We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want longer battery life, a wired backup option, and a more travel-friendly fold, choose Skullcandy Cassette; if you need JBL's Pure Bass tuning and a simple one-button remote for calls, choose JBL Tune 500BT.
• Skullcandy Cassette — biggest strength: up to 22 hours of playback plus Rapid Charge (10 minutes gets you roughly 3 hours), and an included 3.5mm AUX cable so you can keep listening wired when the battery runs down.
• Skullcandy Cassette — biggest trade-off: plastic enclosure and on-ear cushions mean it isolates sound passively rather than actively — no noise cancellation here, just sound isolation.
• JBL Tune 500BT — biggest strength: JBL's Pure Bass sound signature and a dead-simple one-button remote with microphone for hands-free calls.
• JBL Tune 500BT — biggest trade-off: shorter rated battery life (up to 16 hours, 2-hour charge) and no headphone jack at all, so it's wireless-only.
• Pick the Skullcandy Cassette if battery runtime, wired fallback, and a collapsible travel design matter most to you.
• Pick the JBL Tune 500BT if you want bass-forward sound and the simplest possible call control, and you're fine charging more often.
The Cassette is built around stamina. Skullcandy rates it at up to 22 hours of battery life, and the Rapid Charge feature tops you up with about 3 hours of listening from a 10-minute charge. That combination is genuinely useful if you're the kind of person who grabs headphones on the way out the door and forgets to plug them in the night before. A full charge takes about 1.5 hours via Bluetooth 5.0.
The physical design is aimed at daily commuting and travel. It's an on-ear model with a lightweight, ultra-durable headband and plush cushions that pivot in every direction — a small detail that matters more than it sounds, because pivoting cups tend to sit more evenly on different head shapes. The earcups collapse, which makes the whole thing easier to shove into a bag, and the earpiece shape is circular with a plastic enclosure in black. Driver size is 40mm with a 20Hz–20,000Hz frequency range and 30-ohm impedance. Controls are push-button: answer or reject calls, adjust volume, skip or repeat tracks. Bluetooth range is listed at 10 meters.
Who should buy it: commuters, students, and frequent travelers who want long runtime, a foldable frame, and the insurance of a 3.5mm cable for wired listening. It also comes with a Skullcandy warranty, which adds a bit of peace of mind for a daily-use product.
Who should skip it: anyone who wants active noise cancellation, or who dislikes on-ear pressure and prefers the deeper seal of over-ear cups. And if bass is your single priority, the Cassette's spec sheet doesn't advertise a bass-boosted tuning the way JBL does — it's a straightforward dynamic driver design.
The Tune 500BT leans on one thing above all: JBL's Pure Bass sound. If you listen to a lot of hip-hop, EDM, or anything where low-end punch is the point, that tuning is the reason to look here. It's still a 20Hz–20,000Hz dynamic driver setup, so the range is the same on paper as the Cassette — the difference is in how JBL voices it, not in the numbers.
Battery life is rated up to 16 hours, with a recharge in as little as 2 hours. That's not bad, but it's meaningfully less than the Cassette's 22-hour figure, and there's no rapid-charge claim attached. The bigger structural difference: the Tune 500BT has no headphone jack. It's wireless-only over Bluetooth, with a listed range of 10 meters. The Bluetooth version on the sheet is 4, versus Bluetooth 5.0 on the Cassette.
Comfort and portability are handled with a lightweight, foldable design, and the earcups are on-ear with a rounded shape and a plastic enclosure in black. Call handling is deliberately minimal — a one-button remote with microphone, plus volume control. That simplicity is either a feature or a limitation depending on how you use headphones. There's also a bundled LED flashlight keychain in the box, which is an odd but harmless extra.
Who should buy it: listeners who want bass-forward sound, want the simplest possible call button, and don't care about a wired option. It's a reasonable pick for casual wireless listening at a desk or around the house.
Who should skip it: anyone who wants a wired fallback, longer battery runtime, or a newer Bluetooth version. If you've ever had headphones die mid-flight with no cable in your bag, the missing jack will bother you.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for battery life → Skullcandy Cassette. Up to 22 hours versus up to 16 hours on the JBL.
• Best for bass-forward sound → JBL Tune 500BT. Pure Bass is JBL's headline feature here.
• Best for wired listening → Skullcandy Cassette. It includes a 3.5mm AUX cable; the JBL Tune 500BT has no headphone jack at all.
• Best for the simplest call control → JBL Tune 500BT. A single-button remote with microphone is about as uncomplicated as it gets.
• Best for newer wireless tech → Skullcandy Cassette. Bluetooth 5.0 versus Bluetooth 4 on the JBL.
• Best for folding travel convenience → both, roughly. Each has a foldable, lightweight design, so this one's close to a wash.
• Best for a bundled extra → JBL Tune 500BT, if you happen to want an LED flashlight keychain in the box.
One thing worth flagging: the Cassette's sheet lists a couple of conflicting warranty lines, and the JBL's warranty is described only generically as a manufacturer warranty. If warranty length matters to you, verify the current terms on the product page before buying. Same goes for price — neither of these is a fixed number, so check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
In my opinion, the Skullcandy Cassette is the smarter buy for most people. The 22-hour battery, the Rapid Charge top-up, the Bluetooth 5.0 connection, and — most importantly — the included 3.5mm cable give you more ways to keep listening without stopping to charge. The JBL Tune 500BT is the better pick only if bass-forward sound and a one-button remote are your top priorities and you're comfortable going wireless-only. If you truly can't stand the idea of a dead headphone with no cable option, that alone settles it: go Skullcandy.
FAQ
Wipe the plastic enclosure and headband with a slightly damp, soft cloth, and use a dry cloth or soft brush on the cushions to lift dust and skin oils. Don't soak the earpads or submerge the headphones, since both models have electronics inside. For the cushions, gentle blotting beats scrubbing.
If you mean folding them for storage, both the Skullcandy Cassette and the JBL Tune 500BT have foldable designs — collapse the earcups inward toward the headband so they pack flat. If you mean physically opening the housing to repair them, that isn't a user-serviceable task on either model and risks voiding the warranty.
Neither of these has active noise cancellation. Both list sound isolation instead, which is passive blocking from the cushions pressing against your ears. On-ear designs generally isolate less than over-ear cups, so expect to still hear some surrounding noise on a bus or plane.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: JBL Tune 500BT vs ONANOFF Made: Best Selling Headphones, ZIHNIC Headphones Over-Ear vs TOMASHI Cassette Player Tape, JBL Tune 520C vs Yealink UH44: Wired Headphones