Module 8: Print, Textual, & Lyric Analysis
Composition I by Tiffani Tijerina and Magnus Florini is licensed CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 International
Composition I by Tiffani Tijerina and Magnus Florini is licensed CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 International
Analyze how poetic devices, word choice, figurative language, tone, and song lyrics interact with visual imagery to reinforce or complicate a music video's core argument.
Construct a cohesive, well-supported analytical draft that seamlessly weaves lyric quotes, visual descriptions, and cultural context into a unified thesis statement.
Identify and revise passive voice constructions, unnecessary infinitives, and weak phrasal verbs, converting them into active, precise verbs that heighten critical prose.
*Explainer generated with Notebook LM, using Writing Guide with Handbook, Ch 16 as the source content.
Did you know that match cuts, jump cuts, and sound bridges in movies and TV shows are composition? That's right! In film, an edit controls time, tension, and narrative flow. In writing, paragraph transitions, signal phrases, and sentence variety perform the exact same work of guiding the audience seamlessly from one idea to the next.
Review Section 14: Verbs, Voice, Infinitives, and Phrasal Verbs; Section 17: Verbals; and Section 18: Infinitives.
Craft a response of approximately 250–300 words addressing the following two parts.
Noticing Something Interesting: Choose the official music video for the song you plan to analyze in your upcoming rhetorical analysis essay. Watch it at least twice. During your viewing, pay attention to something that surprises, confuses, interests, or troubles you. You might notice a contradiction between the lyrics and the visuals, a repeated symbol, an unexpected change in the music, or a moment that seems inconsistent with the video's apparent message. Describe your observation and provide a link to the video and at least one timestamp.
Turning an Observation into a Problem: From your reading "Looking for Trouble," Savini argues that strong academic arguments emerge from problems and tensions. Using your observation from Part 1, identify a question worth exploring. What seems contradictory, complicated, or unexplained? Why might the artist have made this choice? What might viewers gain or misunderstand because of it? Then, explain what you think is at stake in answering your question. Why is this observation worth analyzing rather than simply describing? Your question should invite analysis rather than a simple yes-or-no answer. You do not need to know the answer yet.
Turning a Process into a Plan: The above steps are part of the “pre-writing” process to help you flesh out ideas and brainstorm. Now that you’ve gone through them, clearly state in one sentence what the message of your chosen song is. This is important to help your peers respond to you.
Reply to at least two classmates, addressing all three parts in each response.
Seeing What They Saw: Watch your classmate's video at their provided timestamp. What do you notice about the moment they selected? Do you agree that it presents a problem or tension worth exploring? Explain why.
Finding More Trouble: Identify another tension, contradiction, repeated pattern, or unexplained choice in their video. Provide a timestamp and explain how this additional observation might complicate their original interpretation.
Providing Our Insight: Help your classmate explain how the contradiction contributes to their video's message, or offer an alternative explanation for the artist's choice.