How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 5 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a stainless steel mesh basket-and-tray set that lets air circulate fully around your food for crispier results, choose SettleDown Stainless Steel Air; if you need a genuine Cuisinart replacement baking pan / drip tray to restore a worn or missing tray in a specific Cuisinart air fryer toaster oven, choose Cuisinart Replacement Baking Pan/Drip.
• SettleDown's biggest strength: a two-piece set — a stainless steel tray plus an elevated mesh basket — that's built for 360° circulation heating and is dishwasher safe.
• SettleDown's biggest trade-off: it's an aftermarket accessory, and it only lists compatibility with the Cuisinart TOA-60 and TOA-65.
• Cuisinart's biggest strength: it's a genuine Cuisinart replacement part that fits a wider spread of models (AFR-25, AFR-25TG, TOA-28, TOA-28BPQVC, TOA-28EBHSN, CTOAF-50BJ).
• Cuisinart's biggest trade-off: it's a single flat tray, so it catches drips and supports baking but doesn't add the raised mesh airflow design.
• Choose SettleDown if you own a TOA-60 or TOA-65 and want better air circulation and easy cleanup.
• Choose Cuisinart if you own one of the listed models and simply need to replace a lost, worn, or damaged tray.
The SettleDown set is really two pieces working together: a stainless steel baking tray pan and an air fryer basket. The tray sits in the oven, and the basket is elevated with a mesh design so heat can move around the food from every angle. That 360° circulation is the whole point — instead of food sitting flat on a solid surface and steaming on the bottom, air gets underneath it too. In my view, that's the feature that matters most if you're chasing crispy results without burning the outside.
It's made from food-grade stainless steel with a fine polishing finish, and SettleDown describes it as non-toxic, tasteless, and high-temperature resistant — meaning no chemical off-gassing when you bake hot. That's a reasonable thing to care about if you cook at high heat often. It's also corrosion-resistant and dishwasher safe, which is a genuine convenience for anyone who hates scrubbing baked-on grease by hand. The set measures 12.5"L x 10.98"W x 0.78"H and weighs about 0.79 kg.
Who should buy it: owners of a Cuisinart TOA-60 or TOA-65 who want a mesh basket for airflow plus a solid tray underneath, and who value dishwasher cleanup. Who should skip it: anyone whose oven isn't a TOA-60 or TOA-65 — check your model first — and anyone who genuinely just needs one flat replacement tray, because this is a two-piece set, not a single pan.
This one is exactly what the name says: a genuine Cuisinart replacement baking pan and drip tray. It's a single flat tray designed to slide into compatible Cuisinart air fryer toaster ovens to catch grease, crumbs, and drippings while you cook. Use it as a baking pan, a drip tray, or a grease tray — it does triple duty across air frying, roasting, broiling, and baking.
The real selling point is fit and authenticity. It's an original Cuisinart part (model AFR-25DT), and it lists compatibility with a wider range of ovens than the SettleDown set: AFR-25, AFR-25TG, TOA-28, TOA-28BPQVC, TOA-28EBHSN, and CTOAF-50BJ. If your model is on that list, you get a tray that's designed to sit securely inside it. It's built from stainless steel with a smooth surface that wipes clean easily, and Cuisinart positions it as the fix for a lost, worn, or damaged tray so the appliance keeps performing like new.
Who should buy it: anyone with one of those listed models who's missing a tray or whose original has seen better days. It's the low-drama, correct-fit choice. Who should skip it: TOA-60 and TOA-65 owners, since those models aren't on this compatibility list — and anyone specifically wanting a raised mesh basket for airflow, because this is a flat tray.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for airflow and crispiness → SettleDown. The elevated mesh basket circulates heat 360° around food; the Cuisinart tray is solid and flat.
• Best for a genuine, correct-fit replacement → Cuisinart. It's an original Cuisinart part made for its listed models.
• Best for AFR-25 and TOA-28 family owners → Cuisinart. It covers AFR-25, AFR-25TG, TOA-28, TOA-28BPQVC, TOA-28EBHSN, and CTOAF-50BJ.
• Best for easy cleanup → SettleDown. It's explicitly dishwasher safe; the Cuisinart tray has a smooth surface that's easy to wipe but isn't listed as dishwasher safe in the specs.
• Best for catching grease and drippings → Cuisinart. That's its core job, and it does it as a dedicated drip tray.
• Best for a two-piece cooking setup → SettleDown. You get both a tray and a basket in one set.
• Best for the simplest single-tray fix → Cuisinart. One tray, one job, no extra pieces.
If I owned a Cuisinart TOA-60 or TOA-65, I'd buy the SettleDown Stainless Steel Air. The two-piece tray-and-mesh-basket design is the more useful cooking tool — the raised mesh genuinely changes how air moves around your food, and the dishwasher-safe stainless steel makes cleanup something you won't dread. If I owned an AFR-25 or a TOA-28-family oven, though, I'd go the other way and buy the Cuisinart Replacement Baking Pan/Drip, because a correct-fit original part beats a better design that doesn't fit your machine. Match the model number first, then choose.
See also: Deedro Stainless Steel Baking vs Reynolds Kitchens Air Fryer, Whole Foods Market vs DOITOOL Stainless Steel Air, PRIJESSE Air Fryer Dual vs Bella Pro Stainless Steel 9-qt, MKGDDS Air Fryer Basket vs VAIZIQ Stainless Steel Vertical
Only if you have a TOA-60 or TOA-65. Those are the two models it lists. If you own anything else, check your model number before buying, because it isn't listed as fitting other ovens.
The Cuisinart Replacement Baking Pan/Drip. It lists six compatible models (AFR-25, AFR-25TG, TOA-28, TOA-28BPQVC, TOA-28EBHSN, CTOAF-50BJ), while the SettleDown set lists two.
It's a flat drip and baking tray, so its main job is catching grease and crumbs, not boosting airflow. For crispiness, the SettleDown's elevated mesh basket is the design that specifically targets even air circulation.
Start with your oven's model number. If it's a TOA-60 or TOA-65, I'd lean SettleDown for the airflow and dishwasher-safe cleanup. If it's on Cuisinart's listed models, go with the genuine Cuisinart tray for a guaranteed fit. You can check the current price on Amazon before deciding.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.