This funny cartoon reminds us that a topic is not the same as a main idea.
The main idea is a sentence with two parts. Here's the formula:
The main idea = The topic + what the author wants to say about the topic.
For example: Puerto Rican food + is delicious.
The second part of the formula is also called the controlling idea.
Imagine that you are reading the newspaper. Your friend asks: “What are you reading about?” You might answer:
The Bulls game, construction on the CTA, and the economic recession are examples of topics! A topic is simply what the text is about. A topic is generally one to five words long. It does not express an opinion, and is not a full sentence with a verb and an adjective. If you are having trouble determining the topic of a reading, look for words and/or concepts that are repeated several times.
Any guess on what the topic is?
Knowing the topic is just the beginning! To find the main idea, you must also know what the author has to say about the topic. Let's imagine you have told your friend you are reading about the economic recession. Your friend says, “Oh yeah? What about it?” You might answer…
The bolded part of each of these sentences is the second part of the formula—the controlling idea.
Please note that this idea can be a fact or an opinion.
All three sentences above are examples of main ideas. They all have the same topic—the economic recession. But each sentence expresses a different controlling idea about the same topic.
A main idea needs those two parts—the topic and the idea about it—but it doesn't matter what order they go in. So you could also say “Irresponsible loans made by banks caused the economic recession.”