past perfect explained:
When I arrived at the party everyone left.
When I arrived at the party everyone had left.
By a certain time...
My grandparents had died by the time I graduated college.
Internet had already been invented by the year 2000.
By 2010, I had already been to China.
By 2015, I had already quit smoking.
by 2010 ______
by 2005 ________
by the time I graduated university ______
by the time I had my first child _____
by the year 2000 ______
ALIBI GAME AND OTHER PAST PERFECT IDEAS: https://www.tefl.net/elt/ideas/games/fun-past-perfect-practice/