How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• TL HONGPHUC 3M — biggest strength: a 4-count pack of black memory-foam pads aimed squarely at 3M WorkTunes Connect and AM/FM radio earmuffs, so heavy users get spares instead of reordering every time a pad flattens.
• TL HONGPHUC 3M — biggest trade-off: the fit is narrow. It is built for 3M WorkTunes and ProHear-style headsets, not for mainstream music headphones, so you must check your model before buying.
• Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads — biggest strength: high-density slow-rebound memory foam wrapped in soft protein leather, with a plastic removal tool included and a stated 3-to-5-minute install.
• Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads — biggest trade-off: it is a single pair (one white set) for one specific JBL family, so you get no spares and no use on any other brand.
• Who each pick is for: TL HONGPHUC 3M for mowing, construction and workshop users who want a stock of pads; Hmoke for JBL Live/Duet owners who just want their old headphones to feel new again.
This is a consumable part, not a gadget, and it is priced and packaged like one. Four pairs of memory-foam pads in black, each sized around an 8.66 x 5.91 x 1.18-inch footprint for the ear-cup assembly. The listing points repeatedly at 3M WorkTunes Connect, WorkTunes AM/FM radio earmuffs and ProHear Bluetooth headsets. That tells you the intended buyer: someone who already owns one of those work-focused headsets and wears it for hours at a time.
What it does best is spare-pad logistics. Hearing-protection earmuffs get sweaty, crushed and shoved into a truck bed, and the foam is always the first thing to give out. Buying one set at a time means you are back on the site in a few months. A four-pack means you replace the pads on your main pair and still have three sets waiting. The memory foam is also the point of the upgrade: the stated goal is reduced clamping pressure over long wear, which matters when you are wearing muffs through a full afternoon of mowing or a shift on site.
Who should skip it? Anyone whose headphones are not 3M WorkTunes, WorkTunes Connect or a comparable work earmuff. If you own JBL, Sony, Bose or Audio-Technica consumer headphones, this is simply the wrong shape and mount — no amount of stretching fixes that. Also skip it if you want a single replacement pair and nothing more; you would be buying three sets you may never open. And note the stated warranty is 30 days, which is short compared with what some pad makers offer, so treat this as a wear item you replace rather than a long-term investment.
Hmoke plays a different game: one headphone family, one pair, done properly. The pads are cut for the JBL E65BTNC, Live 650BTNC, Live 770NC, Live 660NC and Duet NC, and the listing is blunt that you should confirm your model first. That is honest and worth taking seriously, because these fit on-ear and over-ear JBL cups specifically.
The materials are the selling point. High-density slow-rebound memory foam under soft protein leather: slow-rebound foam compresses gradually rather than fighting back, which is exactly what you want when the complaint is sore ears after a long session. Protein leather is the same family of material most original pads use, so the feel should land close to stock rather than plasticky. Hmoke also claims the pads match the originals in size, shape and quality, and that they restore the look of tired headphones — a fair pitch, since peeling cushions are usually the only thing wrong with an otherwise fine pair of JBLs.
Installation is genuinely the easy part here. No glue, no special tools required, and a plastic removal tool is included so you can pry the old rings off without gouging the plastic. The stated turnaround is three to five minutes. The white colorway is the one caveat — it looks sharp when new but shows sweat and grime faster than black, so if your headphones live in a gym bag or on a mower, think about that. Support is listed at a 24-hour reply window, and the warranty runs a full year, which is a meaningful difference if you are worried about foam collapsing early.
Who should skip it? Anyone without one of those five JBL models, and anyone who wants spare pads on hand. You get one pair, so a second failure means a second order.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for JBL Live/Duet owners → Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads, sized for the E65BTNC, Live 650BTNC, Live 770NC, Live 660NC and Duet NC.
• Best for getting spares → TL HONGPHUC 3M, sold as a 4-count; Hmoke is a single pair.
• Best for a quick, tool-free swap → Hmoke, which includes a plastic removal tool and states a 3-to-5-minute install with no glue.
• Best for long-session comfort materials → Hmoke, with slow-rebound memory foam and protein leather described as shaping to the ear without pressure build-up.
• Best for color choices → neither is a color-matching exercise — TL HONGPHUC 3M is black only, Hmoke is white only.
• Best warranty coverage → Hmoke, at a stated 1-year manufacturer warranty versus 30 days for TL HONGPHUC 3M.
• Best for reviving old headphones instead of replacing them → Hmoke, whose whole pitch is a new look and feel from a simple pad swap.
In my opinion, the right pick is decided entirely by what is sitting on your desk. If you own JBL Live or Duet NC headphones with flattened pads, I would buy the Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads: the slow-rebound foam and protein leather are the right materials for comfort, the included tool makes the swap painless, and the 1-year warranty backs a part that usually fails quietly. If you own 3M WorkTunes or a comparable work earmuff, I would buy the TL HONGPHUC 3M instead — four sets of memory foam means you stop thinking about pads for a long while, and it is the only one of the two that actually fits your headset. Nobody should be cross-shopping these; check your model number first, then commit.
No. They are designed for 3M WorkTunes Connect, WorkTunes AM/FM radio earmuffs and similar ProHear-style headsets. Hmoke is the one to look at for the JBL E65BTNC, Live 650BTNC, Live 770NC, Live 660NC and Duet NC.
TL HONGPHUC 3M is a 4-count pack, so you get four sets. Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads come as a single pair in white. If you want backups, that difference matters more than anything else on this page.
No special tools. Hmoke includes a small plastic tool to help lift the old pads off, and the listed install time is roughly three to five minutes with no glue involved.
Hmoke backs its pads with a stated 1-year manufacturer warranty; TL HONGPHUC 3M lists 30 days. That said, foam life depends on sweat, heat and how often you wear the headset, so treat both as wear items and check the current price on Amazon before deciding which is the better deal for you.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Saipomor Pro Headphones Ear vs Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads, Aiivioll Ear Pads Replacement vs YOCOWOCO Replacement Ear Pads, ZIHNIC 5.3 vs AKHQC Replacement Ear Pads: Luxury Headphones