How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-20 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• SwimCell Waterproof Phone Holder — biggest strength: certified IPX8 waterproofing, tested to withstand 20m underwater, with a touch screen that still works through the case. It also ships with an adjustable armband and a neck lanyard.
• SwimCell Waterproof Phone Holder — biggest trade-off: it fits standard phones up to 5.9 inches / 15cm in length only, and it is built for use with headphones that are not included — so you still need to buy those separately.
• LUDOS Zenith — biggest strength: a wired 3.5mm in-ear earphone with a built-in microphone, a dynamic driver and a 5 year warranty.
• LUDOS Zenith — biggest trade-off: it is not waterproof and has no water-resistance rating at all, so it has no business being in a pool, lake or heavy rain.
• Who SwimCell is for: swimmers, runners, walkers and anyone who needs their phone protected on or near water.
• Who LUDOS Zenith is for: anyone who wants simple corded earphones with a mic for calls, music, school, commuting or a laptop.
The SwimCell Waterproof Phone Holder is, first and last, a protection product. The case is rated IPX8 — the highest waterproof rating available — and the brand states it has been tested to withstand 20m underwater. That is a serious claim for something you strap to your arm. For open water swimmers, pool swimmers and anyone who runs in British weather, that combination of a sealed case plus a soft, adjustable armband is the whole point.
The kit is more complete than a lot of buyers expect. You get the waterproof case itself, an armband that fits arms from 20 to 35cm and fastens with Velcro, and a neck lanyard. The armband uses a soft, strong fabric with an extra square of padding so the case doesn't rub against your skin — a small detail that matters a lot once you're 40 minutes into a walk or a jog. There's also room inside for keys, cards or cash, which turns it into a lightweight carry-all for a swim.
The touch screen stays fully functional through the case, so you can change music, take photos, make calls and track your activity without opening anything. iPhone users should switch on the floating home button before sliding the phone in — a genuinely useful tip rather than a marketing line. The case is made from soft, textured PVC, which makes it comfortable to hold and less slippery when wet.
Here's the trade-off, and it's the one that trips people up. This version has a headphone jack and is designed for use with waterproof headphones — which are not included. If you own wireless headphones, SwimCell also makes a version without the jack, so check which one you're buying before you commit. The other limit is size: it fits standard phones up to 5.9 inches / 15cm in length. SwimCell explicitly recommends measuring your phone first, and I'd take that seriously — a large phone will not fit, however much you want it to. If you're carrying a big handset, or you want a belt option, note that an XL armband and waist belt are sold separately.
The LUDOS Zenith is a straightforward pair of wired in-ear headphones in turquoise. They connect through a 3.5mm jack, so they work with anything that still has that port — phones, laptops, computers, tablets, school devices. No pairing, no charging, no battery to think about. You plug them in and they work.
The spec sheet lists a dynamic driver and 32 ohm impedance, which is a normal, undemanding load for a phone or laptop to drive. LUDOS describes the sound as detailed with spatial and directional audio for music, films and games. There's a built-in microphone with call control on the cable, so you can take calls without pulling your phone out. Isolation is passive — the in-ear fit blocks some surrounding noise, which is handy on a train or in a shared office, and worth thinking about if you need to hear traffic while running.
The housing is thermoplastic elastomer, a flexible rubbery material that tends to survive being shoved in a pocket or bag better than hard plastic. The headline number, though, is the 5 year warranty. For a budget-tier category where earphones are often treated as disposable, that is a long commitment from the manufacturer, and it is the single strongest argument for buying these over no-name alternatives.
Who should skip it? Anyone who wants to wear headphones in water. There is no IP rating here — no waterproofing, no water resistance. Sweat during a normal workout is one thing, but swimming, showering or running in proper rain is outside what this product is built for. If that's your use case, the Zenith is the wrong tool regardless of how good it sounds.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for protecting your phone in the rain → SwimCell Waterproof Phone Holder. That's its core purpose.
• Best for carrying keys, cards and cash on a workout → SwimCell Waterproof Phone Holder. The case has room for more than a phone.
• Best for hands-free listening while you exercise → LUDOS Zenith, but only in dry conditions. Pair it with the SwimCell case's jack version for a wired setup — just add waterproof headphones.
• Best for phone calls and voice chat → LUDOS Zenith. It has a built-in mic and call control; the SwimCell case is just a case.
• Best for kids, students and school devices → LUDOS Zenith. Wired, 3.5mm, no charging, no pairing, no lost earbuds.
• Best for a long-term purchase you won't have to rebuy → LUDOS Zenith, on the strength of the 5 year warranty. The SwimCell case carries a 1 year manufacturer warranty.
• Best for fitting an existing large phone → neither, as listed. The SwimCell case caps out at 5.9 inches / 15cm, and the Zenith is headphones. Measure before you buy.
• If you're buying both → check the case size against your phone, confirm you're ordering the headphone-jack version, and remember the headphones themselves are not included.
In my opinion, the honest answer is that most people asking this question are really asking "which one do I need for swimming?" — and for that, it's the SwimCell Waterproof Phone Holder. IPX8, tested to 20m, a working touch screen, an armband and a lanyard in the box. It solves a problem the Zenith cannot touch.
But if you're not going near water, buy the LUDOS Zenith. Wired, mic-equipped, 3.5mm, backed by a 5 year warranty. It's the lower-risk purchase of the two, and it doesn't depend on your phone's dimensions. If you're kitting out for open water, get the SwimCell case first and sort your waterproof headphones separately — because the ones you need aren't in the box.
FAQ
Yes, on the specs. It's certified IPX8, the highest waterproof rating available, and SwimCell states it has been tested to withstand 20m underwater. That covers swimming, running and walking in the rain.
Only if your phone is up to 5.9 inches / 15cm in length. That's the standard size limit. Measure your handset before ordering — SwimCell recommends it, and larger phones won't fit.
No. There is no water-resistance rating on the Zenith. They're fine for everyday listening, calls and light sweat, but don't swim, shower or run in heavy rain with them.
Yes, with this version. It has a headphone jack and is designed for use with waterproof headphones, which are not included. If you use wireless headphones instead, look at SwimCell's version without the jack.
Prices change constantly, so check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page rather than trusting a figure in an article. On specs alone, the Zenith's 5 year warranty is the stronger long-term value if you only need earphones; the SwimCell case is the better value if you need water protection, since nothing else here does that job.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.