If you want a heavy-duty, heat-resistant gasket designed specifically to seal the oil filter housing on BMW and Mini engines without premature failure, choose URO Parts 11428591460; if you need a direct replacement oil filter assembly with an integrated plug gasket for Hyundai or Kia vehicles, choose AD Auto Parts Genuine OEM Kia. These two parts serve entirely different mechanical functions and vehicle ecosystems, so the decision isn't about which is better overall, but which one matches your specific engine bay.
• URO Parts 11428591460: Strengths lie in its high-quality material that resists extreme engine heat and oil degradation, specifically replacing hardened or cracked gaskets to stop leaks. The trade-off is that it is strictly a gasket component and does not include the gasket between the housing and oil cooler, requiring careful verification of your current setup. This pick is for owners of 2014–2018 Mini Coopers and 2016–2019 BMW models who need a precise OE-style seal.
• AD Auto Parts Genuine OEM Kia: Strengths center on being a complete unit count solution that includes both the oil filter and the plug gasket, ensuring compatibility with the specific part numbers 26300-35505, 26300-35504, and 26300-35503. The trade-off is its limited application scope, serving only Hyundai and Kia platforms rather than German luxury sedans or hatchbacks. This pick is for drivers of compatible Kia and Hyundai models looking for a genuine OEM-style replacement.
The URO Parts 11428591460 is engineered for a very specific problem: the notorious oil filter housing leaks found on modern BMW and Mini Cooper powertrains. When these vehicles reach higher mileage, the original gasket often hardens or cracks due to constant exposure to high temperatures and pressurized oil. This results in dangerous oil drips onto the ground or vacuum leaks that can degrade engine performance. This component steps in as a direct replacement to restore that critical seal between the oil filter housing and the engine block.
What makes this part stand out is its focus on material integrity. The design features an OE-style gasket profile and durometer, meaning it mimics the exact flexibility and hardness of the original factory part. It is constructed from high-quality materials explicitly chosen to resist the harsh environment inside an engine bay, where standard rubber might fail quickly under the thermal stress of turbocharged engines. If your Mini Cooper base hatchback (2014–2018) or your BMW 330i/430i series (2017–2019) is showing signs of seepage, this is the component designed to fix it.
However, there is a crucial detail buyers must understand before purchasing. This item is sold as a single unit count of one gasket located strictly between the housing and the block. It does not include the separate gasket required between the housing and the oil cooler. For mechanics or DIYers tackling this job, this distinction matters immensely. You must verify if your vehicle requires that second gasket and purchase it separately if needed. This product is best suited for those who already have the correct tools and understanding of their engine's specific gasket configuration, or those who have been advised by a technician to replace only the primary housing seal.
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-11-08 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
On the other side of the aisle sits the AD Auto Parts Genuine OEM Kia solution, which addresses a completely different set of needs. This product is not just a simple gasket; it is a comprehensive maintenance kit designed for the oil system of Hyundai and Kia vehicles. The listing confirms it includes the oil filter itself along with the necessary plug gasket, creating a streamlined replacement experience for owners of these Korean manufacturers' cars. It is compatible with part numbers 26300-35505, 26300-35504, and 26300-35503, covering a range of model years and engine configurations within that brand family.
The primary appeal here is the "all-in-one" nature of the package. By bundling the filter and the gasket together, it eliminates the guesswork of buying separate components that might not align perfectly during installation. For the average driver performing routine oil changes, having a single unit that guarantees the correct filtration media and sealing surface simplifies the process significantly. It ensures that the new filter will thread correctly onto the engine block and that the drain plug will seal tightly, preventing the common issue of stripped threads or loose fittings during reassembly.
This product is exclusively for owners of Hyundai and Kia vehicles. It has no relevance to the European market, nor does it fit the complex architecture of BMW or Mini oil systems. If you drive a vehicle outside of these brands, this part will simply not work. It is ideal for someone looking to perform a scheduled maintenance interval and wants a straightforward, genuine OEM-style solution that covers all the necessary sealing and filtration bases in one go. It is a practical choice for anyone who wants to ensure their oil change is done right without sourcing multiple individual parts from different suppliers.
• Best for stopping oil leaks on BMW/Mini → URO Parts 11428591460, as it targets the specific failure point of the housing-to-block seal.
• Best for complete oil change kits → AD Auto Parts Genuine OEM Kia, because it bundles the filter and gasket into a single functional unit.
• Best for high-heat resistance → URO Parts 11428591460, given its explicit design to withstand engine heat and oil degradation.
• Best for simplicity of purchase → AD Auto Parts Genuine OEM Kia, since it combines two essential items into one package.
• Best for 2017–2019 BMW 330i/430i → URO Parts 11428591460, which lists these specific models as primary applications.
• Best for Hyundai/Kia maintenance → AD Auto Parts Genuine OEM Kia, the only option listed for these specific part numbers.
• Best for targeted repairs → URO Parts 11428591460, allowing you to replace just the failed gasket without changing the entire filter housing assembly.
• Best for avoiding missing parts → AD Auto Parts Genuine OEM Kia, reducing the risk of forgetting to buy the small gasket during a filter swap.
In my opinion, the choice between these two is strictly dictated by the car sitting in your driveway. I would never suggest buying the URO gasket for a Kia, nor would I recommend the Kia filter for a BMW. However, if I were driving a BMW or Mini and faced the dreaded oil leak, I would choose the URO Parts 11428591460 immediately. Its specialized focus on resisting heat and restoring the precise OE seal gives me confidence that the repair will hold up under pressure. Conversely, for a Kia owner, the AD Auto Parts kit is the logical path. It removes the friction of sourcing multiple pieces and ensures the entire system is refreshed at once. Ultimately, neither product is superior; they are just the right tool for the right job, whether that job involves keeping kids safe in a car by preventing engine failure or ensuring reliable daily operation.
No, the URO Parts 11428591460 is designed exclusively for BMW and Mini Cooper oil filter housings and will not fit Hyundai or Kia engines.
The AD Auto Parts kit includes both the oil filter and the plug gasket, providing a complete replacement unit for the specified part numbers.
The URO gasket is designed to replace hardened or cracked seals to stop leaks, but it cannot fix a physically cracked metal housing; the housing itself may need replacement.
The AD Auto Parts filter is a Genuine OEM style replacement intended for standard maintenance intervals on compatible Hyundai and Kia vehicles.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.