How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• SIUDANGKA 125Pcs — biggest strength: 125 disposable, unbleached parchment liners cut to fit specific Ninja baskets, so cleaning drops to "lift the paper out and toss it."
• SIUDANGKA 125Pcs — biggest trade-off: It's a consumable. You use one per cook, the liners need food weight to stay pressed down, and they're sized for Ninja AF101 / AF150 / AF161 baskets rather than every air fryer on the market.
• GWY Air Fryer Rack — biggest strength: A two-piece stainless steel stacking system that lets you cook on two levels at once, with airflow designed for 360° circulation and no mid-cook flipping.
• GWY Air Fryer Rack — biggest trade-off: It's permanent cookware you have to wash. It also takes up vertical space, and the roughly 7.8-inch footprint means you must measure your basket before buying.
• Who each pick is for: SIUDANGKA for Ninja owners who hate scrubbing and cook small-to-medium portions often. GWY for anyone who wants to stop cooking in batches and doesn't mind a rinse-and-dishwasher routine.
The SIUDANGKA 125Pcs is a box of 125 round parchment liners, each about 7.9 inches across, made from raw wood pulp that's unbleached and free of fluorescent agents and BPA. The coating is food-grade silicone oil, and the whole thing is rated heat resistant up to 450°F / 230°C. In practice, that means you drop a liner into the basket, cook, lift it out, and your basket stays essentially clean underneath.
What makes this one worth a look rather than any random pack of parchment is the compatibility claim. SIUDANGKA says these are custom-cut for the original Ninja basket shape and specifically lists the Ninja AF101 4qt, the AF150 5.5qt XL, and the AF161 5.5qt Max XL. If you own one of those three machines, you're not trimming circles out of a roll or fighting a liner that curls up the sides. That fit is the whole point.
The brand also makes a fair argument about why paper beats the alternatives: perforated parchment lets crumbs fall through into the basket anyway, and silicone liners still have to be washed — you've just moved the cleaning from the basket to the liner. Disposable paper actually eliminates the task.
Buy it if you own a Ninja AF101, AF150 or AF161, you cook several times a week, and the scrubbing is what stops you from using the air fryer. Skip it if you own a different brand and size of air fryer, or if you want an accessory you buy once and keep forever.
GWY Air Fryer Rack: Who It's For
The GWY Air Fryer Rack is the opposite philosophy entirely. It's a set of two stainless steel wire racks — a main rack around 7.8 inches square and a skewer rack roughly 7.8 by 2.75 inches — that stack into a double-layer configuration inside your basket. Instead of removing cleanup, it multiplies capacity.
The material is food-grade stainless steel, non-toxic, tasteless, BPA-free, and the brand states it meets FDA standards. It's also dishwasher safe, which matters more than it sounds: the racks are described as firm, resistant to deforming, and non-stick enough that soaked-on food comes off after a quick soak. The one cleaning caveat in the specs is to avoid rough abrasive cloths or metal scrubbers, which would scratch the finish.
The design feature I find most interesting is the airflow engineering. The basket-style rack is built so hot air circulates a full 360° around the food, which the brand says produces more even cooking without burning — and, notably, without needing to flip anything midway. You set temperature and time for whatever you're cooking and leave it alone. For anyone who's stood over an air fryer turning chicken wings at the eight-minute mark, that's a genuinely appealing pitch.
Use cases are broad: chicken, bacon, fish, wings, meatballs, vegetables, potatoes, cookies, cakes. It can double as a grill basket for fruit or vegetables, or even as a stand for tableware and cups. Compatibility is wide too — Nuwave 7.25 and 8 QT, Ninja 4QT and 5.5QT, Cosori 5QT, Instant 4QT and 6QT, Power XL 5QT, plus other air fryers.
The trade-offs are real, though. This is a fixed-size piece of metal, so the roughly 7.8-inch footprint has to physically fit your basket — the brand itself tells you to measure the inside diameter before ordering. It also adds height, so you need vertical clearance. And unlike paper, it doesn't remove cleaning; it just makes it easier.
Buy it if you regularly cook for two or more people, you're tired of making wings in three rounds, and you want one purchase that lasts. Skip it if your basket is small or oddly shaped, or if your only goal is never washing anything.
• Best for zero-effort cleanup → SIUDANGKA 125Pcs. Lift the liner out, throw it away, done. No soaking, no dishwasher space used.
• Best for cooking more food at once → GWY Air Fryer Rack. Two stacked levels turn one basket into two, which is the single biggest practical difference between these two products.
• Best for Ninja AF101 / AF150 / AF161 owners → SIUDANGKA 125Pcs. The liners are cut specifically for those three baskets, so fit is a non-issue.
• Best for mixed-brand households → GWY Air Fryer Rack. The rack lists compatibility across Nuwave, Ninja, Cosori, Instant, Power XL and more.
• Best for long-term value → GWY Air Fryer Rack. One stainless steel set you wash and reuse, versus a 125-count supply you'll eventually run out of.
• Best for delicate or light foods → GWY Air Fryer Rack. The liners need food weight to stay pressed down, so a metal rack handles light items more predictably.
• Best for greasy, crumb-heavy foods → SIUDANGKA 125Pcs. Bacon, breaded items, anything that drips — the liner catches it all and leaves with it.
• Best for no-flip cooking → GWY Air Fryer Rack. The airflow design is built around even circulation so you don't have to interrupt cooking to turn food.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the GWY Air Fryer Rack — but only because of how I cook. In my opinion, the ability to stack two levels and stop cooking wings in shifts is worth more than the convenience of throwing paper away, and a stainless steel rack is a one-time purchase instead of a recurring one. That said, if you own a Ninja AF101, AF150 or AF161 and your real frustration is scrubbing the basket after every meal, I'd go with SIUDANGKA 125Pcs instead. The honest answer is that these aren't competitors — they solve different problems, and plenty of people would reasonably own both. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, and measure your basket if you're leaning toward the rack.
FAQ
Yes. The brand states it's dishwasher safe and that it resists deforming, so it holds up to regular washing. Just avoid rough abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls, which the specs specifically warn against.
Only if you own a Ninja AF101 4qt, AF150 5.5qt XL, or AF161 5.5qt Max XL — those are the models the liners are custom-cut for. The round liners are about 7.9 inches across, so measure your basket if you have anything else.
No, and this matters. The liners need to be pressed down by enough food, you should never use one in a bare preheated basket, and you must keep the temperature under 450°F / 230°C. Follow those three rules and they behave fine.
That's the design intent. The airflow construction is meant to circulate heat 360° around the food so it cooks evenly without burning and without flipping. Adjust temperature and time for what you're cooking, and the brand says you can leave it alone.
They're different kinds of value. The rack is a reusable purchase you wash; the liners are a 125-count supply you use one at a time and eventually replace. If you want to spend once, go metal. If you want the least effort per cook, go paper.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Comicfs Round Cooling Rack vs KICHOUSE 100pcs: Air Fryer, air fryer rack square, air fryer oven rack