How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want an ultra-light, open-air earbud with a crisp, natural sound and a compact on-the-go feel, choose Sony MDRE9LP/BLU; if you need a snug, stay-put oval fit with a tangle-resistant cord and a bass-leaning tuning, choose JVC HAF160P. Both are wired 3.5 mm earbuds built for everyday listening, but they solve the same problem in two very different ways — and the "better" one depends entirely on how you wear your buds and what you want to hear.
• Sony MDRE9LP/BLU — biggest strength: an ultra-light, compact open-air design with 13.5 mm neodymium drivers tuned for clear, natural audio and deep bass that still holds up at lower volume settings.
• Sony MDRE9LP/BLU — biggest trade-off: the open-air shape sits loosely in the ear, so it isolates less and can feel less locked-in than a rubber-tipped design during movement.
• JVC HAF160P — biggest strength: a soft rubber oval body that's shaped to fit snugly and stay in place, paired with a bass-boost tuning and a 3.28 ft cord meant to cut down on tangling.
• JVC HAF160P — biggest trade-off: the sound signature leans toward powerful, bass-forward output, which isn't the first pick if you prefer a flatter, more neutral tone.
• Who the Sony is for: listeners who want featherweight comfort, a minimalist blue look, and clear vocals over a heavier low-end.
• Who the JVC is for: listeners who want a secure, grippy fit during commutes, workouts, or errands, plus a cord that stays out of the way.
The Sony MDRE9LP/BLU is the "barely there" option. At 22.68 g it's a genuinely light, compact earbud, and the theme Sony builds it around is portability — this is a pair you drop in a pocket or bag and forget about until you need it. The open-air design is the defining trait: instead of sealing a rubber tip into your ear canal, it rests at the opening of the ear and lets sound in and out. That's what gives it its crisp, realistic character, and it's also why it can render audio in clean, natural tones rather than a thick wall of bass.
Under the hood, the 13.5 mm neodymium dynamic drivers are the reason this little earbud can still push deep bass despite its size. Sony also tunes it so you can enjoy solid sound quality at lower volume settings — useful if you tend to listen quietly at a desk or in a quiet room. The angled 3.5 mm plug adds a bit of strain relief where cables usually fail, and the box includes two sets of silicone earbuds so you can pick the fit that sits most comfortably and securely in your ear.
In my opinion, the Sony is the better pick if comfort and a light, open feel matter more to you than isolation. The 16 ohm impedance and 22,000 Hz frequency response make it easy to drive from a phone, laptop, or basic MP3 player without extra gear. It's also the more subtle-looking of the two, with a minimalist blue finish rather than a bright pop of color.
Who should skip it? If you want your earbuds to block out background noise — a bus engine, office chatter, gym music — the open-air design works against you. And if you need a fit that clamps into place during running or lifting, a loose-sitting bud can shift. For those cases, look at the JVC below.
The JVC HAF160P is built around fit and grip. Its oval earpiece is wrapped in a soft rubber body — the "Gumy" idea — and that shape is designed to sit snugly and stay put in the ear. If you've ever had an earbud pop out mid-walk, this is the design philosophy aimed squarely at that problem. The rubber enclosure is also forgiving against the ear, so longer sessions tend to stay comfortable.
On sound, JVC goes the other direction from Sony: a bass-boost design with a 20,000 Hz frequency response and a stated range down to 15 Hz. That means it leans into thump and low-end presence rather than a neutral, airy presentation. For pop, hip-hop, EDM, and anything that lives on kick drums and basslines, that tuning is a feature, not a flaw. For acoustic and vocal-heavy tracks, it's a matter of taste — some listeners want exactly that warmth, others want the Sony's more open clarity.
The other practical win is the cord. JVC lists a 3.28 ft tangle-free cord, which is a genuinely useful detail if your earbuds live loose in a bag or pocket. It's short enough to avoid a mess of loops but long enough for phone-in-pocket use. The HAF160P also weighs just 5 g, so despite the chunkier rubber body, it disappears in your hand. And the pink Gumy styling is unapologetically loud — you either love that or you don't.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for lightweight, barely-there comfort → Sony MDRE9LP/BLU (22.68 g, ultra-compact build).
• Best for a secure, stay-put fit → JVC HAF160P (soft rubber oval body designed to stay in place).
• Best for a natural, open, crisp sound → Sony MDRE9LP/BLU (open-air design, 13.5 mm neodymium drivers).
• Best for bass-forward, powerful sound → JVC HAF160P (bass-boost tuning, range down to 15 Hz).
• Best for quiet listening at low volume → Sony MDRE9LP/BLU (tuned to sound good at lower settings).
• Best for a cord that won't tangle → JVC HAF160P (3.28 ft tangle-free cord).
• Best for working out or commuting with movement → JVC HAF160P (snug rubber fit holds during motion).
• Best for a subtle, minimalist look → Sony MDRE9LP/BLU (blue, minimalist-contemporary styling).
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the JVC HAF160P for general everyday use. The combination of a snug rubber oval fit, bass-forward sound, and a tangle-free cord makes it the more practical, all-rounder earbud for commuting, errands, and workouts where a bud that stays in place matters most. That said, if your priority is featherweight comfort and a cleaner, more open, natural tone — and you don't need isolation — the Sony MDRE9LP/BLU is the one I'd reach for. Match the fit and sound to how you actually listen, and either will serve you well. Before deciding, it's worth checking the current price on Amazon, since these two often land in different spots value-wise.
FAQ
The JVC HAF160P is the safer bet for movement. Its soft rubber oval body is shaped to fit snugly and stay in place, while the Sony MDRE9LP/BLU sits more loosely thanks to its open-air design.
Neither is a noise-cancelling headphone — both list sound isolation rather than active noise cancellation. The JVC's snug rubber fit will physically seal a little more than the Sony's open-air shape, but don't expect serious blocking from either.
The JVC HAF160P has the edge here because of its short 3.28 ft tangle-free cord. The Sony MDRE9LP/BLU is lighter and more compact, so it disappears easily too — but its cord isn't specifically designed to resist tangling.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.