How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• SOULWIT Earpads — biggest strength: A model-specific fit for a long list of Skullcandy over-ears (Hesh 3/ANC/Evo, Crusher Wireless/540/ANC/Evo, Venue ANC), with protein leather, high-density foam and a printed install guide.
• SOULWIT Earpads — biggest trade-off: It only makes sense if you actually own one of those Skullcandy models; on anything else it's the wrong shape for the job.
• ARTIBETTER 2pcs — biggest strength: Two pads in one pack, memory-foam filling, protein leather, and a small, light 27.22 g build that's easy to store and swap.
• ARTIBETTER 2pcs — biggest trade-off: It's sold as a generic "suitable for headphones" pad with no named compatibility list, so fit is a gamble rather than a guarantee.
• Pick SOULWIT Earpads if you have a specific Skullcandy headphone and want the pad that was modeled for it.
• Pick ARTIBETTER 2pcs if you want a spare pair of soft protein-leather pads for a generic set or a quick refresh without worrying about a specific brand match.
SOULWIT's pitch here is narrow and deliberate. This is a pad engineered around one family of headphones — Skullcandy's Hesh line (3, ANC, Evo), the Crusher line (Wireless, 540, ANC, Evo) and the Venue ANC. That's it. There's no "fits most headphones" language, and that's the point: the pad's shape is modeled to seat correctly on those cups. In my opinion, that specificity is the single most valuable thing here, because a pad that doesn't sit flush ruins both comfort and the seal.
The materials are the classic combo for this job: high-grade protein leather over high-density foam. The claim attached to that build is that the pad "seals around your ears brilliantly," which is what delivers noise isolation. That reasoning holds up — a denser foam and a full leather wrap will block more outside sound than a thin, worn-out original pad, simply because more material is between your ear and the room. If your current pads are cracked, flaking or flattened, you're almost certainly losing bass response and isolation right now.
Installation is handled with an included user guide, and the stated time is about three minutes. That matters more than it sounds: Skullcandy earcup swaps usually involve tucking a lip under a plastic ring, and a guide removes the guesswork.
Who should buy it: anyone with one of the listed Skullcandy models whose pads are worn, flaking or uncomfortable. Who should skip it: anyone with a different brand or model — this pad simply isn't shaped for your cups, and no amount of foam quality fixes a wrong fit. Also skip it if you don't care about brand-matched fit and just want the cheapest generic option.
ARTIBETTER 2pcs: Who It's For
ARTIBETTER takes the opposite approach. This is a two-piece pack of black protein-leather ear pads with a memory-foam filling, described as a replacement for worn or damaged earmuffs rather than a part for a specific headphone. The listing language is general — "suitable for headphones," "easy to mount and detach," "replacement covers" — so you're buying a pad, not a guaranteed match.
The materials are worth noting because they're genuinely the right ones for the job: protein leather on the outside, sponge/memory foam inside, and a "thickened sponge" that the listing frames around comfort and a skin-friendly feel. There's also a noise angle — the high-elastic memory foam is said to help reduce noise and sound. That's a reasonable mechanism: denser, thicker foam absorbs more than a collapsed pad, and leather blocks more than bare foam. Just treat it as a general improvement over a dead pad, not a calibrated tuning change.
The dimensions are given clearly: roughly 3.74 × 2.95 × 0.98 inches, with a total item weight of 27.22 g. That's a small, light pad — the listing leans into that, calling it easy to carry and store. In practice that tells you these are compact, standard-ish oval pads rather than large over-ear cups, so they'll suit smaller headphones and lighter use better than big flagship over-ears.
Installation is described as simple, tool-free mounting and detaching, and the leather is noted as reducing scratches and giving "new life" to tired earphones. There's no compatibility list, no install guide mentioned and no warranty. That's the trade-off in plain terms: you get two pads and a low-stakes way to refresh a headphone, but you accept that fit is on you to figure out.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a guaranteed fit → SOULWIT Earpads. It names the exact Skullcandy models it's made for; ARTIBETTER names none.
• Best for Skullcandy Hesh 3 / ANC / Evo owners → SOULWIT Earpads. This is its core audience.
• Best for Skullcandy Crusher Wireless / 540 / ANC / Evo owners → SOULWIT Earpads. Same story — the pad is modeled for those cups.
• Best for Skullcandy Venue ANC owners → SOULWIT Earpads. It's on the compatibility list too.
• Best for generic or non-Skullcandy headphones → ARTIBETTER 2pcs. A universal pad is the only sensible option when no specific pad exists for your model.
• Best if you want two pads in one pack → ARTIBETTER 2pcs. Two pieces versus SOULWIT's single-pair replacement.
• Best for a lightweight, compact pad → ARTIBETTER 2pcs. 27.22 g and roughly 3.74 × 2.95 × 0.98 inches.
• Best for first-timers who want instructions → SOULWIT Earpads. The included guide and the roughly three-minute install take the risk out of the swap.
If you own a Skullcandy Hesh, Crusher or Venue ANC, I'd buy the SOULWIT Earpads. The reason isn't foam quality or leather grade — both products use protein leather and foam — it's that SOULWIT tells you, by name, which headphones it fits, and a pad that seats properly is the whole game. I'd only reach for the ARTIBETTER 2pcs if my headphone weren't on any compatibility list, or if I wanted a spare pair of soft pads for a generic set and was happy to check the fit myself. Whichever way you lean, check the current price on Amazon before deciding — that's the one variable I can't weigh for you.
FAQ
No. The listing says "suitable for headphones" without naming any model, so it's a general-purpose pad. Check the 3.74 × 2.95 × 0.98 inch size against your cups before buying.
Both use protein leather over foam, so the mechanism is the same. SOULWIT emphasizes a high-density foam and a tight seal; ARTIBETTER emphasizes memory foam that helps reduce noise. Either will beat a flattened, torn pad.
SOULWIT includes a user guide and states roughly three minutes. ARTIBETTER describes simple, tool-free mounting and detaching but doesn't include a guide, so you'll be working it out yourself.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: AILIHEN I35 vs SOULWIT Earpads: Small ON Ear Headphones, Semme 2pcs vs FILFEEL Replacement Earpads, Actpe Earpads vs LYSvvx Solo 3