How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-19 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• SIUDANGKA 4's biggest strength: Four identical Teflon liners cut to a 12.5 x 8.5-inch footprint for the CHEFMAN 12Qt, rated up to 500°F, and BPA-, PFOA-, lead- and cadmium-free.
• SIUDANGKA 4's biggest trade-off: It's a liner-only set — no crumb tray, no pan, no hardware — and the fit is aimed at one specific CHEFMAN model line.
• brikinte 4's biggest strength: It bundles a replacement crumb tray pan with four matching Teflon pads, so you're restoring the tray and protecting it at the same time.
• brikinte 4's biggest trade-off: Lower heat ceiling. The pads top out at 480°F and the brand itself recommends staying under 450°F, so high-heat roasting is off the table.
• Who SIUDANGKA 4 is for: CHEFMAN 12Qt owners who want a stack of identical, high-heat liners for everyday drip-catching and easy cleanup.
• Who brikinte 4 is for: Ninja DT201 or DT251 owners whose crumb tray is worn, stained, or missing, and who want liners plus a fresh tray in one box.
This is a liner set built around one job: keeping the floor of a CHEFMAN 12Qt air fryer clean. You get four mats, each one 12.5 x 8.5 inches, cut to sit inside that specific 12-quart cavity. The material is Teflon-based and the brand states it's free of BPA, PFOA, lead and cadmium — the kind of detail that matters if you're cooking directly on the mat rather than just using it as a drip catcher.
The heat rating is the standout spec here. SIUDANGKA lists a maximum of 500°F, which is genuinely useful headroom in an air fryer that runs hot and circulates air aggressively. That said, the brand is upfront about the safety rules: keep the mat away from direct contact with heating elements or open flames, and if your oven has concealed elements, set the liner on the lowest rack or tray. Follow that and you're using it the way it was designed.
Who should skip it: If you own a Ninja DT201 or DT251, this isn't your fit — the dimensions and the intent are both aimed at CHEFMAN. And if what you actually need is a replacement crumb tray rather than a liner, this set won't solve that problem. It's liners only, four of them, nothing else in the box. Also note the item weight is listed at 0.06 kg, so these are thin, flexible mats — not rigid trays. Set expectations accordingly.
brikinte 4: Who It's For
brikinte takes a different angle: it's a two-part kit. You get a brand-new replacement crumb tray pan plus four matching black Teflon cleaning pads sized for the Ninja DT201 and DT251 countertop air fry ovens. The stated purpose of the pads is to sit on top of the crumb tray, protect it, and extend how long it lasts.
The material is PTFE with a special surface coating, BPA-free, PFOA-free and nonstick. The brand notes these are produced in batches on an assembly line, which is a small but reassuring nod toward consistency if you're buying more than one set.
The heat limit is where brikinte is more conservative than SIUDANGKA, and the brand is refreshingly blunt about it. The pads cannot exceed 480°F, and brikinte actually recommends keeping them below 450°F. That's a real constraint, not fine print. If you do a lot of high-heat roasting — think crispy wings, charred vegetables, anything pushing past 450°F — you'll want to pull the liners out for those cooks or accept that they're not the right tool for that job. The warning is printed in the listing for a reason.
Who should buy it: Ninja DT201 or DT251 owners dealing with a grimy, scratched or missing crumb tray. That's the core scenario this set is built for. The tray is the headline item; the four pads are the bonus that keeps the new tray from getting wrecked. It's also a sensible pick if you want a single purchase that resets the bottom of your oven rather than just layering a mat over a tray you already dislike.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for high-heat cooking → SIUDANGKA 4. 500°F versus brikinte's 480°F ceiling and 450°F recommended working limit.
• Best if your crumb tray is damaged or missing → brikinte 4. It's the only one of the two that includes a replacement tray pan.
• Best for CHEFMAN 12Qt owners → SIUDANGKA 4. Sized at 12.5 x 8.5 inches for that specific cavity.
• Best for Ninja DT201 / DT251 owners → brikinte 4. Built around those models.
• Best for getting four usable liners → SIUDANGKA 4. Four identical mats, nothing else in the box.
• Best for liner-plus-tray value in one order → brikinte 4. One purchase covers protection and replacement.
• Best for multi-use beyond the air fryer → SIUDANGKA 4. The brand explicitly lists BBQ grill mat, baking mat and pan liner as alternate uses.
• Best if you want a thicker, more substantial item → brikinte 4. Listed at 1.52 pounds for the set versus 0.06 kg for SIUDANGKA's mats.
• Best if you already own the right tray and just want protection → SIUDANGKA 4. No redundant hardware.
In my opinion, the deciding factor here isn't quality — it's which appliance is sitting on your counter. If you own a CHEFMAN 12Qt, I'd buy the SIUDANGKA 4. The 500°F rating gives you room to cook the way an air fryer is meant to be used, four identical mats means you're never stuck waiting on one to dry, and the fit is cut for your machine. If you own a Ninja DT201 or DT251 and your crumb tray is the problem, I'd buy brikinte 4 — the replacement tray is something SIUDANGKA simply doesn't offer, and the lower heat ceiling is a fair trade for getting a fresh tray and four protective pads together. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your oven before you commit.
FAQ
No — it's designed to fit the CHEFMAN 12Qt air fryer, including the ExacTemp 12 Quart 5-in-1. The 12.5 x 8.5-inch size is cut for that cavity. For Ninja DT201 or DT251, look at brikinte 4 instead.
No. SIUDANGKA 4 is four liners only — no tray, no pan. brikinte 4 is the set that includes a replacement crumb tray pan alongside its four Teflon pads.
Yes. SIUDANGKA states its Teflon liners are BPA-free, PFOA-free, lead-free and cadmium-free. brikinte states its PTFE pads are BPA-free and PFOA-free with a nonstick surface coating.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.