Module 11: Research Process & Source Evaluation
Composition I by Tiffani Tijerina and Magnus Florini is licensed CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 International
Composition I by Tiffani Tijerina and Magnus Florini is licensed CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 International
Conduct systematic academic research using university databases and scholarly indexes, evaluating sources for currency, authority, bias, and relevance to a specific community issue.
Identify and fix awkward source mechanics such as "quote-dropping", unannounced quotes, and vague signal phrases to blend source material smoothly into academic prose.
Synthesize external research into body paragraphs in a way that keeps the writer's analytical voice in the lead, using source material as supporting evidence rather than letting quotes carry the narrative.
Apply correct punctuation conventions including commas, colons, semicolons, quotation marks, etc.
*Explainer generated with Notebook LM, using Writing Guide with Handbook, Ch 13 as the source content.
Did you know that live sports broadcasting, Twitch stream commentary, and podcast storytelling are composition? That's right! Commentators don't just state what happens (facts/evidence); they analyze why a play matters, weave in player backstories (narrative), and contextualize stats (data) for the viewer in real time.
Last week, you looked at solutions to a community issue. This week, you'll be looking at challenges posed or revealed by those solutions. This way, you can more readily address counterarguments in Assignment 3 (the section "Unintended Consequences & Limitations").
Craft a response (around 250-300 words) addressing the following three parts:
Reflecting on Citing: To start, refresh yourself with the common mistakes people make when providing sources found in "Annoying Ways People Use Sources." Then, describe a time you've made one of these mistakes. You may use an example from previous discussion boards or essays in this class.
Understanding Sources: Locate two scholarly sources which address hidden costs, systemic barriers, or trade-offs to a solution to your chosen community issue (this can be from last week's discussion board or something new). Briefly explain each source's central finding, argument, or contribution.
Synthesizing Sources: Write a short paragraph about these challenges which incorporates both sources into it. Use at least one direct quote and work on integrating your sources by avoiding the common mistakes in your reading. Your paragraph should include a clear topic sentence, source integration, and your own explanation of how the evidence supports your claim. Avoid simply summafrizing one source after another.
Reply to at least two classmates addressing the following:
Evaluation Integration: Evaluate how your classmate introduces and incorporates the source. Does the classmate introduce their signal phrases specific? Could they make the source integration smoother? Are the two sources connected effectively?
Realizing Together: What changed in your thin king as a result of what your classmate has written? What did the student help you realize?
Appreciating Rhetoric: What is one rhetorical technique or strategy your classmate used well, and why do you think so?