How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
• GXF Air Fryer Accessories — best for Emeril Lagasse 26 QT owners who want a direct-fit replacement pan; pick this if you want the exact 12.5" × 11.3" × 0.8" footprint, a 480°F limit, and FDA-standard, BPA-free steel.
• SettleDown 12.4"x11 — best for Cuisinart TOA-60/65/70 convection toaster oven owners; pick this if you need a 12.4" × 11" × 0.78" tray and you want the lightest option here at 3.2 ounces.
• GWYXC Air Fryer Grill — best for Emeril Lagasse Dual Zone 360 25 QT owners with the French door combo; pick this if you need the largest tray in this guide at 14" × 12" × 0.8".
• GWBSXM Air Fryer Grill — best for Emeril Lagasse 26 QT owners who want a second, heavier-duty pan; pick this if you want the same 12.5" × 11.3" fit in a noticeably heftier build.
This is a single stainless steel pan measuring 12.5" × 11.3" × 0.8", sold as one piece and designed around the Emeril Lagasse 26 QT Extra Large Air Fryer. That specificity is the whole point. If your machine is that model, you are not guessing at fit or trimming anything down — the tray slots into the space the original crisper plate occupied. It weighs 10.4 ounces and comes in silver.
The material spec is what I'd focus on. It's food-grade stainless steel, BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, and stated to meet FDA standards. In daily use that matters less as a label and more as a behavior: there's no nonstick coating to flake or scratch, so you can use metal tongs, a spatula, or a grill fork without worrying about peeling a surface off your food. The tray is rated to a maximum of 480°F, which covers everything a typical air fryer or countertop oven will throw at it.
One thing to read carefully before you buy: the maker requires a preheat step. The instructions say to place the pan in an oven preheated to 300°F for 10 minutes before first use, and warn that skipping this can cause the pan to deform, bend or be damaged and shorten its lifespan. That's an unusual extra chore, and I'd treat it as a real requirement rather than a suggestion. It's also dishwasher safe, though the maker says to avoid rough abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls — a soak handles stuck-on food.
The main trade-off is fit. This pan is built for one machine family. If you don't own an Emeril Lagasse 26 QT, the dimensions probably won't line up with your basket, and there's no adjustability. It's also a single tray, so if you like to run two racks at once you'd need to buy a second one. For the right owner, though, it's a clean, no-compromise replacement.
SettleDown 12.4"x11
Because it's so light, it behaves differently from the heavier options. It heats up quickly and is easy to slide in and out one-handed, and it won't add meaningful weight when you're pulling a loaded tray out of a hot oven. The steel is described as food-safe and chosen for durability and fast, even heat distribution for uniform browning — the practical version of that is a sheet pan that doesn't leave you with pale centers and scorched edges on the same batch of fries.
This is a genuinely versatile piece rather than a one-trick crisper plate. The maker positions it for chicken wings, french fries and vegetables, and for grilling, baking and frying generally. In a Cuisinart toaster oven, that means it can pull double duty as a baking sheet for a small batch of cookies or a sheet-pan dinner, not just an air fry tray. It's dishwasher safe, with the same caution about avoiding abrasive pads and metal scouring balls.
The trade-off is the same one that makes it good: it's a dedicated fit. Cuisinart TOA-60/65/70 only. The maker also notes there may be a slight color difference between the photos and the real tray — a minor thing, but worth knowing if you're matching existing pans. And at 3.2 ounces, it's thin stock; treat it as a lightweight pan rather than a heavy-gauge roasting sheet.
At 14" × 12" × 0.8", this is the largest tray in this guide, and it's designed for the Emeril Lagasse Dual Zone 360 Air Fryer Oven 25 QT Extra Large combo with the French door. If you own that machine, you already know the cooking area is wide and shallow, and a tray that doesn't span it wastes the whole point of a dual-zone oven. This one is built to span it. It weighs 0.41 kg and comes in silver.
Like the other Emeril-oriented trays here, it's food-grade stainless steel, BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, and stated to meet FDA standards, with a 480°F maximum heat resistance. It's dishwasher safe with the same warning against rough abrasive cloths and metal balls, and the maker notes that even stubborn stuck-on food loosens after a quick soak. The same first-use preheat applies: 300°F for 10 minutes, and skipping it risks deformation, bending or damage.
Who is this for? Someone who cooks in volume. A 14" × 12" surface is enough to lay out a full tray of wings, a pile of cut vegetables, or several pieces of fish in a single layer instead of stacking and steaming them. That single-layer capacity is the difference between roasted and soggy, and it's the strongest argument for this pan over the smaller ones.
The trade-off is obvious and worth stating plainly: it's big, and it only fits the Dual Zone 360 25 QT combo. It won't fit the standard 26 QT machine or a Cuisinart toaster oven, and it will take up real cabinet space when stored. If your air fryer is any other model, skip it — but if you have the French-door combo, the size is exactly right.
GWBSXM's tray is 12.5" × 11.3" × 0.8" — the same footprint as the GXF pan — and it's also designed for the Emeril Lagasse 26 QT Extra Large Air Fryer. It weighs 1.01 pounds, which makes it the heaviest tray in this guide by a wide margin, and it's a single pan in silver.
That weight is the interesting part. A heavier pan generally means thicker steel, which tends to feel more solid in the hand, resist flexing when you lift a loaded tray, and hold heat a little more steadily. If you've ever had a flimsy replacement pan bow or warp under a heavy roast, this is the spec that speaks to that concern. The rest of the feature set matches its siblings: food-grade stainless steel, BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, FDA standards cited, and a 480°F maximum.
It's dishwasher safe, and again the maker says to avoid rough abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls, with a soak recommended for anything stuck on. The preheat requirement is identical and non-optional — 300°F for 10 minutes before first use, or the pan may deform, bend or be damaged. Note that the listing is a little less polished than the others, and the fit claim is tied strictly to the Emeril Lagasse 26 QT.
The trade-off here is that it's essentially a twin of my top pick on dimensions and machine compatibility, so the choice between them comes down to feel rather than fit. The heavier build is a plus if you want something substantial; it's a minus if you prefer a lighter tray that's easier to handle when hot. If you want the thickest-feeling option for the 26 QT, I'd lean this way.
How We Picked
I compared these four on published specs alone: tray dimensions, stated machine compatibility, material and food-safety claims, maximum heat resistance, weight, and cleaning instructions. Size and compatibility did most of the work, because a replacement tray that doesn't fit your machine is useless no matter how good the steel is. Where two trays matched on fit, weight and build feel broke the tie. This ranking is our independent editorial opinion, and no brand paid for placement.
For the three Emeril-oriented trays, yes — the makers specify 300°F for 10 minutes before first use, and warn the pan can deform or bend if you skip it. That's a first-use step only, not something you repeat every time you cook.
All four are listed as dishwasher safe. Each maker also asks that you avoid rough abrasive cloths and metal scouring balls, so use the normal cycle and let a soak do the work on baked-on residue.
The GXF, GWYXC and GWBSXM trays are rated to a maximum heat resistance of 480°F. The SettleDown listing does not state a figure, so I'd keep it within normal air fryer and toaster oven temperatures rather than pushing it to a broil.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer accessories stainless steel, stainless steel air fryer basket, stainless steel air fryer rack