LP1036 - Land North of Shelf Cricket Ground

Suggested Comments

Below you will find our suggested comments for LP1036 Land North of Shelf Cricket Ground

Please follow our detailed instructions below as they will help you to 'walk through' the commenting process easily.

Please remember that these are our 'suggested comments', you may use them as they are or use them as a basis for your own comments

Before you can comment on the Local Plan you must login to the consultation portal.

Please login to the consultation portal and then return to this window,

leaving the consultation portal window open

Click on the 'Add Comments' link below to open the Local Plan consultation page for LP1036 Land North of Shelf Cricket Ground in a new window.

This means that both windows [our comments page and the consultation portal] will be open at the same time and this will make the 'copy and paste' function between the pages much easier.

You should read the consultation portal page and answer the questions in order. Once you reach the Second Section, you will need to 'copy' the suggested comments below and then go to the consultation portal window and 'paste' into the appropriate box.

First Section Local Plan


The Council ask if you consider the plan to be Legally Compliant?

Our suggested answer for this question is YES

But if you believe that the Local Plan is not legally compliant, you should give details in the box provided

Second Section Local Plan


The Council ask if you consider the plan to be Sound?

Our suggested answer for this question is NO

Comments below will provide details why SNLPF believe the plan is not sound - you can if you wish use these comments

Start of the suggested comments - highlight the comments below and then copy them

These are my comments for site LP1036 - Land North of Shelf Cricket Ground, Shelf


The boundaries of LP1036 have been significantly altered since the Local Plan Draft version 2017 but the Green Belt assessment does not appear to have been updated. This makes it very difficult to make an informed comment on its Green Belt status.

The site is linked to the existing urban area only by its short boundary to the east. Development would result in a narrow strip of housing surrounded by Green Belt on two sides and a sports field on the third. The existing green belt assessment is highly subjective and lacking in competence.


This site needs to be assessed alongside adjacent sites LP1034, LP1035 and LP1037 to which it is linked. Access to LP1036 will have to be through LP1034/1035 onto Soaper Lane which lacks a footway on the south side. Access onto the A6036 via Burned Road (most likely route) uses a dangerous, narrow, winding country lane which is poorly lit as befits a quiet rural lane. Burned Road does not have footways for the majority of its length so is not suitable for the larger traffic volumes generated by this and other linked sites interacting with pedestrians. Widening of Burned Road would require third party land and demolition of dry-stone walls which the Conservation Section has recommended to keep.

Access onto the A6036 will be via narrow, overloaded junctions at Burned Road and Shelf Moor Road. Management of traffic at the Burned Road junction by traffic lights is a ludicrous suggestion. They will be within tens of metres of the existing pedestrian lights at Shelf Pharmacy and about 100 metres away from Shelf Moor road where more traffic lights are proposed through this already overloaded junction, to manage traffic from other proposed allocations.

The local highway network in Northowram & Shelf is already congested but no figures for current or future traffic volumes and congestion have been provided, preventing an informed understanding of future problems, at this site and for the area as a whole.


There is an old Coal Pit and mine tailings recorded on Coal Authority records, this is visible on the ground. The site is also in a ‘Development High Risk’ area as shown on Coal Authority maps. Old mine workings are becoming increasingly evident from the number of ‘sink holes’ developing. This is a great risk to health and safety and also a financial risk for future residents. A full geotechnical survey should be carried out before allocating this site.

Historic Environment:

This site and LP1034, 1035 and 1037 are bounded by dry stone walls which are a characteristic feature of the local environment and Conservation (Heritage) Section has recommended they be retained. These walls would be destroyed by development in order to widen roads and create access points.


The journey times specified in the Council’s assessment are strangely LONGER than those for linked or adjacent sites that are as close to a bus stop e.g. LP1037. This just shows the complete lack of knowledge or consistency in producing these assessments and also that they cannot be relied upon as a measure of sustainability.

Additional Comments:

This site is one of 12 proposed new housing sites in Northowram and Shelf Ward, which would increase the number of houses there by 959. This scale of development will drastically change the nature of our communities and local environment and cause unsustainable pressures on roads and other social infrastructure. Instead the focus of development in Calderdale’s Local Plan should be on the regeneration of brownfield sites in sustainable town centres.

I propose that the land remain as Green Belt.

I have read the suggested comments for this proposed housing site prepared by the Shelf and Northowram Local Plan Forum and agree with them.

End of suggested comments

You can now 'paste' the highlighted text into the box provided in the Local Plan consultation page for LP1036

You can also edit your comments if you wish

Third Section Local Plan


The Council ask if you consider that the Local Plan complies with the Duty to Co-operate?

Our suggested answer for this question is YES

But if you believe that the Local Plan does not comply with the Duty to Co-operate you should give details in the box provided

Now click the 'NEXT' button to continue to the next section

Modifications on the Local Plan


The council ask you to suggest modifications necessary to make the Local Plan sound. You may use the suggested comment below but you can also add your own suggestions

Our suggested modification appears below, you may 'highlight and copy' the text below.


You may now 'paste' the highlighted text into the box provided in the Local Plan for LP1036

You can edit your comments if you wish

Examination of the Local Plan


The council ask if you would like to participate in the oral part of the examination.

Please note that the examination is open to the public and you can attend as a spectator rather than speaking.

If you wish to speak at the examination you must answer YES

to this question and give your reasons in the box provided

You have now reached the end of the questions for site LP1036 Land North of Shelf Cricket Ground.

To submit your comments, click on the SUBMIT button to finish.

Please wait for the confirmation message

Once submitted you can no longer modify your answers but you can add new comments following the process above.