How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-27 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Samudgate Mini — biggest strength: it weighs next to nothing (0.18 oz / 17 g) and clips onto the ear instead of entering the canal, so there's no plugging pressure at all and you stay fully aware of traffic, gym noise and people talking to you.
• Samudgate Mini — biggest trade-off: it's a single earbud with 5 hours of playtime and no charging case in the box, so it's a one-ear, one-session device rather than an all-day pair.
• Defunc True Basic — biggest strength: a complete package — two buds, a charging case, 22 hours of total playtime, Bluetooth 6.0, quad microphones and a companion app with AI voice features.
• Defunc True Basic — biggest trade-off: the semi-in-ear MultiTip design sits closer to the canal than a clip-on, and at 50 g for the product (35 g of that the case) it's a bulkier thing to carry than a single featherweight bud.
• Who each is for: Samudgate Mini suits runners, cyclists and anyone who wants one ear free at all times; Defunc True Basic suits commuters, remote workers and everyday listeners who want a normal pair of buds plus smart extras.
The Samudgate Mini is built around one idea: get sound into your ear without blocking it. The clip-on ear design leaves the canal open, which means you hear your music, podcast or film while still registering the world around you. For a runner on a shared path, a cyclist in traffic or someone working in a busy open office, that awareness isn't a gimmick — it's the whole reason to pick this thing over a sealed bud.
The second thing that stands out is the weight. At 0.18 oz with soft silicone and flexible earhooks, this is designed to disappear on your ear during movement. Because nothing is jammed into the canal, there's no swelling or soreness after a long session — the kind of discomfort that makes people give up on earbuds entirely. It's also left/right universal, so you can wear it on whichever ear you prefer and swap sides whenever you like.
Who should skip it? If you want stereo sound in both ears, a charging case to top up during the day, or app-based features, this isn't that product. It's a deliberately minimal, one-ear, open design — and it's excellent at exactly that job.
Defunc True Basic: Who It's For
Defunc True Basic is the more conventional product, and it's conventional in a good way. You get a matched pair of semi-in-ear buds using Defunc's patented MultiTip design with soft silicone ear wings. The open-fit approach keeps you aware of your surroundings — same philosophy as the Samudgate — but the wings add stability so the buds stay put without clamping down on your ear. Designed in Sweden with a clean, lightweight look, it's aimed at commuting, walking, working and general daily listening rather than a single sport.
The spec list is where it pulls ahead on paper. Bluetooth 6.0 promises faster pairing, lower latency and a more reliable connection than the older 5.0 standard. There are four microphones — two per earbud — for voice pickup on calls. Total playtime is rated at 22 hours with the charging case, and the case itself is a compact 7 × 3.5 × 2.5 cm at 35 g. The buds use 13 mm bass drivers with 16 ohm impedance, and passive noise cancellation is handled by the physical fit rather than electronics.
Then there's the Defunc AI App. It adds an OpenAI-powered Chat AI voice assistant for hands-free questions, translation, brainstorming and content creation, with multiple voice modes. Whether you'll actually use that is a personal call, but it's a genuinely unusual feature at this tier and it's controlled through the app rather than by tapping the buds.
Touch controls handle playback, and the connection range is listed at 10 meters. IPX4 keeps sweat and splashes from being a problem. Who should skip it? Anyone who specifically wants a single open earbud, hates app pairing, or wants the absolute lightest possible thing on their head. This is a two-bud system, and it behaves like one.
• Best for running and cycling safety → Samudgate Mini. The clip-on open design plus 0.18 oz weight is purpose-built for movement with full environmental awareness.
• Best for all-day listening → Defunc True Basic. 22 hours with the case versus 5 hours on a single bud is not close.
• Best for call and voice quality → Defunc True Basic. Four microphones (two per bud) versus a single built-in mic.
• Best for the latest wireless standard → Defunc True Basic. Bluetooth 6.0 against Bluetooth 5.0.
• Best for a stereo experience → Defunc True Basic. It's a pair; the Samudgate Mini is a single left/right-universal earbud.
• Best for minimalist, case-free carry → Samudgate Mini. One tiny bud, no case to remember.
• Best for extra features and tinkering → Defunc True Basic. The Defunc AI App with its AI assistant is the differentiator here.
• Best for comfort if you hate things in your ear → Samudgate Mini. Nothing enters the canal at all.
If I had to pick one for most people, I'd buy the Defunc True Basic. In my opinion, two buds, a charging case, 22 hours of playtime, Bluetooth 6.0, four microphones and an app with real added functionality make it the more complete product for commuting, working and everyday listening — and the silicone ear wings mean the open-fit comfort doesn't cost you stability. The Samudgate Mini is the better choice only if your priority is a single, featherweight, clip-on bud for sport and you actively don't want a case or a second earbud. Buy for your actual routine, not the longer spec sheet.
FAQ
Both are IPX4 and both use an open design, so sweat and awareness aren't the deciding factors. The Samudgate Mini wins on weight and the clip-on fit; the Defunc True Basic wins on stability from the silicone wings and on having a case to carry. For pure single-ear running, I'd lean Samudgate Mini.
The Samudgate Mini is rated at 5 hours of normal use with 60 hours of standby from a 50 mAh battery, and charges in about 1.5 hours. The Defunc True Basic is rated at 22 hours of total playtime with the charging case.
Defunc True Basic. The Samudgate Mini is a single earbud (left/right universal), so if stereo listening matters, the Defunc pair is the only option here.
Both listings change over time, so check the latest price on Amazon using the button on this page rather than relying on any figure quoted elsewhere.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Ti Cow TICOWTEK vs Togetface OpenEarRing Open Ear, Puro Sound Labs vs Candy Bila USB C Kids, Yeabomy Open Ear Clip vs WIVTAK Open Ear Headphones, Botesty Sound Headphones vs JBL Tune 530: Wired Headphones