How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a bulk supply of larger, white parchment sheets that cover a full baking tray and last you through months of cookie batches, choose SMARTAKE 200; if you need smaller precut liners sized to drop straight into a typical air fryer basket, choose Generic 100PCS.
• SMARTAKE 200 — biggest strength: 200 sheets at a full 10 x 15 inches, white, with a storage box, so you're set for a long run of oven and tray baking. Trade-off: that larger size can be awkward or wasteful in a small air fryer basket, since you'd be trimming it down.
• Generic 100PCS — biggest strength: 9 x 12 inch precut sheets explicitly pitched as air fryer liners, unbleached, with double-sided silicone coating. Trade-off: half the sheet count (100 vs 200) and a smaller footprint that won't cover a large baking tray edge to edge.
• Who SMARTAKE 200 is for: bakers who work in volume on standard sheet pans and want flat, full-coverage liners in white.
• Who Generic 100PCS is for: air fryer owners who want a grab-and-go liner that fits the basket without scissors.
• Bottom line: both are food-grade, non-stick and rated to 450°F — the real decision is sheet size and count, not performance.
The SMARTAKE 200 is built around one idea: stop fighting the roll. Instead of curling parchment you have to cut and weigh down, you get 200 precut sheets that lie flat on the tray. For anyone who bakes cookies in rounds — a batch in, a batch out, tray after tray — that flat, non-curling behaviour is the whole point. The 10 x 15 inch size is the classic half-sheet-pan footprint, so it covers the surface without gaps at the corners.
The material is natural wood pulp with a silicone-oil coating, which is what gives it the non-stick, waterproof surface. Food lifts off cleanly and keeps its shape, and because the sheet is disposable you just bin it and move on. It's rated up to 450°F, so it handles cookies, bread, meat, pizza and roasting without you thinking about it. Grease and residue stay on the paper instead of baking onto the tray, which is the difference between a quick wipe-down and a scrub session.
Where it makes sense: high-volume oven baking, sheet-pan dinners, anything where you want the liner to match the tray exactly. The rectangular storage box matters more than it sounds — 200 loose sheets are a mess, and a box keeps them flat and accessible.
Generic 100PCS: Who It's For
The Generic 100PCS goes the other direction: smaller sheets, fewer of them, but sized for the appliance that's actually on a lot of counters now. The 9 x 12 inch format is described as fitting most air fryers and baking pans, and that's the sheet's reason for existing. You pull one out, drop it in, cook, and throw it away — no measuring, no trimming, no roll.
Two details stand out in the spec sheet. First, it's unbleached, which is why the paper reads yellow rather than white, and it's described as non-toxic and food-grade. Second, the silicone coating is double-sided, so non-stick works on both faces. Like the SMARTAKE, it's rated to 450°F, and the listed uses go beyond air frying — cookies, cakes, bread, roasted vegetables, oven liners, even wrapping sandwiches and sublimation heat presses.
For air fryer cookies specifically, the size is the advantage. Air fryer baskets are small, and a liner that roughly matches the basket means your dough goes straight onto paper instead of through a wire rack. Cleanup is the payoff: the sheet catches the mess and the basket stays clean, which is the single biggest annoyance with air fryer baking.
Who should skip it: if you bake full sheet pans of cookies, 9 x 12 inches won't cover the tray — you'll get bare edges where dough can spread onto metal. And with 100 sheets versus 200, a heavy baker will go through the pack roughly twice as fast. The yellow, unbleached look is a preference thing; some people like it, some want a bright white liner. In my opinion, this is the air-fryer-first buy, not the sheet-pan buy.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer baskets → Generic 100PCS. The 9 x 12 inch size is aimed at air fryers and small pans, so it drops in without trimming.
• Best for full-size baking trays → SMARTAKE 200. The 10 x 15 inch sheet matches a standard tray, so cookies never touch bare metal at the edges.
• Best for unbleached paper → Generic 100PCS. It's explicitly unbleached, which is why it's yellow rather than white.
• Best for non-stick on both faces → Generic 100PCS. The silicone coating is double-sided; SMARTAKE describes a silicone-oil coated surface.
• Best for storage → SMARTAKE 200. It ships in a rectangular box that keeps 200 sheets flat and out of the way.
• Best for neat edges and uniform size → either. Both are precut with clean-cut edges — that's the shared upgrade over a roll.
• Best for a mixed kitchen (oven + air fryer) → SMARTAKE 200 for trays, Generic 100PCS for the basket. If you can only pick one and you air fry most often, take the Generic.
I'd buy the Generic 100PCS if air fryer cookies are the actual job. The whole point of an air fryer liner is that it fits without fuss, and a 9 x 12 inch precut sheet does that while a 10 x 15 inch one asks you to trim. The unbleached, double-sided non-stick paper and the 450°F rating cover everything you'd throw at it. I'd switch to the SMARTAKE 200 the moment my baking moves to full sheet pans, where the extra coverage and the 200-count box win. Size first, then count — that's the call.
how to air fryer cookies
Line the basket with a precut sheet sized to fit — that's exactly what the 9 x 12 inch Generic sheets are made for. Place the dough on the paper, leaving space between pieces, and cook at your recipe's temperature. Both papers here are rated to 450°F, so normal cookie temperatures are well within range.
how to air fry cookies pillsbury
Refrigerated dough works the same way: cut or break the pieces, space them on a liner, and air fry. Use a sheet that matches your basket so the dough doesn't slump through the rack. Because both products are non-stick, the cookies release cleanly and the basket stays free of baked-on sugar.
how to air fry cookies dough
Homemade dough benefits from a flat liner more than anything, since soft dough spreads as it warms. A precut sheet keeps it contained and stops it gluing to the basket. If your basket is small, the 9 x 12 inch Generic sheet is the closer fit; for a larger basket or tray, go with the 10 x 15 inch SMARTAKE.
how to air fry cookies from frozen
Frozen dough goes straight onto the paper — no thawing needed, and no sticking, thanks to the silicone coating on both products. Add a minute or two versus fresh dough and check early, since air fryers run hot. A liner also means any butter or sugar that escapes lands on the sheet instead of the basket.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Homaisson 200 vs Ciieeo 100pcs: Air Fryer Banana Bread, Generic BBQ Rack Holds vs Ipetboom 100pcs: Air Fryer Ribs, TINMIX Oil Dispenser vs Generic 200: Air Fryer Brush