If you want over-ear headphones for big ears, choose JBL Tune 510; if you need wireless in-ear earbuds for big ears, choose Skullcandy Indy Evo in-Ear. The JBL’s padded on-ear design and up to 40 hours of battery life suit long listening stretches, while Skullcandy offers a compact, cordless fit with a charging case and controls on the earbuds. For big ears, the JBL is the more straightforward pick if you prefer headphones that sit over the ears; the Indy Evo makes more sense if you specifically want earbuds and can find a comfortable tip fit.
• JBL Tune 510: Its padded on-ear cushions, foldable frame, and up to 40 hours of battery life suit extended listening. Its trade-off is that it sits on the ears rather than sealing inside the ear canal.
• Skullcandy Indy Evo in-Ear: True wireless earbuds offer a charging case, stability ear gels, and controls for music and calls. Their trade-off is that comfort and sound depend on finding a snug ear-tip fit.
• Pick JBL if you want a foldable Bluetooth headset with long stated battery life and multi-point connections.
• Pick Skullcandy if you want separate earbuds, a case, and the option to use either bud for calls or an assistant.
• For a gaming headset for big ears, consider which fit you can wear comfortably; neither product’s listed features establish a dedicated gaming headset design.
The JBL Tune 510 is a wireless on-ear headphone with soft, padded cushions and a lightweight, foldable design. That combination is useful if you want a headphone you can put on for a long commute, a work session, or a day of music, then fold down for carrying. The product information lists a weight of 159 g, so this is a portable headphone rather than a bulky over-ear set. Its cushions sit on the ears, though, not around them. That distinction matters to anyone searching for over ear headphones for big ears: “over-ear” is often used loosely, but the Tune 510 is specifically described as on-ear.
Battery life is a clear strength on paper. JBL lists up to 40 hours, plus a quick-charge feature that provides two hours of listening after five minutes of charging. It uses USB-C for charging, and the listed charging time is two hours. For someone who would rather charge less often than manage a small case, that long single-charge figure is appealing. Bluetooth multipoint is another practical detail: the headphones can connect to two Bluetooth devices and switch between them, which may suit a person moving between a phone and another device. The stated Bluetooth range is 10 meters.
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-19 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
JBL highlights Pure Bass sound, and its listed frequency range is 20 Hz to 20 kHz. Push-button media controls keep common playback adjustments on the headphones. There is no listed noise control, so don’t choose this model expecting a noise-cancelling feature.
Who should skip it: Skip the Tune 510 if you want earbuds, a listed noise-control feature, or a product whose data sheet clearly specifies a microphone.
The Indy Evo is a true wireless in-ear set with a charging case. Its small separate earbuds are a different proposition from JBL’s headband and ear cushions: they sit in the ear canals, with stability ear gels intended to help keep them in place. The sheet calls out workout, travel, school, work, and gaming among possible uses, but fit remains personal. It specifically warns that mismatched tips or improper wear can affect sound and call performance. That is worth taking seriously for big ears: the earbuds may be more compact to carry, but the right tip fit—not earcup space—is the comfort question.
Skullcandy lists 30 hours of total charge, split between six hours in the earbuds and 24 hours in the case. It also lists rapid charging that gives two hours of play from a 10-minute charge. Those figures describe a different routine from JBL’s 40 hours in the headphones: Indy Evo’s earbuds need to return to the case to draw on the case’s charge. That can be convenient between listening sessions, while the separate case is one more item to keep track of. Tile technology is included to help locate either earbud through the Tile app, a useful feature if small pieces of audio gear tend to disappear around a bag or home.
The controls support music, calls, assistant activation, and EQ-mode switching. Either bud can take calls or activate an assistant, so you can use one at a time if that better suits the moment. The sheet describes sound isolation and lists a frequency range of 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz. It does not specify active noise cancellation, so sound isolation should not be read as a promise of electronic noise cancelling. The listed Bluetooth range is 10 meters, and the product includes a one-year manufacturer warranty.
Who should skip it: Skip the Indy Evo if you dislike in-ear tips, cannot get a snug fit, or want the long single-charge battery figure listed for JBL.
• Best for a long stretch without returning to a case → JBL Tune 510. Its listed battery life is up to 40 hours on the headphones themselves.
• Best if you want earbuds that pack into a case → Skullcandy Indy Evo. It is a true wireless in-ear design with a charging case.
• Best for switching between two connected Bluetooth devices → JBL Tune 510. Multi-point connections are specifically listed.
• Best for taking calls with one earbud at a time → Skullcandy Indy Evo. The product sheet says either bud can handle calls or activate an assistant.
• Best if you want to fold your headphones for carrying → JBL Tune 510. Its lightweight design folds, and its listed weight is 159 g.
• Best if you want a way to help locate a misplaced earbud → Skullcandy Indy Evo. Tile technology is included for tracking either bud through the app.
• Best for shoppers considering over ear headphones for big ears → JBL Tune 510, if on-ear cushions suit you. It avoids choosing in-ear tips, but its cushions rest on the ears rather than enclosing them.
• Best for a workout-oriented in-ear option → Skullcandy Indy Evo. Workouts are among its listed uses, and stability ear gels are part of its design; a secure fit still depends on the tips.
I would choose the JBL Tune 510 for big ears if I wanted a headband-style option, long listed battery life, and easy switching between two Bluetooth devices. Its on-ear cushions are not the same as roomy earcups that surround the ears, so I would keep that fit distinction in mind. I’d choose Skullcandy instead if compact earbuds, single-bud calls, and Tile tracking mattered more. For my big-ears use case, JBL is the more practical pick when I prefer not to rely on in-ear tip fit.
The central question in this comparison is not simply which product has more listed battery time. It is whether you want a headband and cushions or two small earbuds. JBL gives you up to 40 hours in one headphone charge; Skullcandy lists 30 hours total across the buds and case. Those numbers describe different setups, so consider how you listen. If you wear headphones for long blocks, a single-charge figure may be easier to plan around. If you listen in shorter sessions and keep a case nearby, the earbud arrangement may suit your routine.
Fit deserves equal weight, particularly if you’re shopping for big ears. The Tune 510’s cushions rest on the ears, which avoids ear-tip sizing but may not feel like an enclosing over-ear design. The Indy Evo’s fit depends on the ear tips and stability gels; Skullcandy says that poor fit can affect sound and call performance. Neither format is automatically comfortable for everyone. Think about whether you prefer pressure from a headband and cushions or a snug in-ear seal.
Calls are another point to check before deciding. Skullcandy explicitly lists a microphone-related use through calls and says either bud can take calls. The JBL sheet does not specify a microphone, even though its push-button controls handle media. If your search is for with mic headphones for big ears, don’t assume the JBL will meet that need based on its general headphone design. Confirm the call features you need before choosing.
Finally, don’t treat sound isolation and noise control as interchangeable claims. Skullcandy lists sound isolation, while JBL lists no noise control. Neither sheet specifies active noise cancellation. JBL emphasizes Pure Bass sound; Skullcandy describes bass and treble and includes EQ-mode switching. Those are useful clues about their feature sets, but they do not establish which one will sound better to every listener. If the current price matters to your decision, check the latest price on Amazon rather than relying on an outdated figure.
For someone who wants to avoid in-ear tips, JBL is the more direct choice: it has padded on-ear cushions. It does sit on the ears rather than around them, so shoppers seeking roomy over-ear cups should note that distinction.
The Indy Evo’s features include calls, and either earbud can handle a call or activate an assistant. The JBL Tune 510 data provided here does not specify a microphone.
JBL lists up to 40 hours for the Tune 510. Skullcandy lists 30 hours total for the Indy Evo, divided into six hours in the buds and 24 hours in the case.
Neither product’s listed features specify active noise cancellation. Skullcandy lists sound isolation, while JBL lists no noise control, so don’t interpret either description as a confirmed active noise-cancelling feature.
• Turtle Beach Recon 70 vs Skullcandy SLYR Pro
• KLIM Nomad Wood vs Arafuna CD Player: Portable Headphones
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.