vaguelly is a flat, thin steel surface for browning foods such as fries, pizza and chicken wings. A silicone liner like the PRETYZOOM is a flexible, roughly three-inch-deep tray that holds food and catches grease during baking, frying and roasting. One gives you a firm cooking surface; the other contains mess.
The liners are rectangular and measure about 7.66 x 4.99 x 3.14 inches each, and the design is described as fitting most air fryer baskets for even cooking. If your basket is square and roughly 8.5 inches across, the Vaguelly crisper at 8.54 x 8.54 inches is the closer match, so measure before buying.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Generic 3 vs PRETYZOOM Air Fryer Liner: Air Fryer Chicken, Hamilton Beach Quantum Toaster Oven vs OVENTE 8L: Air Fryer, GWYXC Air Fryer Replacement vs TEHAUX Air Fryer Silver