How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a versatile, round liner that drops into almost any air fryer, microwave, oven or steamer, choose TOGOO Air Fryer Paper; if you need a rectangular liner sized specifically for Ninja Foodi Smart XL and dual-basket grill/air fryer combos, choose MooManGoo Ninja.
• TOGOO Air Fryer Paper — biggest strength: a 100-count pack of 6.3-inch round liners with a 4.5 cm raised edge that fits air fryers, microwaves, ovens, steamers and cookers alike.
• TOGOO Air Fryer Paper — biggest trade-off: the 6.3-inch round shape is small and won't line a large rectangular or dual-basket basket properly.
• MooManGoo Ninja — biggest strength: 120 rectangular liners measuring 13 x 9 inches, sized for Ninja Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 indoor grill and rectangular-basket air fryer/grill combos, with a taller 6 cm edge.
• MooManGoo Ninja — biggest trade-off: it's built around one appliance family, so it's a poor fit if you don't own a Ninja Smart XL or a rectangular-basket combo.
• Who each pick is for: TOGOO suits anyone with a standard round air fryer or several different cooking appliances; MooManGoo suits Ninja Smart XL and dual-appliance owners who want a wider liner.
TOGOO's whole pitch is versatility. This is a pack of 100 disposable parchment liners, each shaped like a shallow round bowl 6.3 inches across with a 4.5 cm heightened edge. Because they're pre-formed, you don't tear, fold, cut or bend anything — you just set one in the basket and cook. The material is food-grade parchment rated to withstand temperatures up to 428°F, and it's waterproof, oil-proof and non-stick. TOGOO also states the liners don't interfere with the air fryer's internal air circulation, which is the point of an air fryer in the first place.
The real draw is the cleanup story. Grease and crumbs land on the paper instead of the basket, so when you're done you lift the liner out and throw it away. The liner itself is designed with that raised lip specifically to keep food residue off the sides of the fryer. If you hate scrubbing a basket after every batch of wings, this is the exact problem the product solves.
Where TOGOO fits best is a household with a standard round air fryer — or someone who also bakes, roasts and reheats. The liners are listed as suitable for air fryer, microwave, oven, steamer and cooker, which makes them a single-item answer across your kitchen rather than an appliance-specific accessory. The 100-count pack also suits people who cook in small, frequent batches and don't want to ration liners.
MooManGoo Ninja: Who It's For
MooManGoo takes the opposite approach: one appliance family, done properly. This is a 120-count pack of rectangular liners measuring 13 x 9 inches, built for the Ninja Smart XL. The brand explicitly lists compatibility with the Ninja FG551 Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 indoor grill, and says the liners also fit grill-and-air-fryer combos with a rectangular basket, naming the IG601, IG651 and FG511 among others. If that's your machine, the fit is the entire reason to buy this product.
Like TOGOO, the material is food-grade parchment rated to 428°F, waterproof, oil-proof and non-stick, with no effect on food taste. The bowl-shaped rectangle means no tearing, folding or cutting — drop it in and cook. The raised edge here is 6 cm, noticeably taller than TOGOO's 4.5 cm, and MooManGoo points out a practical benefit: that taller lip makes it easier to lift the food out once it's done, and it shields the fryer's sides from residue.
The other design difference worth noting is the absence of holes. MooManGoo argues that even without perforations, the liners don't disrupt the air circulation that comes off the pan wall, and that a solid liner actually keeps food residue off the fryer's bottom better than a perforated one. That's a reasonable trade-off to understand: you get a cleaner basket floor, but you should expect to lift the liner when you want the air to reach the underside of food.
MooManGoo also includes an important safety note in its own listing: don't put an empty liner in during preheating, and don't use too little food, because the lightweight paper can be blown up into the heating element. That's a genuine usage caveat, not a flaw — it applies to lightweight parchment liners generally, but it's worth respecting here given the large surface area.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for round air fryers → TOGOO Air Fryer Paper. The 6.3-inch round bowl shape is made for standard round baskets.
• Best for Ninja Smart XL and rectangular-basket combos → MooManGoo Ninja. The 13 x 9-inch rectangle is sized for those appliances specifically.
• Best for cross-appliance use → TOGOO Air Fryer Paper. It's listed for air fryer, microwave, oven, steamer and cooker; MooManGoo is aimed at Ninja machines.
• Best for easier food removal → MooManGoo Ninja. Its 6 cm edge is taller than TOGOO's 4.5 cm, which helps you lift food out.
• Best for keeping residue off the basket floor → MooManGoo Ninja. Its solid, hole-free design is pitched at keeping food off the fryer bottom.
• Best for small, frequent batches → TOGOO Air Fryer Paper. The smaller liner suits quick single portions without waste.
• Best for larger single batches → MooManGoo Ninja. A 13 x 9-inch liner covers far more basket area than a 6.3-inch round one.
• Best count-to-spare ratio → MooManGoo Ninja. 120 liners versus TOGOO's 100, if you cook often and large.
If I had to pick one, I'd choose MooManGoo Ninja — but only because the choice hinges entirely on your appliance. If you own a Ninja Smart XL or a rectangular-basket grill/air fryer combo, the 13 x 9-inch fit and the taller 6 cm edge make it the more useful liner, and 120 pieces go a long way. If you own a round air fryer, or you want liners that also work in your oven and microwave, TOGOO is the smarter buy and I'd recommend it without hesitation. Match the liner to the basket you actually own — that's the whole decision.
FAQ
Both are disposable parchment liners with similar heat resistance, so value comes down to fit and count. MooManGoo gives you 120 larger liners; TOGOO gives you 100 smaller round ones. If a liner doesn't fit your basket, it isn't value at any count — so check the shape first, then check the current price on Amazon for both.
Only if your basket is rectangular and Ninja-compatible. MooManGoo lists the Ninja FG551 Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 indoor grill and notes fit for rectangular-basket combos including the IG601, IG651 and FG511. On a round-basket air fryer, a 13 x 9-inch rectangle won't sit properly.
Both brands state their liners don't interfere with the internal air circulation, which is what air fryers rely on. That said, a solid liner covers the base, so the underside of food won't get the same direct airflow — lift the liner when you want crispness underneath.
MooManGoo advises against putting an empty liner in during preheating and against using too little food, because the lightweight paper can be blown into the heating element. A good habit with any parchment liner: always weight it down with food.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: BOSOIRSOU 6 vs MESTAEK Air Fryer Paper, CXINYI vs MMH Air Fryer Paper: Best Air Fryer Accessories, Nuwave Brio 2.6-Qt vs Ninja DT202BK: Best Air Fryer for 2