Tea vs. Coffee

       Over time, a major debate has caused a rift between people: the debate regarding coffee and tea. Which one is better? I would like to offer my personal thoughts and insight on the matter. While this is a divisive topic, I take a neutral stance.

A reason commonly stated by proponents of coffee superiority is that the aroma is more pleasing to the nose. While I agree with this statement, I believe that it must also be noted that this observation is not objective. Everyone is unique; what I find appealing may be considered appalling by the next person I ask. On the topic of the smell of coffee, coffee breath is a smell that many (including myself) consider to be off-putting and disgusting. This is where tea comes in; being less aromatic, it also has more subtle differences in breath. While there are differences in scent emitted by both tea and coffee, the fact of the matter is that perception of taste is highly subjective, and therefore claiming that one is superior or inferior is not a fact: it is merely an opinion.

Another highly contested, albeit subjective point is that one tastes better than the other. While I do believe that coffee tastes better in general, it is highly dependent on preparation. Some people complain that coffee doesn’t taste good or is too bitter, but the issue at hand is that they usually have not tried a style of preparation of coffee that particularly appeals to them. My personal preference lies with the mellower, richer taste of coffee. However, having tried numerous varieties of both, I have come to this opinion. I prefer coffee, but bear no animosity towards tea. People are very hasty to come to judgements without seeing the whole picture.

A final point in regard to potential points of superiority is the effects that each beverage imparts upon the health of the consumer. Both beverages contain caffeine, albeit in varying amounts. Tea, contrary to popular belief, does contain caffeine, although about 97% less than coffee does. Depending on what a person wants and needs, that may be either a good or a bad thing. For example, someone with exams to complete may need that extra caffeine boost in order to be able to stay awake and study for longer. On the other hand, someone planning to travel may opt to drink tea instead, as it facilitates the process of resting. Caffeine is a stimulant and is known to disturb rest. Coffee and tea have effects on the health of their consumers, although the effects are different, and different people desire different things from their beverages.

The conclusion of this debate is, ironically, inconclusive. While many, including myself, have preferences, likes, and dislikes, superiority of either beverage cannot be determined upon preference. With this debate, it is especially difficult, because each beverage presents different unique characteristics. Based on knowledge of these effects, consumers can decide which beverage appeals to them. Personally, I find coffee to be better, but that depends from person to person. Either way, both beverages are sure to provide a refreshing, enjoyable experience.