We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-18 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a first-party replacement case that keeps official Galaxy Buds3 Pro pairing behaviour, choose Samsung Charging Case; if you need a budget replacement case to revive a pair of AirPods 4th Gen earbuds that lost their original case, choose Yitonglian Charger Case Replacement.
• Samsung Charging Case — biggest strength: It's the genuine Samsung case built specifically for the Galaxy Buds3 Pro, with one-touch pairing via the button on the bottom of the case.
• Samsung Charging Case — biggest trade-off: It only works with the Galaxy Buds3 Pro, and earbuds are not included — you're buying the case alone.
• Yitonglian Charger Case Replacement — biggest strength: A 450mAh battery that the maker says delivers up to 3 extra full charges and a 30-minute top-up to 100%, plus a clear LED power indicator.
• Yitonglian Charger Case Replacement — biggest trade-off: It fits only AirPods 4th Gen (models A3053/A3050/A3054/A3056/A3055/A3057) and will not work with 1st, 2nd, Pro or 3rd generation AirPods.
• Who each is for: The Samsung case is for Galaxy Buds3 Pro owners who want the official part; the Yitonglian case is for AirPods 4th Gen owners replacing a lost or dead case without paying for a first-party one.
This is the official Samsung charging case for the Galaxy Buds3 Pro, sold on its own with earbuds not included. That last point matters more than anything else on the sheet: if you already own Buds3 Pro and you've lost or damaged the case, this is the correct replacement. If you don't own the earbuds, this product is not for you, because there's nothing to put inside it.
The pairing story is the reason to go first-party. Open the case and the Buds3 Pro pair to your Galaxy device; if they don't connect automatically, you press and hold the button on the bottom of the case for three seconds. That's the same behaviour Samsung designed into the original case, and it's the kind of thing a third-party shell can't fully replicate. The case itself is a hard polycarbonate shell in Silver, measuring 2.32 x 1.92 x 0.96 inches and weighing 47.06 g. In other words, it's small and pocket-friendly — roughly the footprint of a small stack of coins.
On charging, the listing describes both wired and wireless charging and includes a USB-C cable. That combination is useful in daily life: drop it on a wireless pad on your desk, or plug in USB-C on a trip when there's no pad around. It's a hard shell, so it protects the earbuds in a bag better than a soft pouch would.
Who should buy it? Galaxy Buds3 Pro owners who want the genuine part, care about the standard pairing flow, and are fine with a one-ecosystem accessory. Who should skip it? Anyone with AirPods, anyone with different Galaxy Buds generations, and anyone who doesn't already own Buds3 Pro earbuds. Also skip it if you want an extended battery bank for your earbuds — nothing on the sheet suggests this case does anything beyond charging and pairing the Buds3 Pro it was made for. It carries a 1-year manufacturer warranty, which is worth noting because third-party cases typically don't.
The Yitonglian case is a replacement charging case for the AirPods 4th Generation, sold without earbuds. The compatibility list is specific and you should check it before buying: it fits models A3053, A3050, A3054, A3056, A3055 and A3057. It is explicitly not compatible with 1st, 2nd, Pro or 3rd generation models. That's the single most important thing on the sheet — get the generation wrong and the case is useless to you.
Where this case earns its place is battery capacity. Yitonglian rates the built-in battery at 450mAh, says it provides up to 3 additional full charges for your earbuds, and says it can bring the earbuds to 100% in about 30 minutes. The case itself fully recharges in roughly 2.5 hours. For someone who listens through a long commute, a workday or a flight, that combination is the whole point of carrying a case at all.
Two practical touches stand out. First, one-touch Bluetooth pairing: press the button and your phone recognises the case and shows its battery status, so you're not guessing whether the case is alive. Second, an LED power indicator that shows remaining capacity at a glance — genuinely handy, because the most common failure of a replacement case is that you can't tell how much charge is left until your earbuds die.
The shell is hard plastic in White, which matches the usual AirPods look. Note what's absent from the sheet: there's no mention of wireless charging, no stated dimensions, no weight and no warranty. So if wireless charging matters to you, don't assume it's there. Who should buy it? AirPods 4th Gen owners whose original case is lost, damaged or holding almost no charge, and who want a straightforward, affordable replacement. Who should skip it? Anyone with any other AirPods generation, and anyone who specifically needs a wireless-charging case.
• Best for Buds3 Pro owners → Samsung Charging Case. It's the official part for that exact model, and compatibility is guaranteed by design.
• Best for AirPods 4th Gen owners → Yitonglian Charger Case Replacement. It's built for those specific model numbers, and it's the only one of the two that fits them.
• Best for battery life → Yitonglian Charger Case Replacement. A 450mAh battery, up to 3 extra full charges, and a claimed 30-minute top-up to 100%.
• Best for charging flexibility → Samsung Charging Case. Wired and wireless charging plus a USB-C cable in the box; the Yitonglian sheet only describes USB-C charging.
• Best for knowing your power level → Yitonglian Charger Case Replacement. Its LED indicator shows remaining capacity at a glance.
• Best for a genuine, warranty-backed part → Samsung Charging Case. Samsung is the manufacturer and the case carries a 1-year manufacturer warranty.
• Best for a no-fuss pairing button → either. Samsung uses a 3-second press on the bottom button; Yitonglian uses a single button press to wake Bluetooth pairing.
• Best for buyers who want to spend less → that's a judgment call about budget, so check the current price on Amazon for both before deciding — I won't guess at numbers here.
In my opinion, the right pick depends entirely on which earbuds you own, and there's no overlap: these two cases are not interchangeable. If you have Galaxy Buds3 Pro, I'd buy the Samsung Charging Case — it's the official part, it pairs the way Samsung intended, it does wired and wireless charging, and it comes with a 1-year manufacturer warranty. If you have AirPods 4th Gen, I'd buy the Yitonglian Charger Case Replacement — the 450mAh battery, the 30-minute top-up and the LED indicator make it a sensible way to get a dead pair of earbuds back in rotation. Buy the one that matches your earbuds' model number. That's the whole decision.
No. The sheet lists its compatible device as the Samsung Galaxy Buds 3 Pro only. It's a first-party case for that specific model, and it will not fit or pair with AirPods of any generation.
No. Yitonglian states it fits only AirPods 4th Generation models A3053, A3050, A3054, A3056, A3055 and A3057, and is not compatible with 1st, 2nd, Pro or 3rd generation models.
Neither one. The Samsung case is listed as charging case only with earbuds not included, and the Yitonglian case is described as a charging case without earbuds. Both are replacements for a case you already need.
Only Yitonglian publishes a figure: about 30 minutes to reach 100%, with the case itself recharging in roughly 2.5 hours and providing up to 3 additional full charges. Samsung's sheet doesn't state charging times, so there's nothing to compare on that point.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.