How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a closed-back, isolation-friendly headphone you can wear on a commute, in a noisy room, or at a desk without leaking your music to everyone around you, choose SoundMAGIC P55; if you need an open-back, wide-soundstage headphone for critical listening, composing, or mixing in a quiet space, choose Behringer Alpha Open-Back Hi-Fi.
• SoundMAGIC P55 — biggest strength: a closed-back, on-ear design with 40 mm dynamic drivers, a stainless-steel frame, replaceable cables and memory-foam earcups, which makes it the more practical, portable, isolation-friendly pick.
• SoundMAGIC P55 — biggest trade-off: on-ear fit and closed-back acoustics mean a narrower, more "in your head" soundstage than an open-back design, and the 20 Hz–20 kHz range is the standard hi-fi window rather than an extended one.
• Behringer Alpha Open-Back Hi-Fi — biggest strength: a genuine open-back design with a metal grille and large 50 mm Neodymium drivers covering an extended 10 Hz–28 kHz range, which is exactly the recipe for an airy, spacious, "surround you" presentation.
• Behringer Alpha — biggest trade-off: open-back means almost no isolation and lots of sound leakage, so it's a poor fit for commuting, shared offices, or anywhere you need to keep your audio to yourself.
• Who each pick is for: the P55 suits listeners who want one versatile, durable, closed headphone for home, studio and travel; the Alpha suits musicians, composers and critical listeners who work in quiet rooms and want a wide, natural soundstage.
The P55 is built around a 40 mm full-range dynamic driver, and SoundMAGIC tunes it for what it calls a natural, faithful and expansive sound: tight bass, a rich midrange, and clear highs. The 35-ohm impedance and 20 Hz–20,000 Hz frequency range put it in comfortable, easy-to-drive territory for a phone, laptop or portable player — you don't need a dedicated amp to get it going. In my opinion, the honest way to describe the P55 is "balanced and unfussy" rather than "spectacular." It's the kind of tuning that flatters a wide range of genres instead of exaggerating one.
Who should buy it: anyone who wants one wired headphone that does isolation, voice calls, travel and casual critical listening reasonably well. The closed-back, on-ear design gives you private listening and decent noise isolation, and the memory-foam, faux-leather earpads are built for long sessions. Who should skip it: if your priority is the widest possible soundstage for mixing, or if you dislike on-ear pressure and prefer a fully over-ear cup, the P55's closed, on-ear approach will feel like a compromise. It's a do-everything headphone, not a specialist's tool.
Behringer Alpha Open-Back Hi-Fi: Who It's For
The Alpha is a different animal entirely, and the spec sheet says so immediately. It uses 50 mm Neodymium dynamic drivers with a 10 Hz–28 kHz frequency range — noticeably wider at both ends than the P55 — and the open-back earspeakers sit behind a metal grille. That grille isn't decoration. Letting air move freely behind the driver is what produces the "true sound-stage feel" Behringer describes, and it's why open-back headphones are the default recommendation for people who need to hear spatial placement in a mix. If you've only used closed headphones, the sensation is often described as the music sitting around you rather than inside your head.
Comfort is clearly a priority here. The headband is self-adjusting, so there's no fiddling with a slider to get the fit right, and the ear cushions are described as ultra-soft. The Alpha is an over-ear design, which spreads pressure around the ear rather than pressing on it — a real advantage during the extended sessions that mixing and composing involve. The enclosure mixes ABS, aluminum, faux leather and stainless steel, and the whole thing weighs 1.7 pounds, so it's a substantial, sit-down headphone rather than a lightweight travel pair.
The cable situation is also thoughtfully done: a detachable two-sided audio cable that stretches up to 3 m (9.8 ft), plus a gold-plated 3.5 mm to 6.3 mm threaded adapter. That length and adapter combo is aimed squarely at a desk or studio setup where your source might be an interface or amp a few feet away. A zipper case is included for storage and transport.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for noise isolation and private listening → SoundMAGIC P55. Its closed-back design is the whole point here; the Alpha has effectively none.
• Best for the widest, most spacious soundstage → Behringer Alpha. Open-back grille plus 50 mm drivers is the textbook formula for that airy presentation.
• Best for commuting, travel and shared spaces → SoundMAGIC P55. Closed cups, a hard case, and a smart cable with inline mic and volume make it the more portable, socially polite option.
• Best for mixing, composing and critical listening → Behringer Alpha. Open-back tuning and an extended 10 Hz–28 kHz range are aimed at exactly that job.
• Best for easy amplification → tie, with a nudge to the P55. At 35 ohms it's marginally easier to drive than the Alpha's 32 ohms — honestly, both are low-impedance and friendly to everyday sources.
• Best for long-session comfort → Behringer Alpha. Self-adjusting headband and over-ear cushions distribute weight differently than an on-ear fit.
• Best for durability and repairability → SoundMAGIC P55. Stainless-steel headband, fork and slider, plus a replaceable cable, is a strong long-term combination.
• Best for desk and studio cabling → Behringer Alpha. The 3 m detachable two-sided cable and included 3.5 mm-to-6.3 mm adapter suit a proper listening station.
My Verdict
Yes, in my opinion. The P55's closed-back design isolates you from noise and keeps your music from leaking, while the Alpha's open-back grille does neither. For a train, plane or office, the P55 is the sensible choice.
It does. Letting air move behind the driver is what gives open-back headphones their wide, natural, "sound around you" feel. The Alpha's metal grille and 50 mm drivers are built for that; the P55's closed cups trade some of it away for isolation.
Both are low-impedance — 35 ohms for the P55 and 32 ohms for the Alpha — so either will run from a phone, laptop or portable player. A dedicated amp or interface helps both, but neither strictly requires one.
Decide by where you'll listen, not by specs alone. Noisy, shared or mobile environments point to the SoundMAGIC P55. A quiet desk or studio where you want transparency and a wide stage points to the Behringer Alpha. Check the current price on Amazon for each before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: AMORNO Headphones Over Ear vs Bluedio Headphones Over Ear, Sleep Headphones Sports Headband vs WaveBlend Kids Headphones, Motorola SF600 vs HyperX Cirro Buds Pro: APTX HD Earbuds, trucker bluetooth headset